avatarKristine Laco

Summary

The author argues that Canadian Thanksgiving is superior to its American counterpart, citing eight reasons ranging from the timing of the holiday to cultural significance and family traditions.

Abstract

The article titled "8 Reasons Why Canadian Thanksgiving is Better Than US Thanksgiving" presents a humorous yet pointed comparison between the two nations' Thanksgiving celebrations. The author, Kristine Laco, asserts that Canadian Thanksgiving, celebrated on the second Monday in October, is inherently better due to its strategic placement as a long weekend, allowing for a more relaxed post-feast recovery. Canadians are depicted as enjoying their festivities without the commercialized shopping frenzy that characterizes the American Black Friday. The piece also touches on the historical origins of both holidays, suggesting that the Canadian tradition focuses more on gratitude for the harvest and family, whereas the American holiday has roots in the controversial celebration of subduing the Pequots. Additional points include the preference for outdoor activities and pie over parades and competitive family sports, and the environmental benefit of not having back-to-back turkey-centric holidays.

Opinions

  • Canadian Thanksgiving is seen as more family-oriented and less commercial, with a focus on enjoying leftovers and outdoor activities rather than shopping.
  • The long weekend associated with Canadian Thanksgiving is preferable to the American holiday, which may require taking additional time off for a comparable break.
  • The author suggests that the historical context of American Thanksgiving, involving the massacre of natives, is less honorable compared to the Canadian celebration of safe exploration and a fruitful harvest.
  • Canadian Thanksgiving is celebrated earlier in the year, providing a month's respite from turkey dinners and the associated environmental impact of methane emissions from turkey farming.
  • The article pokes fun at the American tradition of watching football, implying it is less integral to the Canadian holiday, which is more about the "sport of eating."
  • The author expresses a clear preference for the Canadian approach to Thanksgiving, emphasizing the enjoyment of pie and family time without the perceived excesses of the American version.

YOU HAVE IT WRONG ‘MURICA

8 Reasons Why Canadian Thanksgiving is Better Than US Thanksgiving

Sorry, but it’s true. The Canadians have this one right.

So last month. Photo by Element5 Digital on Unsplash

This may not be a popular opinion, but I’ve never been accused of being popular.

Suck it cool kids’ table.

Our Thanksgiving is better than yours and here’s why:

1. Long Weekend

Canadian Thanksgiving is always a long weekend — the second Monday in October. You don’t have to take an extra day off to make it a long weekend. It just is. We keep all our vacation time to spend away from Aunt Carol.

2. Hangover Over

You likely don’t work the day after your big feast and have to pretend you aren’t hungover. Most Canadians eat their enormous meal on the weekend, leaving leftovers and hangovers for their days off.

3. Thankfulness

Thanksgiving is a time to gather the family, mark the start of fall, and celebrate the harvest season — more specifically the beginning of root veggie season. It originated in Canada as thanking God for keeping early explorers safe and morphed into being thankful for a fruitful harvest.

Mostly we are thankful for family.

US Thanksgiving celebrates the massacre of the natives and the Governor of Plymouth’s declaration of: “from that day forth shall be a day of celebration and thanks giving for subduing the Pequots.”

So there’s that. Yeah. Good time.

4. Less Shopping, More Pie

We don’t celebrate shopping on Thanksgiving. We often hike, play games outside with our family, eat our first helping of pie and a third helping of pie.

I never skip the second helping.

We save the shopping for other times.

No one ever has to wake up from their pie coma to get a $12 TV.

5. Dibs

Canadians started in 1578. The USA started in 1621. Making us the OG. We were also the OG for peanut butter, so that alone puts us on top.

6. We Stick to Inflating Our Waistlines

We don’t clog our streets with parades. I’ve been to NYC for the Macy’s parade and my favorite part was watching the birds in Central Park poop on the VIP stands while I stood across the street and felt thankful for mitts. I would have rather been eating pie than standing in the cold.

Do you do it because you feel bad about the massacre of the natives and you are trying to drown out the shame? Just wondering.

7. The Best Sport

Football, yeah, we do it. It’s kind of lame with three downs and stuff, but it happens and only thirty-seven people watch. So Thanksgiving is not about sport. It’s about the sport of eating, but we don’t pretend to play football with Uber-competitive Uncle Jed and sprain an ankle wearing our team’s jersey that never seems to smell good after the first wear.

No one sprains an ankle eating pie.

8. Digestion Not Indigestion

We don’t have back-to-back turkey holidays — end of November and end of December. Look, I love a good dry bird, but, as the person responsible for cooking and cleaning that giant poultry, I am thankful for the extra month when we can eat tacos and pasta like normal people.

Besides, the turkey farts my family generates is methane enough to melt the ozone. The world needs time to repair before we subject the universe to the foulness of fowl again.

Happy Thanksgiving to my friends and family in the US. I will raise a glass on your Thanksgiving Thursday and be thankful for my pizza.

Want more of me? I don’t blame you. Become a member with this link! Only $5/month inspires a writer to write another day and prevents them from inserting you into a scene with an armed madman.

Humor
Satire
Thanksgiving
This Happened To Me
Pumpkin
Recommended from ReadMedium
avatarRoz Warren, Writing Coach
Flying First Class

Here’s what I got for my $500

6 min read