avatarDavid C. Wyld

Summary

The article discusses the divergence in political perspectives between Democrats and Republicans, which significantly influences their opinions on various industries and can affect consumer behavior and investment strategies.

Abstract

The article, titled "The Politics of Investing Today," explores the impact of the political divide in the United States on public perception and investment in different industries. It highlights a study by YouGov, as visualized by Pallavi Rao of Visual Capitalist, showing the disparities in favorability ratings across 39 industries among Democrats and Republicans. The findings reveal a highly polarized view, with Republicans generally favoring industries like agriculture, automotive, and mining, while Democrats show more favorability towards broadcasting, education services, and technology. This polarization is seen to extend into consumer choices, such as picking sports teams based on political leanings, and has implications for corporate strategy and investment decisions, suggesting that companies and investors may need to navigate this landscape more strategically.

Opinions

  • Democrats and Republicans have starkly different views on a range of industries, as indicated by the YouGov study.
  • The author, a strategic management professor and consultant, emphasizes that these differing views have real-world consequences for companies' bottom lines and investment attractiveness.
  • Consumer spending habits and investment preferences are increasingly influenced by political stances.
  • The traditional approach of political neutrality for business, as encapsulated in Michael Jordan's quote "Republicans buy sneakers, too," may no longer be effective or practical in the current political climate.
  • Companies and executives are advised to be acutely aware of the political implications of their brand perception, as it may lead to industry-wide stereotypes and potentially impact sales, profits, and investments.
  • The author suggests that as political perspectives harden, so do the consumer perceptions of companies and industries, leading to the possibility of politically aligned investment funds.
  • Only two industries, retail and wireless carriers, were viewed similarly by both political groups, indicating an anomaly in the broader trend of polarized perceptions.

The Politics of Investing Today

Democrats and Republicans view companies and entire industries differently today based on political perspectives. Here’s a look at what this means for investing going forward in our highly polarized political environment.

Photo by Adam Nir on Unsplash

Introduction: The “Red Team” versus the “Blue Team”

We are a country divided today. We seem to be almost hopelessly divided into two camps — the “Red Team” (the Republicans) and the “Blue Team” (the Democrats). And the members of the “Red Team” and the “Blue Team” are divided over politics and, because of that, just about everything else.

Heck, we can’t even agree on how to view the budding romance between Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce due to the couple’s outspoken political and vaccine positions! Can’t we just love love anymore? Apparently not! So now, we even pick the team to pull for in the Super Bowl based on our politics.

Photo by Ümit Yıldırım on Unsplash

Political Views on Industries

Well, if we choose between the San Francisco 49ers and the Kansas City Chiefs based on our political perspective, is it any surprise that politics influences how we feel about entire industries and sectors of our economy today?

YouGov recently surveyed Americans on just this question of how politics influences how we view different industries today. The question posed by the YouGov researchers in regard to each of the 39 industries under examination was simply this:

“Generally speaking, do you have a favorable or unfavorable opinion of the following industry?”

What they found was an extremely divided America on many industries and sectors of the economy. Pallavi Rao, a data journalist with Visual Capitalist, created the infographic shown in Figure 1 (Democrats and Republicans — Divided Opinions on U.S. Industries). As you can see, from higher education to the media to technology and more, people of differing political perspectives have highly different views on various sectors of our economy today.

Figure 1: Democrats and Republicans — Divided Opinions on U.S. Industries

Source: Visual Capitalist, “How Do Democrats and Republicans Feel About Certain U.S. Industries?”, February 2024 (Used with permission).

Breaking down the numbers, there are industries that are more favorably viewed by Republicans than Democrats, and vice versa. The complete list of 39 industries/sectors included in this study is broken down in Table 1 (Democratic vs. Republican Favorability of Industries and the “Net Favorability Gap” in Each).

