Two Book Ideas: Decisions, Decisions

Summary

A writer is torn between two book projects, one already in progress with extensive planning but a complex plot, and the other a newer, compelling idea that continues to intrigue them.

Abstract

The author has been working on a novel (Project One) for some time, having developed an outline, premise, and character sketches. However, the story's dual timeline and multiple points of view present significant challenges, leaving the writer feeling overwhelmed. Meanwhile, a second book idea (Project Two) has taken root in the author's mind, offering a creative distraction with its persistent flow of new ideas. Despite the allure of Project Two, the writer acknowledges the investment already made in Project One and seeks advice on how to proceed, questioning whether exploring the new idea constitutes 'writer cheating'.

Opinions

The author feels a strong attachment to Project One, having invested significant time in its development, but is intimidated by its complexity.
Project Two is described as an idea that "wouldn't let go," suggesting a strong emotional or creative pull towards this new concept.
The writer is logically inclined to continue with Project One due to the time and effort already expended, yet is emotionally drawn to Project Two.
There is a sense of guilt or indecision about entertaining Project Two while still working on the first project, as indicated by the question about 'writer cheating'.
The author is seeking external advice or validation to help make a decision on which project to prioritize.

Look for writing advice for when you can’t decide which story to write first

Photo by Burst via Unsplash

Last year, I started a rough draft of a novel idea I had. I had no idea what I was doing. I worked on it for a few months and realized it was not enough for a book, more like a short story. Another idea popped into my head and it wouldn’t let go. I spent a few months thinking about the plot as it was a little complicated.

The problem I am facing is I have two book ideas, both vying for my attention. Project One is the one I have invested a lot of time in writing. I’ve written an outline, premise, and character sketches. But the plot is complicated with a dual timeline and at least two points of view. As I write the first draft, I feel overwhelmed with the best approach to telling the story. This type of book is the type I would love to read but am feeling intimidated by the scope of how best to put the story together.

Project Two entered my headspace a few months ago. I’ve written the idea in my journal of ideas. From time to time, I get more ideas for this second project. It’s not letting me go. I remind Project Two that I’ve done a lot of work already for Project One, so it makes sense to keep going with that book.

I’m not sure how to proceed. Logically I know I should continue on with Project One since that is the one I’ve invested so much of my time in. I don’t want to start Project Two while working on the other book, at least not until I complete the first draft.

As I write this post, I know I should continue working on the first project idea. But I may play around a little more with Project Two (is this writer cheating?!).

Do you have any advice or words of wisdom for this writer stuck at the fork in the road?