avatarHenrique Centieiro & Bee Lee

Summary

The article describes the unexpected poverty and lack of development in Dundo, Angola, despite its rich diamond resources, attributing this paradox to a government-implemented Universal Basic Income (UBI) that stifles entrepreneurship and economic activity.

Abstract

Dundo, the capital of a northern Angolan province and a significant mining town, presents a stark contrast between its abundant diamond wealth and the stark poverty visible in its underdeveloped infrastructure. The author recounts their experience of bureaucratic hurdles, including signing non-disclosure agreements and bribing officials, to visit Dundo. Upon arrival, the absence of small businesses, restaurants, and basic amenities like running water and electricity in the only hotel was shocking. The state-owned diamond company, Endiama, maintains a monopoly over the diamond trade, and to suppress individual entrepreneurship, it provides a UBI to residents, along with monthly food baskets. This policy, while superficially benevolent, has led to a lack of incentive for business and innovation, resulting in a stagnant economy. The author critiques UBI, suggesting it is a tool for control that ultimately undermines human initiative and societal progress.

Opinions

  • The author believes that the UBI implemented by Endiama in Dundo has a detrimental effect on the local economy and entrepreneurship.
  • The article suggests that the Angolan government's UBI policy is a form of social control that keeps the population dependent and docile.
  • There is a clear opinion that the wealth from diamond mining is not benefiting the local population in Dundo, despite the town's significant contributions to Angola's status as the 4th richest country in Africa in terms of natural resources.
  • The author implies that the lack of economic activity in Dundo is an unintended consequence of the UBI, which kills the human ingenuity and the will to move things forward.
  • The article conveys skepticism about the effectiveness of UBI, stating that if simply providing money could solve poverty, it would have been eradicated long ago.
  • The author emphasizes that government-provided "free lunches" come with a price, namely the loss of independence and initiative among the populace.
AI image created on MidJourney by the author.

Why Is The Richest Diamond Capital of Africa So Poor?

When I arrived at this mining town Dundo, I didn’t expect to see what I saw. Then, I discovered it was related to UBI.

Dundo is the capital of a northern Angola province and one of the biggest mining towns in Africa. It’s a town jam-packed with diamonds.

Yes, Angola is the 4th richest country in Africa in terms of natural resources.

Before landing in a town close to Dundo, all I heard were stories about diamonds and how diamonds are abundant around those lands. So, I’ve obviously built an image of wealth around that place.

I arrived early at the airport in Luanda (capital city of Angola) to take my flight to Dundo. To my surprise, I had to sign a document declaring why I was travelling to Dundo and a non-disclosure agreement. I also had to bribe the government official to accept my documents.

I was surprised not about the bribing (that’s very common) but about the bureaucracy required to simply travel to another province.

I started to think, “Hmm… they might be trying to hide something in that town.

Dundo, on the northern side of Angola, is one of the mining cities of Africa. Google maps screenshot.

When the plane was about to land, I looked through the window and asked myself: “Hey, where is the airport landing strip?

Lucapa Airport. Photo by the author.

The “airport” landing strip was just dirt, and the airport building was rather underwhelming.

Lucapa airport building. Photo by the author.

Once I arrived at the Dundo “airport”, I was interrogated again by the police and local government officials, asking me exactly what I was doing there. I told them the truth: I was visiting the site of a new hotel that my client was planning to build.

After they held me for about one hour, they finally released me, and I took the road on my way to Dundo.

Photo by the author.

After driving for about one hour on a pick-up truck, I finally arrived at the mining capital of Angola.

Photo by the author.

Do you know what shocked me the most about this mining city?

I’ve travelled all over this African country, and almost everywhere I went, I saw tons of small businesses, people hustling, agriculture, and people selling everything you can imagine by the side of the road.

Up until then, I’ve covered thousands of kilometres in Angola, and there were small businesses everywhere.

This shows a typical street in Angola buzzing with activity and people selling everything you can imagine. Not in Dundo, tho! Photo by the author.

Angolan people are true entrepreneurs, and because of the lack of formal jobs, a massive percentage of the population are solopreneurs or have small businesses.

Except in this mining town.

No one sold fruits, vegetables, or chickens by the side of the road. There were no food stands, almost no restaurants, no shops, no beauty saloons and no agriculture.

The only hotel in the region (where I stayed) had cockroaches, there was no running water, and no electricity at night.

Why was the mining capital of Angola the most underdeveloped and poorest place I’ve visited in Africa?

Kids in Dundo, the mining capital of Angola. Photo by the author.

I even visited a fair with big diamond exhibitors while I was there… Money was being made, but businesses and infrastructure were nowhere to be seen.

This is all diamonds. At Expo Cacanda in Dundo. Photo by the author.

This was truly unexpected for me… so I decided to ask around and found my answers.

Endiama is the state-owned diamond company of Angola. They have a 100% monopoly over the diamond business, and obviously, they don’t want any sort of competition.

To prevent individuals from venturing into the diamond business or trying to find diamonds themselves, they have implemented a sort of UBI — Universal Basic Income. Every family receives money from the government and a monthly basket with different food items for the entire family.

At a superficial level, this sounds good, but the end result is bad.

The result is they killed most economic activity in this province by giving UBI to the residents. There’s no incentive for business, entrepreneurship and ambition.

Talking about UBI, I’ve written an in-depth exploration of how UBI will eventually impact our society. Feel free to check it out:

Dundo street. Photo by Antonio Ventura.

UBI experiments around the world have this kind of result. They kill the human ingenuity and the will to move things forward.

At a surface level, these policies seem well-intentioned.

If you dig deeper, they are about control and tyranny and keeping the population quiet, dependent, and docile.

Despise the free lunch. No matter where you are.

If throwing money at things would solve the problems, poverty would have been solved long ago.

What is offered for free is dangerous.

A free lunch, especially from a government, comes with the price: the price of your soul.

If you found any value in this article, throw us some Medium love!

🥰 What you can do to support us: Clap up to 50, leave a message to share your thoughts & be sure to follow. 💌

🌞 Stay in touch with us:

Society
Africa
Economy
Politics
Thepov
Recommended from ReadMedium