Table 1: Democratic vs. Republican Favorability of Industries and the “Net Favorability Gap” in Each

  • Agriculture

Democratic Favorability: 44%

Republican Favorability: 55%

Net Favorability Gap: 11%

  • Airlines

Democratic Favorability: 11%

Republican Favorability: 3%

Net Favorability Gap: 8%

  • Alcohol

Democratic Favorability: 23%

Republican Favorability: 16%

Net Favorability Gap: 7%

  • Automotive

Democratic Favorability: 19%

Republican Favorability: 36%

Net Favorability Gap: 17%

  • Book publishing

Democratic Favorability: 30%

Republican Favorability: 29%

Net Favorability Gap: 1%

  • Broadcasting

Democratic Favorability: 17%

Republican Favorability: -30%

Net Favorability Gap: 47%

  • Cable

Democratic Favorability: -12%

Republican Favorability: 3%

Net Favorability Gap: 15%

  • Construction

Democratic Favorability: 23%

Republican Favorability: 49%

Net Favorability Gap: 26%

  • Dairy

Democratic Favorability: 45%

Republican Favorability: 46%

Net Favorability Gap: 1%

  • Education services

Democratic Favorability: 21%

Republican Favorability: -16%

Net Favorability Gap: 37%

  • Entertainment

Democratic Favorability: 34%

Republican Favorability: -17%

Net Favorability Gap: 51%

  • Fashion

Democratic Favorability: 4%

Republican Favorability: -6%

Net Favorability Gap: 10%

  • Finance

Democratic Favorability: 2%

Republican Favorability: -2%

Net Favorability Gap: 4%

  • Food manufacturing

Democratic Favorability: 15%

Republican Favorability: 37%

Net Favorability Gap: 22%

  • Grocery

Democratic Favorability: 35%

Republican Favorability: 22%

Net Favorability Gap: 13%

  • Health care

Democratic Favorability: 3%

Republican Favorability: 4%

Net Favorability Gap: 1%

  • Higher education

Democratic Favorability: 45%

Republican Favorability: 0%

Net Favorability Gap: 45%

  • Hotels

Democratic Favorability: 30%

Republican Favorability: 35%

Net Favorability Gap: 5%

  • Insurance

Democratic Favorability: -12%

Republican Favorability: -14%

Net Favorability Gap: 2%

  • Manufacturing

Democratic Favorability: 27%

Republican Favorability: 53%

Net Favorability Gap: 26%

  • Mining

Democratic Favorability: -3%

Republican Favorability: 36%

Net Favorability Gap: 39%

  • News media

Democratic Favorability: 17%

Republican Favorability: -57%

Net Favorability Gap: 74%

  • Oil and gas

Democratic Favorability: -28%

Republican Favorability: 7%

Net Favorability Gap: 35%

  • Pharmaceutical

Democratic Favorability: -18%

Republican Favorability: -14%

Net Favorability Gap: -32%

  • Professional sports

Democratic Favorability: 1%

Republican Favorability: -2%

Net Favorability Gap: 3%

  • Railroads

Democratic Favorability: 37%

Republican Favorability: 35%

Net Favorability Gap: 2%

  • Real Estate

Democratic Favorability: -2%

Republican Favorability: 6%

Net Favorability Gap: 8%

  • Restaurant

Democratic Favorability: 53%

Republican Favorability: 54%

Net Favorability Gap: 1%

  • Retail

Democratic Favorability: 31%

Republican Favorability: 31%

Net Favorability Gap: 0%

  • Shipping

Democratic Favorability: 24%

Republican Favorability: 33%

Net Favorability Gap: 11%

  • Technology

Democratic Favorability: 44%

Republican Favorability: 36%

Net Favorability Gap: 8%

  • Television

Democratic Favorability: 22%

Republican Favorability: 3%

Net Favorability Gap: 19%

  • Textiles

Democratic Favorability: 24%

Republican Favorability: 34%

Net Favorability Gap: 10%

  • Tobacco

Democratic Favorability: -44%

Republican Favorability: -27%

Net Favorability Gap: 17%

  • Transportation

Democratic Favorability: 27%

Republican Favorability: 37%

Net Favorability Gap: 10%

  • Trucking

Democratic Favorability: 27%

Republican Favorability: 55%

Net Favorability Gap: 28%

  • Utilities

Democratic Favorability: 2%

Republican Favorability: 6%

Net Favorability Gap: 4%

  • Waste management

Democratic Favorability: 15%

Republican Favorability: 22%

Net Favorability Gap: 7%

  • Wireless carriers

Democratic Favorability: 19%

Republican Favorability: 19%

Net Favorability Gap: 0%

Quite amazingly, only two industries/sectors — retail and wireless carriers — were viewed similarly by Democrats and Republicans alike. In all, 16 of the industries/sectors under review were more favorably viewed by Democrats. These were:

