avatarMaria Theresa Stadtmueller

Summary

The article suggests that the traditional Christmas narrative, including the story of Baby Jesus, is worn out and in need of a reevaluation, proposing instead a celebration focused on personal meaning and the acknowledgment of the story's historical inaccuracies.

Abstract

The author reflects on the traditional Christmas story, expressing a sense of disconnection from its supposed joy even from childhood. The narrative points out that the celebration of Jesus' birth is overshadowed by the anticipation of his crucifixion, suggesting a repetitive and flawed cycle. Historical inconsistencies are highlighted, such as the Roman census method and the commonality of virgin birth narratives in ancient myths. The article argues for a shift in the celebration of Christmas, moving away from the need for salvation and the perpetuation of the traditional story, to a more personal and authentic observance that respects the need for a break from the traditional narrative, not just for oneself but also for the symbolic figure of Baby Jesus.

Opinions

  • The author challenges the conventional Christmas story, indicating it is not just tired but also historically questionable.
  • There is a critique of the traditional narrative's implication that humanity is inherently bad, requiring salvation.
  • The article suggests that people have been conforming to Christmas traditions to please family members, rather than out of genuine belief or desire.
  • It is proposed that the current times, with the possibility of staying home due to health guidelines, offer an opportunity to rethink and redefine how Christmas is celebrated.
  • The author advocates for a celebration that is more aligned with individual values and meaningful aspects of life, rather than adhering to traditional religious stories.
  • The piece calls for empathy, extending to the symbolic figure of Baby Jesus, by suggesting that the story itself is in need of a rest.

Sure, We All Need A Break Right Now. So Does Baby Jesus.

Basel Christmas Market — Manu Schwenderer on Unsplash

It’s not just us who’s tired. Baby Jesus needs a break too.

Even when I was a devout Catholic kid, Christmas escaped me. We were supposed to feel joyful — Santa! Lights! Presents! Baby Jesus, so tender and mild.

But peering past the tinsel, we all knew Baby Jesus was getting whacked come spring. Because we were born bad. Every year, Christmas inevitably churned on to Good Friday, like Groundhog Day with crucifixion.

The whole story is holey: Any Roman census went door-to door, and was recorded (Just not Luke’s). About ten ancient mythic man/gods were born of virgins December 25. Etc.

But mostly: We don’t need salvation. Because this. Maybe you’ve felt that, but attended church to keep family members happy. Now Fauci lets you stay home! Do over!

Celebrate lights, life, what’s meaningful to you. But give the kid a break — and all the kids he supposedly died for.

Religion And Spirituality
Psychology
Culture Change
Culture
Holidays
Recommended from ReadMedium