avatarSmillew Rahcuef

Summary

The author expresses dissatisfaction with an article by Philip Ogley, criticizing it without having read it, and uses the experience to vent about unrelated morning disturbances.

Abstract

The article titled "Short Critique of an Article I Didn’t Read" is a satirical piece where the author admits to not reading Philip Ogley's work, "Short History of a Novel No One Will Ever Read," yet criticizes it based on its title. The author's morning was disrupted by a neighbor mowing the lawn at an early hour, setting a negative tone that led to the writing of this critique. Despite not having read the article, the author questions the purpose of a backstory for a novel that claims no one will read and suggests that the title may have been an attempt at humor that did not land. The author's rant serves as a form of catharsis and is concluded with a sarcastic offer to critique other authors' work and a recommendation for more of Philip Ogley's "droning boredom."

Opinions

  • The author did not appreciate the intrusion of the article into their feed and likens it to the unwelcome noise of their neighbor's lawnmower.
  • There is a sense of irony in the author's critique of an article they admit to not reading, highlighting their disdain for the content based on its title alone.
  • The author believes that Philip Ogley's title choice for his article may have been a misguided attempt at humor or a clever marketing ploy, though they lean towards the latter.
  • The author uses hyperbole to express their frustration with the content they did not enjoy, referring to it as "drivel" and "droning boredom."
  • Despite the negative tone, the author acknowledges that their critique is a constructive way to deal with their irritation and that it aligns with their mood at the time of writing.
  • The author sarcastically invites others to have their articles critiqued in a similar manner, indicating a lack of seriousness in their offer.
  • The author's overall opinion of the article in question is negative, and they seem to take issue with the author's style and content as previously experienced on Medium and Twitter.

Critique of pure BS

Short Critique of an Article I Didn’t Read

TL;DR — I didn’t read it and didn’t like it.

Matheus Bertelli didn’t read it either.

Yet again an article came to my feed uninvited.

I wish the Algo would LISTEN to my prayers and fill my feed (and everybody else’s) with ONLY my articles, but so far, the Algo’s pretending to be deaf.

Age of Empathy generously agreed to publish the article in question.

I don’t have anything against the publication in general, but when I woke up this Sunday at 5:16 AM because my neighbor decided it was a good time to mow his lawn, I didn’t feel empathetic.

I felt like writing a rant instead, and the article I will reveal in a few lines was perfect for that purpose.

I hear you and even agree that confronting my neighbor would be a better option. However, since he was mowing grass hidden under one foot of snow and wearing nothing but his boxers, I thought it would be better for my health to stay inside and rant about something as innocuous as an article written by Philip Ogley.

The title of his article triggered me.

“Short History of a Novel No One Will Ever Read.”

If no one will ever read the novel, why would anyone want to read the corresponding short history?

Backstories are interesting insofar as the original story is. Since I didn’t read Philip’s article, I can’t say if his title was a mistake or a clever (but failed) attempt at reverse manipulating humor.

Having published another of Philip’s stories recently, I would argue for the latter, but can’t be sure since — to be 100% clear — I didn’t read his article.

To his credit, Philip used the tag “killing time” to describe his story, indicating it was likely to be more of the droning boredom he became famous for on Medium and Twitter.

Instead of killing my time with his drivel, I decided to kill his drivel with my time. It sounded much more constructive and was, in any case, more aligned with my mood so early in the morning.

I feel better now and will leave you in a few lines to drink coffee and eat a scone.

Thank you for your attention, and see you later.

If you would like me to write a short critique of one of your articles, drop a link in the comments.

In the meantime, you might enjoy more droning boredom that I didn’t write nor read (Philip did).

And if you want to keep the boring spirit alive, read this:

Rant
Marketing
Social Media Marketing
Humor
Social Media
Recommended from ReadMedium
avatarRoz Warren, Writing Coach
Flying First Class

Here’s what I got for my $500

6 min read