While the Nanny Watches

Theme: voyeurism, open relationship, group sex, anal, assumed cheating

FAITH POV

Putting myself through grad school is harder than I thought so I’m working a new side job as a nanny.

I found the listing online by a gay couple looking for a babysitter for their 10-year old daughter, Tia.

I met Harry and Nate at a coffee shop for the interview, and we hit it off so much they asked me to be a nanny instead, meaning I would work slightly more hours. Needing the money, I was elated at the offer and accepted on the the spot.

After a month now, I can say I’m really lucky to have found this job. They are the coolest guys. 40-year olds with an amazing sense of humor and easy-going personalities.

Definitely not bad to look at either. You can tell they don’t skip their gym days. I may or may not have seen the outline of their lengths a few times after their workouts in those tight biker shorts. How are both men that well endowed? Not that I would ever make a move obviously. Oh and Tia is the sweetest little girl, too.

Today, the dads are working from home and called me in since they would be in and out of meetings all day.

I just put Tia down for her afternoon nap, grabbing her baby monitor so I’d know when she wakes up. That little girl can sleep, it’d be another hour or two so I decide to make myself some lunch.

As I’m eating, I notice a text from Nate.

Nate: Left to run an errand. Harry’s in his office if you need anything.

After I finish, I make some lemonade and decide to bring a glass up to Harry. I attach the baby monitor to my hip and walk to his office.

I quickly glance inside Nate’s across the hall to find it empty, then turn to Harry’s. Finding it cracked slightly, I gently kicking it open.

I see Harry standing with his back faced towards the door, leaning on his desk. He has one hand wrapped around on the edge, sleeves rolled up, veins straining up his forearm, and the other seemingly rubbing this forehead.

Is he on a tense work call? I freeze in the doorway not wanting to interrupt.

I break out of my internal debate at wet noises squishing around. I quickly tilt the baby monitor towards me, unsure of where the sound is coming from.

I snap my head back up when Harry lets out a loud groan. His head falls back, his raised hand now pulling through his hair. His other hand leaves the desk, moving towards the front of his crotch.

“Yea just like that.” He hisses.

He bends forward just a bit, grunting as a loud pop fills the air.

“Does Nate suck you off like this?” A seductive yet girly voice says.

My feet dig into the ground, not wanting to make a noise. I try hard to not shake the glass.

Who is that? Is he cheating on Nate? I should leave. But what if I make a noise leaving? What if Nate comes home and finds me watching?

And how has he not noticed me? Oh right, cause he’s busy stuffing a woman’s face with his cock. I have so many questions.

“Keep going, this feels so good. I’m not gonna last if you keep sucking me so tight.”

This is all so wrong. But why am I getting wet?

I feel slickness starting to spread between my thighs. There’s no way I can move my legs without a giving myself away now.

Harry grabs what I assume is the woman’s head and thrusts his hips forward. His ass cheeks bounce off the desk, giving him leverage to fuck her face harder. She moans, enjoying the attack as dainty fingers wrap around and grab his ass.

“I’m coming!”

Harry slams his hips forward, releasing his load down her throat for what seems like minutes.

“Fuck I haven’t came that hard in a while.”

Still in shock by what I just witnessed, I forget to hide when the mystery woman stands up, wiping any spilled come off her chin with the back of her hand.

“Oh my god!” She screams as we make eye contact.

Uh-oh.

HARRY POV

I struggle to catch my breath, my ears ringing as I come down from my release. Her mouth was so tight and wet, I got lightheaded feeling her swallow around my head.

“Oh my god!” My assistant, Grace, screams as she looks past me towards the door.

Is Nate back? I turn around, surprised to find our nanny, Faith, looking like a deer in headlights.

I should be ashamed to be caught but an idea pops in my mind.

You see, me and Nate are in an open relationship. We both enjoy the sexual pleasures of women but only find intimacy in each other, so we came up with an arrangement that made us both happy.

We were looking for a babysitter for our beautiful Tia when we met Faith. We only needed to share a brief glance to know we were both thinking the same thing.

She’s a beautiful young woman, fit figure, an average yet plump chest, and a round behind so firm I wanted to take a bite. Not that we were expecting anything, but she was a sight for sore eyes so we asked her to be our nanny instead.

“Faith! I can explain.”

“Oh. Uh- it’s none of my business. I- I was just bringing you a drink. I should go check on Tia.”

“Where is Tia?”

“She’s uh, taking a nap.”

“And you have her baby monitor on your hip.” I say more as a statement. “Nate and I have an open relationship. He knows about-”

I pause realizing I haven’t actually introduced my nanny to the woman who’s mouth I just fucked in front of her. “This is Grace, my assistant.”

Grace blushes, waving while Faith gives a shy smile back.

“Right. Well, I’ll let you get back to it.” Her eyes widen. “I mean I’ll get myself off- No! I mean ugh, I’ll get going now.”

Her nervousness is so cute. I wouldn’t mind watching her tight behind jiggle on her way out, but I rather have my hands all up on that while I bury my cock inside her tight hole.

