avatarJF Danskin

Summary

J.F. Danskin discusses Raymond Carver's advice on writing, emphasizing the importance of avoiding gimmicks and tricks that violate the trust between reader and author, particularly in the fantasy and LitRPG genres.

Abstract

The article reflects on the writing advice of Raymond Carver, a renowned short story writer who eschewed novel writing in favor of shorter fiction. Carver's disdain for tricks in writing is highlighted, with the term 'tricks' referring to any contrived or deceptive techniques that undermine the reader's trust. Danskin, who writes in the fantasy and LitRPG genres, often encounters such tricks, especially among novice writers. These can manifest as delayed revelations about narrators or inconsistencies in world-building that are only resolved later in the text, leaving readers feeling manipulated rather than engaged. Danskin aligns with Carver's philosophy, advocating for transparent and honest storytelling that respects the reader's experience. The article also includes a call to action for readers to subscribe to Danskin's posts and consider a Medium membership to support writers directly.

Opinions

  • Raymond Carver is admired by Danskin as a successful author who focused on short stories and provided valuable advice for writers.
  • Carver's advice against using 'tricks' in writing is endorsed by Danskin, who sees it as a principle that maintains the integrity of the story and the reader's trust.
  • Danskin observes that tricks are common in the fantasy and LitRPG genres, particularly by inexperienced writers, which can detract from the storytelling experience.
  • The article suggests that readers should be given sufficient information to understand the narrative without being subjected to manipulative revelations.
  • Danskin encourages readers to engage with his work by subscribing to his posts and supports the Medium platform's model of compensating writers through membership fees.

AUTHOR TIPS

Raymond Carver on Writing

Photo by JK Sloan on Unsplash

Raymond Carver was an unusual thing — a successful author who focused entirely on short stories. He wrote poetry and a bit of non-fiction too, but no novels at all.

He’s one of my favourites.

His piece “On Writing” is one of the best examples of advice for authors, too, and I often find myself sharing his thought on ‘no tricks’:

“I hate tricks. At the first sign of a trick or a gimmick in a piece of fiction, a cheap trick or even an elaborate trick, I tend to look for cover. Tricks are ultimately boring, and I get bored easily.”

Here, ‘tricks’ doesn’t mean surprises, but rather violations of the basic understanding between author and reader.

In my genre, fantasy and LitRPG, I see many examples of tricks. Typically, these come from inexperienced writers.

Maybe you don’t find out who your narrator is until chapter two or three, or perhaps a fantasy species looks and behaves totally differently from the norm… The issue comes when you aren’t given enough information to get your head around this until the author later reveals it. Then, it’s like they are saying, “Ah-hah! Reader, look how clever I am!”.

I agree with Carver — tricks are best avoided from the outset.

What are your favorite pieces of advice for authors?

p.s. you should get my posts direct to your inbox. Do that here! Also, if you’d like to experience Medium yourself, consider supporting me and thousands of other writers by signing up for a membership. It only costs $5 per month, it genuinely supports writers, and you have the chance to make serious money with your own writing as well! By signing up with this link, you’ll support me directly with a portion of your fee, it won’t cost you extra. If you do so, thank you so very much!

Short Form Content
Authortips
Creative Writing
Raymond Carver
Litrpg
Recommended from ReadMedium
avatarGrim Flandango
The Good Folk

A Drabble a Day

2 min read