avatarCeleste Wilson

Summary

The author reflects on the insincerity of secondhand generosity, using the example of a family member who gifted his wife an expensive gold chain he no longer wanted, to highlight the importance of genuine gifts as a reflection of true value and care for the recipient.

Abstract

The article discusses the concept of secondhand generosity, questioning its sincerity and value. The author recounts an incident where a typically frugal family member purchased an expensive gold chain for himself, only to pass it on to his wife as a gift when he decided it didn't suit him. This act, which the author perceives as an insult, underscores the idea that gifts should be a genuine expression of appreciation and care for the recipient, rather than a means of dispensing with unwanted items. The author contrasts this with their own experience of rejecting a similar 'gift', choosing to value their self-worth over accepting an insincere gesture. The article concludes with a call to readers to support the author by joining Medium, emphasizing the importance of sincere writing and storytelling.

Opinions

  • The author believes that true generosity involves giving gifts that reflect the value one places on the recipient, not just disposing of personal buyer's remorse items.
  • Gifts should be thoughtful and given with sincerity, not as an afterthought or a way to alleviate the giver's guilt or regret.
  • The act of giving a spouse an expensive item that was initially bought for oneself and later discarded is seen as an insult to the spouse's worth.
  • The author values self-respect and authenticity in gift-giving, advocating for the rejection of gifts that lack genuine intention.
  • The author feels that the wife's excitement over the secondhand gift reveals a lack of recognition of the insincerity behind it, which the author finds disheartening.
  • The article suggests that readers should consider the true meaning behind acts of generosity, both in giving and receiving.

Secondhand Generosity Is Not Generosity

When I receive a gift, I assume it’s because I’m valued. Gifts represent a sense of care.

Image by Starbright on Pixabay

Selfish Spending

I feel a bit silly for being upset about this, but I am.

A family member bought himself an expensive gold chain. He’s a penny pincher, so the purchase was surprising. He rarely bought his wife jewelry and had never given her an expensive gift like this.

He counted his money and bragged about having a large savings account. He was going to retire with wealth and comfort. We were reminded every time we visited.

He once complained about the price of bubble bath. Yet, he could buy himself an expensive gift. He didn’t even buy his wife flowers. He would tell her that she had flowers in the garden. Why should he buy her flowers that will just die in a vase?

I honestly have to bite my tongue in these conversations.

Secondhand Giving

About a month after buying himself the very manly heavy gold chain, he decided it didn’t suit him and told his wife that she could have it.

My heart broke into pieces when she showed it to me. She was excited about the ‘gift’.

I gritted my teeth into a smile which probably looked more like a grimace. This was not a gift! This was an expensive buyer’s regret hand me down from a husband to a wife.

She genuinely didn’t see the insincerity.

I did.

I also saw the insult. Now that he didn’t see the value in the gold chain, it suddenly became enough to give to his wife.

This secondhand generosity was not generosity at all. It was blaringly obvious that he didn’t value her.

My Trigger

This happened years ago, but when something similar happened to me recently, it triggered the memory.

Unlike the wife in this story, I politely rejected the ‘gift’. I was labeled as ungrateful.

The difference here is that I recognized the insincerity and I value myself. So, no thanks, keep your ‘gift’.

Thank you

Thank you for reading my article. I really appreciate your support and interest. To read more of my articles click here. https://medium.com/@cwstoryteller

Join Medium

Please consider joining Medium for $5 a month to get full access to all the incredible writers on the platform. Your membership supports writers like myself to continue doing what we love most. To write and entertain.

Please click on my referral link below to join.

Another article from Celeste that you might enjoy reading.

Billet-Doux — A short Love Note

Women
Relationships
Abuse
Lack Of Care
Gift Giving Etiquette
Recommended from ReadMedium