“You don’t have to!” My gaze drops down her body and I smirk seeing her knees slightly squeeze together. I take long strides towards her.

“Harry-”

“Faith.”

I unclip the monitor, letting my fingers brush against the skin of her hip. Her chest rises quicker, the ice shakes against the glass.

When she doesn’t pull away, I quickly grab the cup and place both items on the side table behind her.

I hover my hand over her camel toe, tight leggings wedged in between emphasizing it more. I see exactly how puffy her pussy lips are.

“So if I run my fingers here, I won’t feel how wet you are for me?”

“I never said that.”

“So why do you want to leave?”

“I’m the nanny. This is unprofessional.”

I nod my head in understanding.

My fingers run down the fabric, putting pressure with my two fingers to follow the outline of her camel toe. I maintain eye contact, searching for any sense of resistance. I stop at the moisture-wicked spot, licking my lips at the sudden craving.

“You’ve been teasing me for the past month. Walking your hot body around in tight leggings all the time.”

I press a little harder causing her to whimper. “I get off just imaging you naked in my bed.”

“Ahem- hello.” Grace reminds me of her presence.

“I come at the thought of fucking you both.” I turn back to Faith, raising a brow. “What do you say?”

I continue to pry my fingers through her silence. I know she’s thinking about it, too.

“Let me taste you. You’re soaking wet, it shouldn’t go to waste.”

She bites her lip, nodding ever so slightly. That’s all I need.

I place my hands on her lower back, tracing the curve before hooking my thumbs in her pants and pull. I cup my hands letting it fill with the soft flesh.

I lift her up, Instantly, she wraps her long legs around my waist. I feel her warm juices spread along my lower stomach.

“So ready with no underwear on?”

I lay her across my desk and kneel on my knees as I bring her pants down with me. She parts her legs, greeting me with the smell of her arousal.

My cock springs to life again when the first drop of her pussy juice hits my tongue. She suffocates me between her legs, using her hands to smash me in further until she hits her release.

I lean back, wiping her wetness from my chin and nose.

“I need to fuck you both. Now.”

Grace jumps on the desk, laying down next to Faith with her skirt hiked up and ready.

I move each hand under their shirts, palming their breasts. I give them each a good squeeze before pushing the fabric up. I lean over, playing with each nipple with my tongue. Making sure to pull on their firm nubs as I drop my pants to the floor.

I step out of them quickly, my excitement overtaking my patience.

“It’s gonna take too long to find a condom.”

I watch each woman as they look at each other then back at me, giving me the approval I need. I flip Faith over by the hips, guiding her on top of Grace so both women are face to face.

Rewarded with Faith’s juicy peach, I spread her cheeks to give me easier access. I smear her juices around her ass, not forgetting to give attention to her clit.

Her moans fill the room, then is quickly replaced with lips smacking as the girls passionately kiss.

“This pussy juice is delicious, you guys gotta try.”

I put my soaked finger in between their mouths, letting their skilled tongues battle as they lick all around.

I bend down, running my tongue around Faith’s tight hole until I see her open up, letting me deeper inside.

My cock straining harder than ever, I stand and line it up with Grace’s opening. I start fucking her, keeping my thumb on Faith’s tight hole as I tease her some more.

I get in a few strokes before switching to Faith, putting my other hand between Grace’s slit.

“Oh fuck, you’re so much tighter.”

I struggle to fit my whole length inside her. Making shallow strokes, fighting the urge to fuck her senseless.

“Baby, you need to relax and let me in.”

I begin moving my thumb in circular motions, hoping the pleasure to her ass would loosen her up but it only turns her on more.

“Fuck, you like that? I feel you tightening even more.”

“I can’t. I’m com-”

My eyes widen as she rolls her head back, clenching the paperwork underneath her just as tightly as she does around my cock. “I’M COMING!”

I fuck her through her orgasm then continue my game of tag between Grace and Faith’s legs until they both come, multiple times.

On Grace’s fifth release, I withdraw my cock and shove it straight into Faith’s tight ass. I lean on my toes to change my angle, giving me more leverage to dive deeper inside.

Her tight hole hugs my cocks so nice. My balls tighten and a tingle runs up my spine. I thrust my cock all the way inside, depositing my seed in her ass.

I move back, watching my glistening cock pull out. “Volunteer to lick me clean?”

Barely getting the last word out, two tongues run up my still hard cock. Just like on my finger but better.

I close my eyes in bliss, hissing when I’m licked on the sensitive spot below my balls.

“What the- UH.” Any remaining come shoots out from my balls at the instant pleasure, covering both pretty faces.

I can get used to this.

If you enjoyed this story, please leave me a clap or comment for monetization per Medium’s updated policies. Thank you so much for reading!

More short stories you may like:

Ferris Wheel — A shy woman tempted at the public fair by her boyfriend.

Dinner Date with the Neighbors — Husband seduced at dinner by the neighbor