The Difference Between Redemption and Atonement

And why it is important.

Redemption is a common trope in fiction. We talk of characters who did bad things who get “redemption arcs” and eventually come to be seen as better people through that redemption.

Unfortunately, redemption in the real world is much more complicated than spending a couple of episodes doing good things or making a single heroic sacrifice. To redeem yourself in the eyes of someone you’ve wronged takes a lot of effort and action on your part, and you need to prove that you have changed as a person.

However, part of redemption is getting the forgiveness of the person you’ve wronged. This is not always realistic; there may be nothing substantial that you can do to prove your redemption, and the person you have wronged has no obligation to actually forgive you.

This is where an important distinction needs to be made: the difference between redemption and atonement.

As I’ve described above, redemption is the seeking of forgiveness from one’s victim. Both parties need to take part in redemption, and without that, redemption is impossible.

On the other hand, atonement is seeking to improve things for the benefit of everyone without the requirement for forgiveness. Atonement does not require the person you’ve wronged to forgive you, as it is about improving yourself in reaction to the wrongs you’ve perpetrated on others. In short, if you’ve wronged someone and are trying to change yourself for the better without the need for forgiveness, that is atonement.

Atonement sometimes leads to redemption but doesn’t require it. When performed earnestly and honestly, atonement is a selfless action — you recognize the flaws in yourself and seek to change them regardless of the approval of any other party.

On the other hand, seeking redemption can be (but isn’t always) a selfish action, particularly if you’re doing it to seek the status quo. Plenty of abusers seek redemption from their victims, only to backslide into the problematic behaviors once forgiveness is granted. This is a common manipulation technique and can be used to keep victims trapped in the abuser’s web.

That doesn’t mean that redemption is a selfish action by nature. You can earnestly seek redemption with the absolute intent of being a better person; you can also earn redemption through atonement as an unintended but positive consequence of your actions.

Additionally, I don’t necessarily think one is better than the other per se. Honestly seeking redemption can be an unqualified good thing, while using atonement as deception or manipulation is clearly a bad thing.

That said, if you’ve wronged someone, be aware of their feelings when you choose to seek redemption or atonement. It’s perfectly reasonable to seek and want redemption and forgiveness, but remember that they have no obligation to forgive you.

On the other hand, seeking atonement needs to be done with no expectations from the wronged party. Trying to “atone” when you’re actually seeking their forgiveness will likely lead to disappointment on the part of everyone.

Everyone I have ever met has said or done something to wrong someone else. It is part of being human, I think, in a very fundamental way; nobody says the exact right thing all the time, and whether intentional or not, we all do things to hurt others at some point in our lives.

The defining factor is what you do once you’ve realized that you wronged someone. You should decide whether to seek redemption or atonement, but in most cases, honestly attempting to seek either is a good sign. It shows that you have a desire for growth and self-improvement.

On the other hand, sometimes the party you have “wronged” is actually the one at fault. Abusers and manipulators often use a false sense of offense as a means to separate their victims from potential helpers and will react strongly to potential challenges. In those cases, you may have nothing to apologize for, even though you have “wronged” someone, and redemption or atonement is unnecessary or even the wrong course of action.

Regardless, it is generally good to seek personal growth, and redemption and atonement are avenues for that. Realizing that you’ve messed up and that you need to improve is a good sign and tends to reflect well on you as a person.

Just don’t go around intentionally offending people so you can score redemption points. Who even does that?

If you liked this, please subscribe to my publication, Thing a Day. I publish something every day on a variety of topics, so you never know what you’re going to see!

Here are some other things I’ve written: