avatarThe Good Men Project

Summary

The article critically examines the appeal of Donald Trump to his supporters, questioning their support for a leader characterized by lies, incompetence, and authoritarian tendencies, and warns of the dangers his presidency poses to democracy and freedom.

Abstract

The author, Warren Blumenfeld, presents a scathing critique of Donald Trump's presidency and his followers, raising concerns about the former president's character, business acumen, and political leadership. Blumenfeld challenges Trump's supporters to acknowledge the contradiction between their pursuit of personal freedom and their allegiance to an authoritarian figure. He draws parallels between the rise of Trump and historical fascist regimes, emphasizing the role of the "authoritarian personality" in supporting such leaders. The article suggests that Trump's promises of restoring a mythical past and providing security come at the cost of relinquishing freedom and critical thinking. Blumenfeld also reflects on the importance of an educated electorate for democracy and criticizes Trump's enablers within the Republican Party and among his supporters for undermining democratic institutions and the country's global standing.

Opinions

  • Trump is portrayed as a self-serving, incompetent leader with severe personality flaws and a propensity for lying.
  • The author questions the logic of Trump's supporters who prioritize perceived personal freedom and security over democratic principles and critical examination of their leader.
  • Blumenfeld equates Trump's leadership style with authoritarianism, citing historical research on the conditions that lead to the rise of fascist regimes.
  • The article implies that Trump's followers exhibit traits of the "authoritarian personality," susceptible to extremism and anti-democratic beliefs.
  • Trump's presidency is seen as a threat to the rule of law, constitutional governance, and the United States' international reputation.
  • The author criticizes Trump's enablers, including Republican leaders, for their complicity in the erosion of democratic norms and institutions.
  • Blumenfeld emphasizes the importance of an informed and responsible electorate in maintaining a healthy democracy.
  • The article suggests that Trump's repeated lies and deceptions have been normalized by his supporters, who are called to recognize the harm they cause to the country and their own integrity.

Trump Spews Greatest Hits of Lies and His Authoritarian Personality Minions Lap It Up

Why would you even consider supporting and voting for Trump?

Photo credit: iStock

By Warren Blumenfeld

To Donald Trump’s MAGA minions, I ask a tripartite question:

Do you know, and do you care, and do you care to know?

In other words, do you really know, care, and care to know Donald Trump’s actual character: that he only cares about himself and his self-interests while caring little about the concerns and needs of the people of the country he once was elected to serve and protect?

Do you know, care, and care to know of his incompetence in business and in politics, and that he is a scam artist who hasn’t any glimmer of understanding anything even approaching the art of any deal?

Do you know, care, and care to know of his severe personality flaws and narcissism rendering him literally incapable of functioning as an effective President of the United States? Rather, this man (dis)functions as an exceedingly dangerous force in undermining our standing around the world and bringing us to the point of rupture in our constitutional form of government.

And if you know this, those of you who are apparently so concerned with maintaining and expanding your “personal freedom” and “liberty,” why would you even consider supporting and voting for Trump? By doing so, you have essentially relinquished your personal freedom and your liberty as the cost for admission to his personality cult and some intangible promised security.

As someone who has studied World War II and the Holocaust virtually all of my life, I have struggled to comprehend how authoritarian leaders gain ascendancy in presumably liberal democracies built on guiding principles of freedom and the rule of law.

Authoritarianism as a form of government is characterized by strong central power and limited political freedoms. These regimes may be either autocratic (concentrated in the hands of one person) or oligarchic (small number of powerful, often rich people) and may be based upon the rule of a party or the military.

Influential political scientist Juan José Linz defined authoritarianism as composed of four qualities:

  1. Limited political pluralism with severe constraints on the legislature, political parties, and interest groups.
  2. Political legitimacy based on appeals to emotion and identification of the regime as a necessary evil to combat “easily recognizable societal problems, such as underdevelopment or insurgency.”
  3. Minimal political mobilization and suppression of anti-regime activities.
  4. Ill-defined executive powers, often vague and shifting, which extends the power of the executive.

During the late 1940s, researchers, led by Theodor W. Adorno, studied the historical conditions that paved the way for the rise of fascist regimes in the 1930s, World War II, and the Holocaust. They theorized about individuals who supported the growth of fascist regimes.

They suggested that people of a certain personality type, which they labeled the “authoritarian personality,” were most ripe for extremism, in this case, those most susceptible to anti-Jewish prejudice and anti-democratic political beliefs.

These individuals suspended their autonomy and critical thinking facilities, and they pledged obedience, allegiance, and freedom to a powerful leader or social institution for the promise of going back to a future reminiscent of a (mythic) idealistic past of economic, political, social, cultural, and personal security, where their “ingroup” won and led, and “outgroups” served obediently and acquiesced to “ingroup” needs and demands.

In other words, they surrender their freedom for the promise of social and personal security, which usually includes suppressing and even oppressing those outside the circle, the “others.”

Now enters the would-be mighty authoritarian strongman, Donald John Trump.

After painting a gruesome image of a post-apocalyptic U.S.-America, replete with vicious marauding gangs, gunshots whizzing throughout inner cities, decrepit crumbling structures and highways, rampant poverty, declining health care systems, imminent terrorist attacks, ruthless criminal-drug-dealing-rapist invaders from our southern border.

