Why Are We So Upset About Gabby Petito?
We didn’t even know her, but we’re devastated.

It’s not just because she’s White. I won’t deny that it played a role. We all know that Whiteness is the baseline in America for being a real American. That’s just the way it is. I do think it’s getting better incrementally-but it’s still a factor. And she was cute, with a beautiful smile. But it was a deeper, more guttural feeling of horror that has spread throughout the community on her behalf.
This is why it leads on many of the news channels.
However, thousands of pretty people are murdered every year in America. It hurts to say it; it’s awful, actually, but it’s true.
But here is where it differs.
Millions of us got to see Gabby in person, at least on camera. Did you see her in that loop that plays over and over on all the news channels, crying…what emotion is that? Sadness? Fear? Terror? Now, after the fact, it’s still hard to tell.
We heard her voice.
Maybe that’s why we were so invested in her disappearance. Perhaps this is a tip for families of people who are missing. Let the public see them walking and talking on video. It’s kind of macabre marketing, but if it works and they’re found quickly, who cares?
When she cried, I could see how she probably looked like when she was three, only then, mommy or daddy would pick her up and tell her everything was going to be OK. But in this case, it wasn’t. Nobody was on her side. She was all alone. And she knew it.
And that, I think, is what strikes most of us in our gut. We watched the police officers display the same attitude they get when they get together with men they identify with…it’s like they’re all raised by the same woman and played on the same football team in high school.
One officer, in particular, goes through the entire arrest scenario…explaining to his new friend, Brian, what could happen to this woman.
Look at the cray-cray girl! You have scratches on you! No, he didn’t say these exact words, but we know what he meant.
She’s mentally ill!
Later, two other factors came out; the first of which was fully known to the police officers (but not to us) at this time:
- The 911 caller reported that the “gentleman” was hitting the woman.
- It seems that Brian Laundrie has some mental illness himself.
Of course. The police ate that up, didn’t they? They were schooled by a high school graduate who not only diagnosed his girlfriend’s psychiatric state but also his own.
He probably did his research.
They wanted to charge her.
Early news reports stated that the police almost charged 22-year-old Gabby with assault. Between the three or four men, including Brian, they reversed a 911 report in broad daylight! They were overly friendly to Brian Laundrie because he was a man and THIS — combined with poor judgment — allowed them to apply sexist stereotypes, which caused them to blame the victim. They were in a huddle, talking to him like he was the sane one.
The only reason they didn’t charge Gabby is that Brian didn’t want them to. He had so much power…
The police spent so much time with Brian that if this was an NFL game, one could say that the referee (police) made sure he kept possession of the ball.
Look at this confusing paragraph:
Was that a misunderstanding? Or just a plain, old-fashioned lie?
Gaslighting galore
Do you know where the word gaslight comes from? It was the title of a 1944 Alfred Hitchcock movie. Here’s the plot: A man tries to make his wife look crazy…until she believes it herself.
To gaslight: the act of undermining another person’s reality by denying facts, the environment around them, or their feelings
Isn’t that what we all just saw?
