avatarRemington Write

Summary

The author expresses a personal aversion to Christmas, criticizing its capitalist nature and environmental impact, while sharing their experience of opting out of the holiday.

Abstract

The article titled "Slouching Away From Bethlehem" presents a critical view of Christmas, questioning why a capitalist and environmentally harmful holiday is so widely embraced. The author, Remington Write, recounts their journey from participating in the holiday to eventually rejecting it entirely, highlighting the excessive waste produced during the season, the emotional letdown after the festivities, and the societal pressure to conform. They advocate for a more mindful approach to the holiday, suggesting the reuse of materials and questioning the necessity of gift-giving. The author also reflects on the challenges of navigating Christmas Day in New York City when most services are closed and shares their preference for alternative activities, such as attending a Monty Python film screening and enjoying a kosher Chinese buffet. The piece concludes with a recognition of the privilege of being able to opt out of Christmas, particularly without children, and a call to consider the environmental consequences of holiday consumption.

Opinions

  • The author is critical of the capitalist underpinnings of Christmas and the societal expectation to participate in the holiday.
  • They are concerned about the environmental impact of Christmas, citing the significant increase in waste during the holiday season.
  • The author describes a sense of disillusionment with the holiday, recalling a feeling of emptiness after the excitement of gift-opening as a child.
  • They believe that the holiday season is overly commercialized and promotes unnecessary consumption.
  • The author values the freedom of choosing not to celebrate Christmas and the ability to avoid the associated stress and preparations.
  • They express solidarity with others who opt out of Christmas, acknowledging the peer pressure and judgment they may face.
  • The article suggests that having children makes it more difficult to avoid celebrating Christmas due to societal norms and expectations.
  • The author appreciates the quietness of the city on Christmas Day and enjoys activities that remain open, like Chinese restaurants.
  • They reference the work of Joan Didion and W.B. Yeats, indicating a literary influence on their perspective.
  • The author invites readers to join their mailing list, suggesting a desire to connect with like-minded individuals.

Slouching Away From Bethlehem*

For those of us not interested in Being Of Good Cheer

Courtesy of WikiMedia Commons

I am not a Scrooge or a Grinch. But I have no use for this holiday.

I don’t hate Christmas but I do wonder why so many otherwise thoughtful, intelligent, even progressive people are completely on board with this most blatantly capitalist boondoggle. Just the amount of trash going into landfills should give users of Christmas pause.

According to Stanford University Press:

Americans throw away 25% more trash during the Thanksgiving to New Year’s holiday period than any other time of year. The extra waste amounts to 25 million tons of garbage, or about 1 million extra tons per week!

If every family reused just two feet of holiday ribbon, the 38,000 miles of ribbon saved could tie a bow around the entire planet. If every American family wrapped just 3 presents in re-used materials, it would save enough paper to cover 45,000 football fields. The 2.65 billion Christmas cards sold each year in the U.S. could fill a football field 10 stories high. If we each sent one card less, we’d save 50,000 cubic yards of paper.

I still clearly remember that kind of sick feeling as a kid sitting in my grandmother’s living room surrounded by piles of ripped gift wrapping and cast aside boxes after the flurry of opening presents as if we’d all eaten too many sweets. All the weeks of anticipation lead to…….this?

As an adult, I used to try and recreate the holiday but it felt like the only thing I was able to recreate was the sickening feeling when it was all over. Now for the big clean-up. About twenty years ago I had the revelation that I didn’t have to do any of it. I didn’t have to buy anything. I didn’t have to give anyone any gifts. I didn’t have to lug a tree in and trim it or cook too much food. Moreover, I didn’t have to accept presents either.

I quit Christmas

I will say that ignoring Christmas and even New Year’s in New York City is easier than it was back in Cleveland and orders of magnitude easier than in any of the small towns I managed to escape.

Even so, navigating the holiday requires ingenuity and fortitude.

After weeks of stress and preparation here comes the Big Let-down and, while I’ve long distanced myself from that happy horseshit, I still have to figure out how to maneuver through the various obstacles to everyday life that still get thrown in everyone’s path on Christmas. The subways don’t run often and forget about buses. Fortunately, I like Chinese food because those restaurants will all be open. An upside is finding entire swaths of town which are usually packed with rushing crowds to be deserted (Times Square is not ever deserted, however, so don’t bother).

However, all the stores will either be closed or closing early so I’d better be sure to have whatever I’ll need for the day. It is my incredible good luck that my partner is not of the holiday persuasion so it’s that much easier to hole up and ignore the whole show. Here’s his take on the madness:

For years, however, I was on my own when it came to negotiating The Day

Probably the best Christmas I can remember was the year that William, John, Chris and I went down to the new Tribeca performance space for the 92nd Street Y (As in Young Men’s Hebrew Association not to be confused with the YMCA, also a fine organization if a little less in touch culturally). They were having a Monty Python double feature, “Monty Python and The Holy Grail” and “The Life of Brian”, followed by a kosher Chinese buffet. It was absolutely glorious.

It is an unfortunate truth that if you have children and are not a Jehovah’s Witness, you’re pretty much trapped into Christmas. That’s really awful because this holiday is nothing more than an indoctrination into Buy More Stuff.

It’s Capitalism 101 and it is mandatory

I realize that I’m in a tiny minority but there are more of us every year. We get shushed and called names and even pitied by our Christmas-blinded peers. That’s ok. We save hundreds of dollars and never have to subject ourselves to holiday travel or sitting next to extended family members who either drink too much or extol the virtues of (fill in the blank here; there are many choices).

So, yes, I understand that my ability to step away from the madness is a privilege that was made much easier by not having, or wanting, kids. And, yes, I get it that anyone who chooses to quit Christmas is in for some heavy peer pressure. But take a look at how quickly we’re decimating our habitable bits of planet and make your choices.

See you on the other side!

© Remington Write 2019. All Rights Reserved

*Apologies to Joan Didion and W.B.Yeats

Add your name, join my readers:

Christmas
Capitalism
Consumerism
Waste
Rant
Recommended from ReadMedium