Western Culture Hates the Poor
Let’s look at why and what we can really do to change this
In Western culture, there exists a complex and deeply ingrained negative societal attitude towards poverty that is profane.
The association between wealth and success has been deeply rooted in Western societies for centuries. Prosperity is often equated with personal achievement, self-worth, and social status.
Individuals in a state of poverty are seen as lacking these qualities, leading to stigmatization and marginalization.
The fear of poverty often stems from a deep-rooted scarcity mindset, where individuals believe that resources are limited and must be fiercely protected. This mindset fosters a fear of losing one’s financial stability and the associated comforts and security.
Capitalism forms the foundation of many Western economies. It emphasizes individualism, self-reliance, and material accumulation. This ideology often fosters the belief that financial wealth is attainable through hard work and personal merit.
Those unable to achieve financial success may be judged as lazy, unmotivated, or lacking in initiative, reinforcing the notion that poverty is self-inflicted.
Cognitive biases
Humans are also prone to cognitive biases, such as the “just-world hypothesis,” which assumes that individuals deserve their circumstances. This bias may lead people to believe that poverty is a result of personal flaws or lack of effort, reinforcing the fear of being poor.
Love to love me some shopping
Western culture also tends to prioritize consumerism and material possessions, associating them with happiness and fulfillment. In this context, poverty is viewed as an undesirable state, as it restricts access to the material comforts and social experiences that are highly valued.
Professional Political Parrots
The media and politicians repeat endless messages that make people think poverty is an individual’s fault, rather than telling folks that poverty is more often the result of political choices and biased media.
These perspectives are social constructs embedded in Western culture and do not reflect the inherent worth or value of individuals experiencing poverty.
We need more empathy…no we don’t
And the usual spiel is that challenging these attitudes requires promoting empathy, understanding, and advocating for social and economic justice.
Maybe the usual take is right. Maybe we do need greater empathy, but nah. My thinking is we need greater intelligence. We need growth. Because guess where greater empathy and understanding are going to come from?
Yeah. Growth
In the spirit of learning and growth let’s look at what Black and Indigenous cultures can teach Westerners about their overreliance on an economic structure that is killing humanity and destroying our planet.
Let’s note there is significant diversity within indigenous and Black cultures, and generalizations may not capture the full range of perspectives and experiences.
Many indigenous and Black cultures place a strong emphasis on communal values, collective well-being, and mutual support. There is often a sense of interconnectedness and interdependence within the community, which fosters cooperation and resource-sharing rather than individualistic pursuits.
Traditional Practices
Indigenous and Black cultures often have traditional practices and knowledge that promote sustainable resource management and resilience.
Practices may include communal farming, sustainable hunting, and fishing methods, and the preservation of traditional crafts and skills. Such practices contribute to a sense of abundance and self-sufficiency within the community.
Historical Resilience
Indigenous and Black communities have often faced historical challenges and adversity, such as colonization, slavery, and systemic oppression. Despite these hardships, these communities have demonstrated resilience and resourcefulness in finding alternative ways to meet their needs and sustain themselves.
This history of resilience can shape attitudes toward scarcity and inspire innovative solutions.
Spiritual and Cultural Beliefs
Indigenous and Black cultures have spiritual and cultural beliefs that emphasize interconnectedness with the natural world and a holistic view of well-being. These beliefs can instill a sense of abundance and a recognition of the inherent value of community, relationships, and cultural practices over material possessions.
Cultural Wealth
Indigenous and Black cultures possess rich cultural traditions, oral histories, art, music, and storytelling that contribute to a sense of cultural wealth and resilience. This focus on cultural heritage and identity can provide a strong foundation of strength and pride that goes beyond material wealth.
There’s a tendency when writing these kinds of stories to include some type of hopeful note, such as recognizing these psychological reasons helps foster empathy and understanding towards individuals facing poverty and on and on and on. But we know this isn’t true.
Know what would actually help combat poverty?
Political will
Actually, putting policies in place that protect the poor, and tax the wealthy. Having a fair justice system that doesn’t cost an arm and a leg to access.
Because when you look at the price for filings, motions, and on and on, well, yeah, justice is only for those who can afford it.
Of course, we’ll also need to get a better crop of politicians. You know, ones who have healthy values.
Challenging stereotypes, promoting education, and advocating for social and economic equality, hasn’t helped reduce the fear and stigma associated with poverty and it sure as shit hasn’t created a more compassionate society.
So what can?
I don’t know. But I do know that continuing on this path of self-destruction that Western society has us barreling down isn’t the way.
Maybe telling the truth about the narcissistic, self-destructive, greedy rich, would also help. But that’s a comeuppance arriving via snail mail.
In the meantime, let’s look at Indigenous cultures. And remember, there are many distinctive Indigenous cultures around the globe.
Indigenous cultures often have different perspectives and relationships with resources that can contribute to a distinct mindset regarding scarcity compared to Western cultures.
Generalizations may oversimplify the diversity among indigenous cultures worldwide, there are several key factors that can help explain why scarcity mindsets may be less prevalent in some indigenous societies:
Connection to Nature
Indigenous cultures typically maintain a close connection to the natural environment and view it as a provider of resources rather than something to be conquered or controlled.
Communal Sharing
Many indigenous societies prioritize communal values, collective responsibility, and resource sharing. Instead of individual accumulation, resources are often shared and distributed based on community needs, reducing the fear of scarcity at an individual level.
