avatarToni Tails

Summary

The article discusses five historical instances of the Mandela Effect, a phenomenon where a large group of people share false memories about past events, which challenges the author's perception of reality.

Abstract

The concept of the Mandela Effect, coined by Fiona Broome, refers to collective false memories. The article delves into five historical examples that have made the author, a history enthusiast, question their understanding of reality. These include the belief that Nelson Mandela died in prison, the Lindbergh baby's fate, the use of Dazzle Camouflage in WWI, the behavior of Jackie Kennedy after JFK's assassination, the Mona Lisa's smile, and the appearance of Moai statues on Easter Island. The author reflects on their personal experiences and the impact of these discrepancies, emphasizing the dissonance between widely held memories and documented historical facts.

Opinions

  • The author expresses skepticism about the scientific explanation of shared false memories, as their personal knowledge and research conflict with the historical record.
  • The Lindbergh baby case is presented with a personal anecdote, suggesting that the author's memory, shaped by numerous documentaries, contradicts the established outcome of the kidnapping.
  • The existence of Dazzle Camouflage during WWI is a point of contention, with the author claiming that their extensive background in history should have made them aware of this camouflage technique earlier.
  • The JFK assassination footage of Jackie Kennedy climbing over the car's trunk is described as disturbing and a recent revelation to the author, contrasting with their recollection of the event.
  • The Mona Lisa's smile is another example where the author's detailed study and artistic recreations of the painting differ from the current understanding of the artwork's expression.
  • The Moai statues' appearance, particularly the presence of red hats and facial features, is a significant memory discrepancy for the author, who recently researched Easter Island with their niece.
  • The author acknowledges the potential for sounding "crazy" but remains committed to exploring and sharing these experiences, despite the skepticism they may encounter.

These 5 Historical Mandela Effects will Blow Your Mind

Five historical Mandela Effects that made me question reality

photo of a shocked woman with mind exploding by Ulkar — purchased and edited by the author

Mandela Effect or False Memory?

The Mandela Effect describes a phenomenon where a large group shares memories that never happened in the current reality. The term was coined by blogger, Fiona Broome¹, because of a widespread belief that Nelson Mandela died in prison. The scientific community declares that the Mandela Effect is nothing more than shared false memories.

Common Mandela Effects like the spelling of Berenstain Bears¹ (which I always spelled Berenstein Bears ) are disconcerting. Yet, I can still easily dismiss them as false memories. However, as a life-long history buff, the following five historical Mandela Effects made me question reality.

The Lindbergh Baby

EVERETT COLLECTION/SHUTTERSTOCK

Reality:

In 1932, a man kidnapped Charles Lindbergh’s baby. The infant’s body was found two months after the kidnapping. The child had been killed by a blow to the head not long after the kidnapper abducted him.³

Mandela Effect:

The authorities never found Charles Lindbergh’s baby. No one knew what happened to him. Some theories claimed that the baby lived but never knew his true identity.

Personal Experience:

When I was growing up, my mom and I loved mysteries. We watched many documentaries about the mysterious abduction of the Lindbergh Baby. Could all of these documentaries have been wrong? Am I misremembering a subject on which I’ve watched many documentaries?

Dazzle Camouflage on War Ships

Reality:

During WWI, artist Norman Wilkinson created Dazzle Camouflage. By the end of the war, 2,300 British ships used this method to confuse enemy U-boats. ³ In WW2, this method was used on the decks of ships to confuse enemy planes.

Mandela Effect:

Dazzle Camouflage did not exist during WWI.

Personal Experience:

Dazzle Camouflage was not a military secret, and it was exciting and beautiful. I’m a history and art buff, and considering I’ve watched hundreds of documentaries on WWI, it’s difficult for me to imagine that I’ve overlooked the existence of dazzle camouflage until discovering it in 2019. It was a British camouflage, which could explain it- only I am also into all things British. It just seems like I should have seen it before now.

JFK Assassination: Jackie O. Climbs Out of Car

Reality:

The assassination of President John F. Kennedy while traveling in a Dallas motorcade had six passengers in total, including; JFK, Jackie O, Bill Greer, Roy Kellerman, and John and Nellie Connally. After the assassin shot JFK, Jackie climbed over the trunk. There are debates about why she did that. Jackie’s climb is common knowledge and filmed from multiple angles.

Mandela Effect:

The car only had four people in it. Jackie O sat, frozen as someone shot her husband. There were outcries that she was unfeeling, but doctors explained that she was simply in shock. There was absolutely no footage of Jackie O climbing across the trunk of her car.

Personal Experience:

I watched countless JFK related documentaries growing up. Seeing this new” (to me) footage of her climbing over the trunk disturbed me deeply.

Mona Lisa’s Smile

UNIVERSAL HISTORY ARCHIVE/UIG/SHUTTERSTOCK

Reality:

Mona Lisa’s Smile curves on one side, indicating a smirk if not a smile.

Mandela Effect:

The Mona Lisa did not have a discernible curl to her lip, and her cheeks were less fleshy.

Personal Experience:

I’ve drawn the Mona Lisa many times since childhood. Her mouth was severe — no slight curl on one side. It was a fun challenge to try and replicate this look. I studied the portrait with a magnifying glass, especially around the eyes and mouth, trying to discern how she seemed to be smiling without smiling.

Red Hats on Moai

photo of 3 Moai- the middle Moai wearing a red hat by Ulkar — purchased by the author

Reality:

Some Moai (Easter Island statues) wear red caps. Many of the sculptures have pointy noses. The mystery was how prehistoric inhabitants placed red hats (or top-knots) on the monoliths, and a working theory is now in place.

Mandela Effect:

The statues never had red hats, and the shape of the faces was broader with deep-set eyes and broader, flatter noses.

Personal Experience:

I have a hard time dismissing Easter Island changes as false memories. The information was fresh in my mind when I discovered this Mandela Effect because my niece and I had both recently become obsessed with researching Easter Island.

It’s not a mass misremembering. We share the Moai face and red hat changes. However, so far, only my niece and I remember the big mystery that used to shroud the island.

Sharing that info will make me sound crazy, but I’m going to share it in another article anyway because it freaks me out.

Glossary

The “Mandela Effect”: when a large group of unrelated people shares a memory that never happened in this reality. (Mandelaeffect.com) see also; false memory

Shared false memory: Multiple people saying the same false memory — the generally accepted scientific term that explains the so-called Mandela Effect.

False memory: a psychological phenomenon where a person recalls something that did not happen or happened differently from the way it happened. (Wikipedia)

Sources

¹ https://mandelaeffect.com

² http://theconversation.com/the-mandela-effect-and-how-your-mind-is-playing-tricks-on-you-89544

³ https://www.history.com/news/dazzle-camouflage-world-war-1

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-44466163

Culture
Creativity
Life
Life Lessons
Mental Health
Recommended from ReadMedium