avatarMatt Ruby

Summary

The context describes a powerful and controversial moment in a rock concert where the artist responds to an accusation from the audience.

Abstract

The text describes a highly charged moment in a concert where the artist, presumably Bob Dylan, is accused of being a "Judas" for changing his musical style. The artist responds with a powerful retort, "I don't believe you. You're a liar," and proceeds to perform a song with intense emotion. The incident is used to illustrate the challenges faced by artists when they evolve and the resistance they may encounter from their fanbase.

Opinions

  • The artist is under the influence of amphetamines, which could be contributing to his intense performance.
  • The artist's recent songwriting is considered exceptional, but it has divided his fanbase.
  • The artist is accused of abandoning his fans by focusing on his internal feelings rather than external factors in his music.
  • The artist's response to the accusation is seen as a powerful and iconic moment in rock history.
  • The artist's decision to continue evolving his music despite resistance is praised.
  • The artist's performance is described as incredibly rock 'n roll.
  • The incident is used to illustrate the tension between an artist's desire to evolve and the audience's desire for the familiar.

You’re a liar

He’s blasted on amphetamines. Every press conference he does is Andy Kaufman-level schtick. He’s in the middle of the most incredible 3-year run of songwriting of the past century. Half his fanbase thinks he’s abandoned them because he wants to sing about his interior instead of his exterior. And right before the final number, someone yells out that he’s Judas. Some of the crowd jeers, some applaud. He walks toward the mic and says, “I don’t believe you.” He walks away and strums his guitar. But it sticks. He goes back to the mic. “You’re a liar.” Venom. And then he turns his back on the crowd and tells his band to “play fucking loud” before the song kicks in and when it gets to the chorus, he snarls, “How does it feeeeeeeel?” It doesn’t get more rock ‘n roll than that. When you’re heading for the future, people will scream for the past. But you’ve got to take them there anyway.

Music
Bob Dylan
Songwriting
1960s
Revolution
Recommended from ReadMedium