avatarAnastasia Frugaard

Summary

The author reflects on the diverse and passionate reactions from readers to their Medium articles about America, revealing insights into cultural attitudes, political beliefs, and the complex nature of national identity.

Abstract

The author's experience with Medium comments over two years has been a mix of frustration and joy, with a majority of feedback being positive and informative. However, some comments have been critical, ranging from objections to the use of "America" instead of "United States of America" to assertions that the U.S. is the best country in the world and that critics should leave if they are unhappy. The author also encountered claims that socialism and communism are inherently bad, misconceptions about tax rates in Denmark, and personal attacks on the author's Danish husband for his views. The diversity of the U.S. is cited as a reason why generalizations about the country are difficult, and the author's problems are attributed to living in California. Suggestions to move to the countryside and comparisons of cost of living across states are also discussed. The author acknowledges their white privilege but faces accusations of racism, despite the lack of a specific reason. The author expresses gratitude to both supporters and critics, noting the complexity of America and the challenges of writing about it.

Opinions

  • Some readers are particular about referring to the country as the "United States of America" rather than "America."
  • There is a strong belief among some commenters that the United States is superior to "socialist Europe."
  • Critics of the U.S. are sometimes told to leave the country rather than voice their concerns.
  • The idea of leaving America is suggested as a solution to dissatisfaction with the country.
  • Socialism and communism are viewed negatively, with free healthcare being equated with socialism and seen as detrimental.
  • Misinformation exists about the tax burden in Denmark, with one commenter incorrectly stating that Danes pay 70% of their salaries in taxes.
  • The author's spouse, being Danish, is criticized for his perspective on American society.
  • Some argue that America's size makes it incomparable to smaller countries and precludes it from having similar social systems.
  • The diversity within the U.S. is used to challenge the author's observations about the country.
  • California is singled out as the source of the author's issues, with the suggestion that life would improve by moving to a rural area.
  • Cost of living varies significantly across the U.S., as exemplified by the price difference of bread in Los Angeles versus Tennessee.
  • The author's complaints are dismissed by some due to perceived white privilege.
  • The author faces unsubstantiated accusations of racism.
  • Despite the polarized feedback, the author appreci

What I Learned About America, And Myself, From My Medium Comments

It’s complicated

Photo by Monika Kozub on Unsplash

What would I do without my readers? They brought me so much frustration and joy over the past two years on Medium that I feel like embracing them all in one big virtual hug.

Most comments I have received were positive and informative, but some were less enthusiastic, and others left me wondering: why bother commenting at all?

Here are a few things I learned from responses to my Medium stories.

1. I shouldn’t say “America”

First of all, it’s the United States of America, the U.S., or the States. It turns out that saying “America” upsets some people.

2. America is the best country in the world

Sorry, the United States of America. Whatever you call it, it’s much better than “socialist Europe.”

3. If one doesn’t like anything about America, one should leave

The U.S., it seems, is not very good at taking feedback. This one might just be what’s wrong with our country: telling critics to leave is hardly solving the problem.

4. Hence, we should leave America

The verdict is in: I should leave the U.S. Now, can I have some money and a UK visa, please?

5. Socialism is bad

Free healthcare is basically socialism. And socialism is bad. Don’t I know about Venezuela?

6. Communism is very bad

Socialism is one step away from communism — the ultimate enemy of the U.S.

7. People in Denmark pay 70% of their salaries to taxes

They don’t. My husband paid 40%. In return, he enjoyed more (free) benefits than Americans will ever see if their lifetime.

8. My Danish husband is annoying

How dare he point out the (obvious) inadequacies of “the best country in the world?” He’s just a socialist.

9. You can’t compare America to any other country because it’s bigger

The U.S. is much bigger than Denmark, and all of Europe, so we can’t possibly have a people-centered government and free healthcare.

10. I can’t say anything at all about America because things are totally different in Alabama

The U.S. is so big and diverse that I can’t possibly judge it by the fifty or so places I visited or lived in. How can I, for example, say we’re not a collective-good-based society if someone in rural Alabama might have a different experience?

11. All my problems exist because we live in California

I wrote a separate piece on how all my problems, apparently, can be solved by just leaving California.

12. Things would improve drastically if we moved to the countryside

I even had a dream last night about visiting one of such places recommended to me by a reader. I might just consider it.

13. The same bread that costs $8 in LA is $2.50 in Tennessee

I wrote in one of my pieces about a store in LA selling Dave’s Bread for eight dollars. Only to find out from my reader it’s two-fifty in Tennessee.

14. I have white privilege

I was told that I shouldn’t complain about bread prices since I have white privilege. Fair enough. But someone should still complain.

15. And, of course, I’m a racist

No real reason given, just some angry rambling about privileged white people.

I didn’t realize just how complicated America, and writing about it, could be until I (accidentally) started my column on Medium.

To my loyal supporters, I say thank you for your time from all my heart.

To my haters, I say: thank you for the money I make every time you read my work.

Travel
Politics
Life
Life Lessons
Self Improvement
Recommended from ReadMedium