Why Do We Keep Hitting Replay? The Obsession Behind Our Favorite Songs

Endless loops, you like them, don’t you?

Writer Katie Arnold-Ratliff has listened to the song “Randy Described Eternity” more than 400 times and still obsesses about it.

Sounds familiar?

You might be like a broken record with your songs, but you can’t get enough of them.

Familiar songs can be comforting, but why do you keep coming back to the same ones when there aren’t any surprises left?

After all, part of the fun of music is the unexpected twists and turns. But there’s none after 1,246 replays (and that’s an understatement).

What makes our ears keep craving for more?

The same song again, aren’t you bored?

Researchers from the University of Michigan were curious to learn what made people put their favorite tracks on an endless repeat.

In their study, they surveyed 204 people about their experiences with songs they listened to most frequently. They were asked how they felt during what the researchers called “extreme re-listening” and what were their listening habits.

But instead of asking participants about predefined songs, they asked about the songs the individuals were listening to the most during the study period. This way, we could glimpse people’s real, day-to-day experiences with their favorite songs.

So what did they find?

• Listening frequency: Over 86% of participants reported listening to their favorite songs daily or weekly. When they said daily, they meant 3 times a day. Takeaway: listeners will return to their favorite songs more often.
• Connection to the songs: 65.6% of participants had a very high connection to their songs. Takeaway: these songs are meaningful components of an individual’s life.
• Emotional response: More songs (69%) were classified as “Happy/Energetic” compared to 31% of them, which felt “Calm/Relaxed” or “Bittersweet/Melancholy/Nostalgic.” Takeaway: most favorite songs elicit positive emotions and are used for an emotional uplift.
• Re-listening: Listeners who reported songs making them feel “Bittersweet/Melancholy/Nostalgic” listened more times on average (790.2 times) compared to songs that made them feel “Calm/Relaxed” (515.0 times) or “Happy/Energetic” (174.9 times). Takeaway: songs that elicit a bittersweet feeling are more likely to be played nonstop.
• Reasons for re-listening: Over 50% of participants identified the “melody” as the most important attribute in repeatedly bringing them back to their favorite song. Participants also mentioned the beat and lyrics as essential factors, but less likely when the song felt “Bittersweet/Melancholy/Nostalgic.” Takeaway: multiple musical elements contribute to a song’s appeal.

What can we take from all this?

Well, we might be using positive songs like a mood-regulating pill where we seek a consistent emotional fix each time we listen to them.

For those bittersweet songs, their complexity may comfort us, knowing that someone else (i.e., the artist) has felt the same way. And if there’s a mental health issue, this becomes more intense. For instance, people dealing with depression tend to ruminate about their condition and might listen to songs that resonate with their feelings, potentially extending their blues.

However, it doesn’t mean that each time we listen to them, we feel the same emotion. Some experience different emotions on different listens — happiness at times and sadness at others.

Overall, we see that certain songs stand the test of time no matter how many times we hit that replay button.

Final thoughts

We’re in an age in music that our favorite songs are at our fingertips 24/7.

We can dive deep into a song at our discretion.

Nobody has to know whether we listen to a song one or a thousand times. Thank God!

In summary, we turn to positive songs like an emotional pick-me-up (i.e., mood regulation), and for bittersweet tunes, their complexity offers solace, particularly in the context of mental health issues like depression.

And if you didn’t know why you keep hitting the replay button on your favorite songs, now you know.

Want to learn more about the sound verse?

Join my newsletter to explore everything related to music and sound, from the effects on our psyche to the technologies that use sound to improve our lives.