  1. Airlines
  2. Alcohol
  3. Book publishing
  4. Broadcasting
  5. Education services
  6. Entertainment
  7. Fashion
  8. Finance
  9. Grocery
  10. Higher education
  11. Insurance
  12. News media
  13. Professional sports
  14. Railroads
  15. Technology
  16. Television

On the other hand, 21 of the industries/sectors were more favorably viewed by Republicans. These were:

  1. Agriculture
  2. Automotive
  3. Cable
  4. Construction
  5. Dairy
  6. Food manufacturing
  7. Health care
  8. Hotels
  9. Manufacturing
  10. Mining
  11. Oil and gas
  12. Pharmaceutical
  13. Real estate
  14. Restaurant
  15. Shipping
  16. Textiles
  17. Tobacco
  18. Transportation
  19. Trucking
  20. Utilities
  21. Waste management
Photo by Isaac Smith on Unsplash

Analysis and Discussion

To me, as a strategic management professor and consultant, the divisions we see today between Democrats and Republicans in their views on entire companies and industries are much more than an academic concern. They have real-world consequences for companies, both large and small alike. Indeed, the way we spend, how much we spend, and where we spend may be significantly influenced by our political outlooks today. And when it comes to investing, the companies and sectors we invest in may indeed be guided — consciously or even unconsciously — by our political philosophy.

The famous Michael Jordan quote why he didn’t speak out politically was, “Republicans buy sneakers, too!” Today, however, that may not be a practical and effective guiding philosophy for companies to follow. Our political stances seem to be hardening, and with that, the way we view companies and entire industries is hardening at the same time. It is going to become more and more difficult for companies to balance their approaches to cater to people of all political stripes. Indeed, they are more likely to be painted with a “broad brush” as being a company in the news media that Republicans dislike or a mining company that Democrats distrust, no matter what they individually do. Thus, investments may well become more and more politicized as well, with even industry mutual funds that would cater more to Democratic or Republican interests.

So yes, perceptions do matter — and matter a great deal — today. Companies and their top executives thus need to be keenly aware of just how much political differences can lead to differing perceptions about their firms and their industries today, leading to bottom-line impacts in terms of sales, profits, and investments.

Professor David C. Wyld

About David Wyld

David C. Wyld is a Professor of Strategic Management at Southeastern Louisiana University in Hammond, Louisiana. He is a management consultant, researcher/writer, publisher, executive educator, and experienced expert witness. You can view all of his work at https://authory.com/DavidWyld. You can subscribe to his Medium article feed at https://davidwyld.medium.com/subscribe.

Social Media Links to David Wyld:

Visit us at DataDrivenInvestor.com

Subscribe to DDIntel here.

Have a unique story to share? Submit to DDIntel here.

Join our creator ecosystem here.

DDIntel captures the more notable pieces from our main site and our popular DDI Medium publication. Check us out for more insightful work from our community.

DDI Official Telegram Channel: https://t.me/+tafUp6ecEys4YjQ1

Follow us on LinkedIn, Twitter, YouTube, and Facebook.

Politics
Investing
Personal Finance
News
Business
Recommended from ReadMedium
avatarSamanta Writes
12 Signs of a Highly Unintelligent Person According to Science

3. Nodding Your Head

5 min read
avatarDavid C. Wyld
The Diverse States of America — and American Business

In an increasingly diverse country, the data demonstrates the impact of diversity in our lives and in our workplaces. The companies that…

9 min read
avatarJennifer Hartmann
The Question That Ended My Marriage

In a rare moment of vulnerability, I asked my husband this question, and knew I’d just empowered us to divorce.

6 min read
avatarLevi Borba
7 Countries Expats Are Fleeing Like the Plague

(And Where They’re Going)

9 min read
avatarMichelle Teheux
We Could Learn a Lot About Sex From the Dutch

My Dutch relative’s views shocked me, but I immediately realized she was right

6 min read
avatarRenee Hannes
The Gentle Art of Strolling Through Paris as a Flâneur

How to embrace the beauty of everyday moments in Paris

5 min read