avatarPaul Myers MBA

Summary

The article discusses the importance of balance in leader-follower relationships, emphasizing the role of trust and honesty in effective leadership.

Abstract

The article "The Balance of the Leader-Follower Relationship" explores the dynamics of leadership and the crucial role that followers play in maintaining a healthy power equilibrium. It argues that while various leadership qualities such as diplomacy, courage, consistency, fairness, and firmness are valuable, their effectiveness is context-dependent. Overreliance on these traits can lead to their transformation into vices, such as rigidity, recklessness, or brutality. The piece highlights that as leaders gain power, they may become detached from reality and overly confident in their abilities, risking their strengths being overshadowed by their flaws. Dynamic leaders are acknowledged for their ability to inspire action, but it is the followers who serve as gatekeepers, ensuring the responsible use of a leader's power. The article underscores the importance of trust and honesty as the foundational elements of workplace relations and the need for leaders to foster an environment where feedback is not only welcomed but actively encouraged to prevent the "king's disease" of losing touch with reality.

Opinions

  • Leadership qualities, while beneficial, can become detrimental if misapplied or overused.
  • Leaders may become disconnected from their followers as they acquire more power, which can magnify their character flaws.
  • Followers are crucial in balancing a leader's power and preventing excessive behavior.
  • Trust and honesty are identified as the key values that nurture workplace relations and must be upheld by leaders.
  • Leaders should actively create a culture that invites and values follower feedback to avoid making mistakes and to keep themselves grounded.
  • There is a significant risk that a large majority of followers may not challenge a leader's perspective, even when they disagree, which is seen as a flaw in leadership dynamics.

The Balance of the Leader-Follower Relationship

Two human values that hold the key to enhance work relations

Photo by You X Ventures on Unsplash

Different leadership qualities are needed to be productive in different situations. Qualities like diplomacy, courage, consistency, fairness, and firmness. All useful virtues indeed, but they have a place and time.

Any virtue misused, deployed in the wrong situation or with the wrong intent can become a vice. For instance, consistency becomes rigidity, courage leads to recklessness and firmness can morph into brutality.

As leaders acquire power, traits, behaviours, and qualities that contributed to their success are validated. This affirmation can lead to excessive reliance on these qualities in the future. If a leader only receives positive feedback, their qualities are reinforced.

In some instances it can become dysfunctional.

Character flaws of minor consequence can grotesquely magnify with an increase in power. In this situation, the risk is that a leader’s talents can be eclipsed by their weaknesses.

Dynamic leaders spark followers into action. They’re the flame that ignites a motive in others. Thorugh their vision, they generate the power of focus. The power to influence. But followers are the gatekeepers, those who facilitate the beneficial use of a leader's power. Dynamic leaders tend to use power effectively, but they’re never the gatekeeper, so they must seek permission.

Through expansiveness, passion, energy, and drive leaders can be hypnotized by excess. A merger too big to refuse, a deal too large, a competitor too envied, a profit-margin too ambitious, a lifestyle too materialistic, a brand-image too pure, a purpose too righteous.

A bridge too far.

Gatekeepers can arrest excess. Followers hold the power to strike a balance through their courage to stand up to leaders.

Essential elements

There are two essential elements that nurture workplace relations. Trust and honesty. Leaders' trust must be honest and used appropriately as one without the other is meaningless.

Courage also underpins a leader's ability to maintain a genuine relationship with their followers. The type of courage that values and delivers trust and honesty.

From an elevated position of power, leaders can be prone to losing touch with their followers, with reality, known as “the king’s disease.” As such, Leaders are dependent on their followers to keep them grounded in reality.

Lesson

Leadership expert, Warren Bennis, said that “70 percent of followers” do not challenge a leader’s point of view “even when they feel the leader is about to make a mistake”. This is a huge flaw.

The message for leaders is to create a culture where follower-feedback is invited, encouraged, welcomed and heard. Build a work environment where trust and honesty form the bedrock of the organization. Otherwise, 70 percent of workers will continue to be unheard!

Photo by LinkedIn Sales Navigator on Unsplash
Leadership
Leadership Development
Business
Work
Relationships
Recommended from ReadMedium