avatarRoz Warren, Writing Coach

Summary

The author discusses the complexities and moral implications of inheriting money from a trust set up by their father for his girlfriend, which creates an awkward situation where the author and their sister are financially incentivized to hope for the girlfriend's demise.

Abstract

The article titled "When Dad’s Girlfriend Dies, I’ll Get a Bunch of Money: Why That’s Not a Great Idea" delves into the author's experience with their father's estate planning. The father's will stipulates that a significant portion of his wealth be placed in a trust for his girlfriend, with the author and their sister as administrators. The sisters send checks to the girlfriend every four months, and they will inherit the remaining funds upon her death. The author reflects on the potential reasons behind their father's decision, such as preventing the girlfriend's new husband from inheriting the wealth or her own children inheriting it prematurely. Despite the morbid financial incentive, the author and their sister do not wish harm upon the girlfriend, who has been a positive influence in their father's life. The author grapples with the ethical dilemma of desiring financial gain while also feeling gratitude and respect for the girlfriend's relationship with their father. The article serves as a cautionary tale for those considering similar estate plans.

Opinions

  • The author believes that the trust arrangement, while possibly well-intentioned, is ethically problematic as it creates a situation where they are financially rewarded for the girlfriend's death.
  • The author and their sister are portrayed as morally upright individuals who would never act upon the incentive to harm the girlfriend, emphasizing their professions as a librarian and a musician as evidence of their non-violent nature.
  • There is a sense of gratitude towards the father for not leaving everything to the girlfriend, despite the complexities of the situation.
  • The author acknowledges the girlfriend's positive impact on their father's life and feels that she deserves to live a long life, despite the financial implications for the author and their sister.
  • The article suggests that the reader should reconsider setting up a similar trust due to the potential negative consequences and moral quandaries it may cause.

When Dad’s Girlfriend Dies, I’ll Get a Bunch of Money

Why That’s Not a Great Idea

Photo by Sharon McCutcheon on Unsplash

My dad’s will provided that after he died a big chunk of his money would be placed in a trust for the benefit of his long-time girlfriend. The trust would be administered by his two adult daughters, neither of whom had a particularly good relationship with said girlfriend.

What could possibly go wrong?

My dad died in 2006. Every four months since then, in accordance with the trust, my sister and I have sent a large check to dad’s sweetie.

The two of us get whatever is left in the trust when she dies.

We’re not entirely sure why Dad set it up this way. I suspect he wanted to avoid a situation where he leaves it directly to her, and then she remarries, resulting in Dad’s hard-earned money ending up in the hands of her new husband. (If she does remarry, according to the will, the checks stop.)

Or one where he leaves the money directly to her — and the next day she gets hit by a bus, and her adult children inherit his wealth.

But we really don’t know. And we certainly can’t ask him.

Maybe this plan made sense to my father. But Karma-wise? It’s all messed up.

For one thing, it’s a big whopping incentive for me and my sister to want her dead. (If this were an Agatha Christie novel? She’d be toast.)

Luckily for her, we’re not the murdering kind. I’m a librarian. My sister is a musician. How would we even do it? I’d bash her to death with a reference book while my sister whacked her upside the head with a violin?

Not going to happen.

Instead, four times a year, I google Karen (not her real name) to make sure she’s still on the planet and then send her a nice fat check.

Meanwhile, the amount of money in the trust is dwindling. The longer Karen lives, the less will be left for us.

She is currently 90 years old. She will probably live forever.

And she deserves to! She made the last 15 years of dad’s life very happy.

I’m grateful that dad left us anything at all. He could have left her everything.

Still — could I use that money? You bet I could.

Which means? When I google her name before cutting her that large check, I don’t really want her obituary to turn up.

And yet? I kind of do.

Thanks, Dad.

If I ever suspected that I wasn’t a saint, you’ve figured out a great way to remind me of that fact, four times a year.

So what does this mean for you, the reader? Just this. In case you’re thinking of this kind of set-up for your own estate planning?

I’d think twice.

( Medium Sherpa and Writing Coach Roz Warren writes for everyone from the Funny Times to the New York Times.)

Inheritance
Money
This Happened To Me
Relationships
Family
Recommended from ReadMedium