The Difference Between Good Movies and Entertaining Movies
And why a movie doesn’t have to be both.
I am not a huge movie person. I have a handful of movies and movie franchises that I enjoy, but by and large, I am not the type to watch a particular movie every year on a particular date for some reason or another. For me, movies are entertainment, but not necessarily something I pin my life to.
That’s not to say I look down on people who do those things. I’m a big fan of fandom in general, and as long as you’re not really bothering anyone with your fandom or being a gatekeeper, I don’t care what you do.
Do you want to hold an annual marathon of the Marvel Cinematic Universe through Endgame to see which of your friends can stay awake for the whole thing? Go for it. Do you spend your entire May 4th binging Star Wars movies? Sure, whatever makes you happy.
I do enjoy movies, however — I saw the first Avengers on opening night at midnight with a bunch of friends, and it is one of my favorite movie experiences of all time. As a kid, I watched the re-release of the original Star Wars trilogy in the 90s, and it turned me onto the franchise to the point where I spent the next decade absorbing as much Star Wars media as I could.
All of this is to say that I have a certain understanding of how movies can inspire people, to make them excited about something in what may otherwise be a bleak existence. Movies are important to a lot of people, and everyone has different tastes.
That said, I don’t particularly appreciate it when people crap all over summer blockbusters and popcorn movies. There is a whole group of people that will take every opportunity to beat up on Star Wars, or the Transformers franchise, or the Fast and the Furious franchise, or any of the over-the-top big-budget movies.
First off, why waste your energy? You’re not convincing anyone, you just feel like complaining about something. Second off, who cares? So what if Star Wars isn’t high art on the level of Citizen Kane? It doesn’t have to be good to be entertaining.
This is a distinction that I think a lot of people miss when it comes to movies and media in general. Something doesn’t have to be good to be entertaining. In fact, something can be the opposite of good and still be entertaining. The movie The Room is widely considered one of the worst movies of all time, but people love to watch it. Heck, the existence of Mystery Science Theatre 3000 and RiffTrax proves the popularity of watching bad movies because they’re bad.
So watching bad movies because they’re bad is fine, but what about those big summer blockbusters that are jam-packed with explosions and light on exposition? They may not be bad, per se, but they’re definitely not going to win any awards for their dramatic storytelling.
Herein lies the point. When I judge a movie (or other media), I do so on a scale of good vs. entertaining. A movie can be good (i.e. Citizen Kane, which is considered a fantastic movie) and not necessarily be particularly entertaining (many people don’t care for the amount of exposition in it). On the flip side, a movie can be entertaining (Take your pick of summer blockbusters) and not necessarily be good (it can keep you on the edge of your seat throughout the runtime, but you won’t remember a thing about it an hour later).
There are plenty of movies that come out every year that are considered good but not entertaining. These are often called “Oscar bait,” and their sole purpose is to win “artsy” awards like Best Screenplay and such. They often don’t make a ton of money at the box office, but that’s not the point of them.
On the flipside, Michael Bay has made a career out of making entertaining movies that are, just, not very good. The Transformers franchise has made almost $5 billion at the box office, despite having mostly bad reviews from critics. However, despite the various plot holes, inconsistencies, poor acting, and generally bad scripts, audiences love them because HOLY CRAP IT’S THE TRANSFORMERS GUYS!
And you know what? There’s nothing wrong with that. Plenty of people go to the movies to watch a good movie, but plenty of people go to movies to be entertained. I saw Star Wars: The Force Awakens twice in the theater. Both times I enjoyed the movie thoroughly, and both times I left the theater and reflected on how, generally speaking, it wasn’t a great movie.
This approach can be taken with any media. Many people have shows they like despite them not being terribly good — reality TV tends to get lumped in here. Plenty of people read trashy romance novels despite (or perhaps because) of the fact that they’re terrible. There are plenty of terrible video games that people will play and beat just to say that they did, and they often have fun doing it.
Sometimes, I think we get hung up on whether a piece of media is good and miss the point of whether it fulfills its role in the world: to entertain. James Cameron’s Avatar was, by all accounts, hackneyed and derivative, but that didn’t stop it from making a billion dollars. People liked it, and they went to the theater in droves to watch it. And that’s okay.
I think what this all boils down to is this: let people like things. I’m serious. Too many people bash on movies or comics or books that are “bad” even though they’re popular. To these gatekeepers, liking something that falls into this category makes you a shallow, dumb person — the thing you like is bad and you should feel bad.
Why, though? Why can’t people just like the things they like without it being a value judgment on their character? Why does liking popular things make you bad or dumb? Why does liking a big-budget popcorn flick make you shallow? Why can’t people read trashy romance novels without being judged?
There is no reason for any of it. People are different and like different things. Just because you like something considered “high art” doesn’t make that thing more worthwhile than something popular. Popular things are popular for a reason: because they have mass appeal. Sure, they may not be art pieces or even terribly good at all, but that doesn’t mean we need to crap all over people who like them.
So, next time you see something that seems shallow or bad but is inexplicably popular and decide that you need to bitch about how bad that thing is to anyone who will listen, I have a piece of advice for you: just don’t. Everyone will be better off for it.
If you liked this, please subscribe to my publication, Thing a Day. I publish something every day on a variety of topics, so you never know what you’re going to see!
Here are some other things I’ve written:






