avatarStephenie Magister ✨

Summary

The article suggests watching "All Dogs Go to Heaven" for fans of "The Good Place," drawing parallels in themes of kindness, friendship, and love, and reflecting on the personal significance of the film.

Abstract

The piece recommends the animated movie "All Dogs Go to Heaven" to those who enjoyed "The Good Place," highlighting its thematic resonance with the television series. It recounts the plot of the film, which follows a German Shepherd named Charlie B. Barkin on a quest for revenge that evolves into a journey of self-discovery about the true meaning of kindness, friendship, and love. The author shares a personal connection to the movie, reminiscing about its impact during childhood and its significance in the context of their own life experiences. Despite its initial box office underperformance compared to "The Little Mermaid," the film found enduring success through home video releases. The article also touches on the movie's sequels and the recasting of the main character with Charlie Sheen in later installments, as well as other notable voice actor replacements in animated films.

Opinions

  • The author expresses a strong personal attachment to the movie "All Dogs Go to Heaven," equating it to revisiting cherished childhood memories.
  • There is a sentiment of nostalgia for the era when Disney was not yet the entertainment giant it is today, with "The Little Mermaid" marking the beginning of its resurgence.
  • The article conveys a sense of disappointment in the film's initial box office performance but celebrates its subsequent home video success and lasting legacy.
  • The author has a poignant connection to the character Anne-Marie, advising caution when researching the actress's background out of respect for her tragic story.
  • There is an appreciation for the strategic recasting of iconic voice roles, such as Charlie Sheen stepping in for Burt Reynolds and Dan Castellaneta replacing Robin Williams as the Genie in "Aladdin."

Watch This Movie If You Loved The Good Place

All movies go to heaven

Photos by Naomi Hébert, Alvan Nee, Richard Brutyo, Marek Szturc, charlesdeluvio, Amy Humphries, and Andre Tan

Did you like The Good Place?

I loved The Good Place. It was must-see TV for me.

Recently, I’ve been revisiting animated movies from my childhood. They help me remember all the things I made myself forget. Some of those things are good.

One of them is the movie All Dogs Go to Heaven from director Don Bluth.

Promotional poster for All Dogs Go to Heaven (United Artists/MGM/UA)

“[All Dogs Go to Heaven] tells the story of Charlie B. Barkin (voiced by Burt Reynolds), a German Shepherd that is murdered by his former friend, Carface Carruthers (voiced by Vic Tayback, in his penultimate film role), but withdraws from his place in Heaven to return to Earth, where his best friend, Itchy Itchiford (voiced by Dom DeLuise), still lives, in order to take revenge on Carface, but ends up befriending a young orphan girl named Anne-Marie (voiced by Judith Barsi in her final film role; posthumously). In the process, Charlie learns an important lesson about kindness, friendship and love.” — Wikipedia Summary

The film became a monster of a hit once it was released on VHS, but before then? I was too young to appreciate it at the time, but United Artists released this in direct competition with The Little Mermaid.

I mean…Disney wasn’t the juggernaut back then that it is now. It was mostly due to The Little Mermaid that the company survived and thrived and entered the Disney Renaissance that history will ultimately record as the moment that could have saved us. If only one of us had intervened.

But did anyone really think this was a good idea? The movie lost that war handily and tanked until it found an enduring fanbase on VHS (especially with six-year-old me).

It’s kind of surreal to watch this movie again. The main character is a dog named Charlie. My brother hasn’t used that name in a long, long, long time, but when we were kids? It was one of my names for him. In some ways, it always will be. I relate to the other main character Anne-Marie most. I watched this movie thinking I’d get a happy ending with my own Charlie.

(don’t look up anything about the actress who played Anne-Marie unless you’re ready to pray there really is a heaven for such a sweet child)

The movie spawned several sequels and even a TV series, though it must be noted that Burt Reynolds declined to reprise the role of Charlie in future films. Instead, they brought in the big guns.

When Robin Williams declined to reprise his role from Aladdin for The Return of Jafar and the tv series, they brought in the voice of Homer from the Simpsons. It would take a miracle to one up that kind of recasting.

Photo by Larry Crayton and Isaac Quesada

All Dogs Go to Heaven made it look easy. To replace Burt Reynolds, they brought in no less than Charlie Sheen.

Screenshot from All Dogs Go to Heaven 2 (MGM/UA Family Entertainment)
Dogs
Pets
Movies
HBO
Religion
Recommended from ReadMedium