After inciting violence at his rallies, leading to the deadly insurrection by his fascist militia at the Capitol on January 6, 2021 and his second impeachment, and fear, stereotyping and scapegoating all Muslims and so-called “illegal aliens,” after promising to punish women who had and their doctors who performed abortions, after asserting that he will reestablish the Supreme Court to an ultra-conservative majority, and after promising to reverse both Roe v. Wade and marriage equality, and most importantly, after promising to “Make America Great Again,” Heir Donald non-so-solemnly proclaimed during his meandering diatribe in 2016 at the Republican National Convention:

I am your voice! I alone can fix it. I will restore law and order.

Trump never asked anything of his supporters other than their total loyalty to follow by placing their complete faith in him. And the authoritarian personalities followed brown-shirted in lockstep.

Trump had his followers wax nostalgic to the television shows from many of their youth: “Father Knows Best,” “The Donna Reed Show,” “Ozzy and Harriet,” “Leave it to Beaver,” “The Brady Bunch,” “Happy Days,” and “Full House,” all reflecting the mainstream popular image of the U.S.-American family as white, middle class, with a nice home in the suburbs, and with all family members accepting their assigned raced and gendered scripts.

Democracy, though, demands an educated electorate. Democracy demands responsibility on the part of the electorate to critically examine their politicians and the issues of the day so they can make truly informed decisions. Democracy demands us never to relinquish our freedom and authority for some promise of a comfortable security by returning to a fairytale past.

Those peaceful bygone days where lovely children played in beautifully landscaped yards within lily-white neighborhoods surrounded by rainbows above and unicorns strolling down the freshly cleansed sidewalks never existed except in the mind of the cult believers.

Round Three

“If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it.”

Joseph Goebbels, Nazi Reich Minister of Propaganda

“Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities.”

Voltaire

Now Trump wishes to invade the Oval Office again.

He shot his latest salvo of democracy-killing lies and deceptions at a supposed TV “townhall” on CNN, Wednesday night, May 10, 2023, hosted by reporter Katlin Collins. But this was no regular town hall since the audience members came directly from central casting of MAGA world to bow to their cult leader.

Though Collins tried to constrain the twice impeached failed former president by calling out his continual stream of lies and dehumanizing characterizations of Trump’s critics and attacks upon herself, Collins was simply no match for the would-be dictator and his minions.

Though Trump has been convicted of sexual harassment, is under investigation for conspiring to lead a coup to remain in power, to abscond with classified documents, to change the outcome of the electoral vote in Georgia, and to submit false tax forms in New York State and to the Internal Revenue Service, his minions kept cheering on their deranged leader.

Though he would not address whether he wished Ukraine or Russia to win the deadly incursion by Russia against its neighbor, stated that if reelected he would continue to separate children from their migrant parents, would support a national ban on abortion, and he doubled downed on his contention that it is both normal and natural for men to grab women’s genital “which has been going on for the past one million years,” even though the oldest fossil remains of homo sapiens date back only to approximately 300,000 years, but since Trump was never very interested in history and facts, his minions kept cheering on their deranged leader.

We have long known that Donald Trump is a liar and a racist neo-nationalist. Republican leaders and their supporters who don’t speak out are enablers and are themselves co-conspirators!

“Enabler” is the term given to those who fail to act to help abusers. “Passive bystander” or “bad Samaritan” is the name for people who are conscious of bad actions developing around them but fail to intervene.

Enabling and passively standing by take many forms, including literally offering an addict substances or conspiring with an abuser in a sinister plot, contributing to the denial of addicts and aggressors by asserting that they don’t have a problem, to downplaying the seriousness and making excuses for their behaviors, translating for others what the person “really meant,” downright lying, and so on.

I often wonder how Trump enablers can sleep at night and get back up in the morning still willing to degrade and prostrate themselves by attacking our democratic institutions and seriously dismantling our country’s standing in the world.

Each time anyone enables an abusive action, they keep perpetrators and themselves further from the truth and from help, and they diminish themselves and their integrity more than just a bit.

I have been stuck time and time again by Trump’s lies and deceptions throughout the past post-factual seven years since he first announced his campaign for the presidency, through the transition following his election, his four years in the White House, and his constant promotion of the Big Lie that led to an attempted coup, and now in his newest campaign

He continues to spread his lies, his verifiable lies, big and small.

So questions remain:

How long will it take for Trump’s supporters to finally realize they have been duped by this con-artist who sold them his snake-oil-of-a-campaign-and-presidency of little value, which can have disastrous consequences?

How much longer can Trump’s enablers, and passive and active supporters understand that they are hurting the country and sacrificing their own integrity and sense of dignity for the mere promise of a few shiny coins of glittering gold and the hot glow of fleeting power?

When voters relinquish their freedom for some sort of promised security, we are left with nothing at all.

Read more from The Good Men Project on Medium:

The story was previously published on The Good Men Project.

About Warren Blumenfeld

Dr. Warren J. Blumenfeld is author of God, Guns, Capitalism, and Hypermasculinity: Commentaries on the Culture of Firearms in the United States(Peter Lang Publishers), The What, the So What, and the Now What of Social Justice Education (Peter Lang Publishers), Warren’s Words: Smart Commentary on Social Justice (Purple Press); editor of Homophobia: How We All Pay the Price (Beacon Press), and co-editor of Readings for Diversity and Social Justice (Routledge) and Investigating Christian Privilege and Religious Oppression in the United States (Sense), and co-author of Looking at Gay and Lesbian Life (Beacon Press).

Politics
Social Justice
Equality
Voting
Freedom
Recommended from ReadMedium