avatarJane Frost (Jane Grows Garden Rooms)

Summary

The author discusses their experience of starting a Substack newsletter, including promotion, statistics, earnings, and final thoughts.

Abstract

The author shares their experience of writing a Substack newsletter and reflects on their progress. They have been writing for ten days and have made mistakes, but they plan to continue and hope that it will pay off eventually. They have promoted their newsletter on various platforms, including Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, Medium, and Instagram, and have seen an increase in traffic and subscribers. However, they are only producing free content at this stage and have not yet made any money. They plan to continue building a following before worrying about earnings.

Opinions

  • The author acknowledges that they have made mistakes in their writing and that it may take a while before their newsletter pays off.
  • The author is not discouraged by their lack of earnings and plans to continue building a following before worrying about money.
  • The author is concerned that their niche may be too niche to attract enough subscribers or that they may not be able to find their audience through promotional avenues.
  • The author plans to create a flyer with a QR code and do a letterbox drop in their area to promote their newsletter.
  • The author recommends Medium as an outlet for writers and readers, stating that their earnings have more than paid for their membership.

Ten Days After Substack Launch

My experience of writing a Substack newsletter.

GIF by Author

I’m ten days in.

This is where I tell you that I am making thousands!

I’m not.

This is where I tell you you can do it too!

I’m sure you can not make thousands too, but I’m equally sure you might make thousands before I do.

Writing is like that.

This is where I tell you that I have thousands of subscribers.

I have 21 subscribers. (And you can too!)

I’m not going to wait for “success”, whatever that is, to talk about what I’m doing. I’m okay with saying that I’ve made mistakes, that I think it’s going to be a while before this pays off.

Writing this out helps me reflect and maybe it will help other writers too.

I feel like I didn’t start well. See here for my explanation. (I did send an email to the two subscribers concerned. Neither have responded. Neither have signed up to the actual newsletter. Perhaps they’re busy or my email went to “junk”. It happens.)

Promotion

I have promoted my newsletter on the following platforms:

  1. Twitter — multiple tweets
  2. Facebook — posts on my personal feed and the “Jane Grows Garden Rooms” feed.
  3. LinkedIn — post
  4. Medium — article
  5. Instagram — story

Statistics

And now the graphs…

It surprised me that most of my visitors came from Facebook, but I guess it should have. That’s where I have the most followers. Unfortunately, only 3 of those visitors chose to subscribe.

Screenshot by Author

When I look at the traffic statistics I can see that the promotions are driving traffic. The big peak is when I promoted on the day before launching the newsletter.

Screenshot by Author

Likewise, subscription statistics rose with promotion.

Screenshot by Author

Earnings

At this stage, I am only producing free content. Substack says that around 10% of subscribers will choose to pay from a list of free subscribers.

So, it makes sense to build a following first and worry about money when I reach a minimum of 100 subscribers. At that point, I plan to keep the subscription fee low for weekly newsletters and send out a monthly free newsletter.

I’m hoping that will continue to encourage new free subscribers and over time translate to more paid subscribers.

Final Thoughts

Has it been worth it so far? — Yes, I think so. It’s forced me to write a new way, to come up with new content and to engage in self-promotion which I generally avoid.

My biggest concern is that, either my niche is so niche that I won’t be able to attract enough subscribers OR that I won’t be able to “find” my audience through the promotional avenues available to me.

My next step is to (cringe) create a flyer with a QR code and do a letterbox drop in my area.

Watch this space!

Like to see the newsletter in question?

Like writing or musing? I can recommend Medium as an outlet for a measly $5 per month.

Earn money writing and read as much as you like. Since my third month, my earnings have more than paid for membership. If you use the link below you’ll also be directly supporting me at no extra cost to you!

Writing
Newsletter
Substack
Nature
Sustainability
Recommended from ReadMedium