The Art of Deciding About Art

Summary

The article discusses the subjective nature of defining art, particularly through personal experiences and the act of creation, even in moments of emotional intensity.

Abstract

The piece, titled "The Art of Deciding About Art," delves into the complexities of labeling something as art, suggesting that the distinction between art and personal expression, such as a response to emotional distress, can be blurred. The author, Lucy Dan, recounts a personal anecdote where she threw a dinner plate against the wall during a heated argument with her ex-husband, later considering the act as art rather than a mere outburst. The article emphasizes the duality that an action or creation can be both art and a manifestation of personal turmoil. Additionally, Dan shares links to her other works and invites readers to support her writing by subscribing to Medium through her referral link.

Opinions

The author believes that the definition of art can be highly subjective and personal, extending beyond conventional boundaries.
Lucy Dan suggests that art can emerge from intense emotional experiences, challenging the idea that art must be created in a controlled, serene environment.
The article posits that an act can simultaneously be an artistic expression and a symptom of a mental or emotional state.
Dan implies that the interpretation of what constitutes art can vary greatly among individuals, and having an "art decider" could be beneficial in such ambiguous situations.
The author celebrates her achievement as a top writer in art on Medium and shares additional resources for readers interested in her work and the broader topic of art.

If it’s not art, what is it?

On Twitter, you can call on a profile to decide whether a post is “art or not art.”

I think it would be very helpful to have a real-life art decider on call for those moments when you’re not sure whether what you just did is art or an expression of your own brand of crazy.

Recently I was telling someone about an experience with my ex-husband. He was yelling at me until I couldn’t handle it anymore, and I picked up my dinner plate and threw it against the wall.

My friend said he imagined I was sorry I had done that, and after considering for a moment, I said, “No. It was art.”

Was it art or a mental breakdown?

Two things can be true at the same time.

—

I hope you enjoy my writing. Here’s a link to a story about a new project I’m working on.

If you don’t yet have a membership and enjoy reading my posts, please consider joining through my referral link.

The Art of Deciding About Art

If it’s not art, what is it?

Celebrating a New Milestone: Top Writer in Art! 🎊

And reviewing the pieces that got me there

Maggie’s List

Resources for the new, the old, and anyone else interested

Join Medium with my referral link - Maggie LaFae

As a Medium member, a portion of your membership fee goes to writers you read, and you get full access to every story…