avatarTom Navratil

Summary

The Writers' Group has established stringent rules for their annual Pumpkin Carving Contest to prevent plagiarism and ensure originality.

Abstract

In response to the previous year's controversies, the Writers' Group has revised the guidelines for their Halloween Pumpkin Carving Contest. The new rules emphasize the importance of originality by prohibiting imitations, appropriations, and any form of derivation from another writer's work. The updated parameters are designed to foster a fair and creative environment, where each participant is encouraged to develop their own unique jack-o'-lantern design without copying, referencing, or mocking others' ideas or personal attributes. The guidelines also explicitly ban any entries that could be considered offensive or inappropriate, including those shaped like or commenting on human anatomy.

Opinions

  • The organizers are concerned with maintaining fairness and creativity in the contest.
  • There is a clear disapproval of past incidents of plagiarism and imitation.
  • The tone suggests frustration with the complexity of the rules, implying that common sense and respect for originality should be sufficient guidelines.
  • The author expresses exasperation at having to spell out what should be obvious: that each participant should create an original work without stealing or mocking others.
  • There is an underlying desire for the contest to be fun and a showcase of individual talent, free from negativity and derision.
  • The instructions to "sharpen those knives" for pumpkin carving, not for personal attacks, indicates a wish for a friendly competition focused on the craft rather than rivalry.

HALLOWEEN FUN

Revised Rules for Writers’ Group Pumpkin Carving Contest

Imitation is NOT the sincerest form of flattery

Photo by Blaz Photo on Unsplash

Dear Authors:

In light of the truly frightening controversies that arose from last year’s jack-o’-lantern competition, we have updated our guidelines. To ensure a level pumpkin patch, please follow these parameters so we all may enjoy this alternative outlet for our creative energies:

1. No copying another writer’s carving.

2. No appropriating.

3. Do not sample another writer’s work.

4. Retellings are ineligible for the contest.

5. Do not claim someone else’s pumpkin as your own, even if you change a line here or there.

6. Homages are not permitted.

7. Taking someone else’s pumpkin and repurposing it, however transformatively, will result in expulsion from the contest.

8. Faces or figures based on characters in another writer’s work are not allowed. Not even as a fangirl or fanboy.

9. Do not submit alternative versions, sequels, or spinoffs of any jack-o’-lantern created by another writer. Moreover, and this really should go without saying, no smashing another contestant’s pumpkin.

10. Mockery is also not the sincerest form of flattery. Arguably, it is the very opposite of flattery. Your carving is not the place to call out a colleague’s personality traits or scoff at their behavior.

11. While humorous entries are permitted, do not choose a pumpkin shaped like a butt and then scratch someone else’s name on it.

12. In fact, do not use your entry to refer to, or comment in any way on, any colleague’s buttocks or other personal areas.

13. Anyone who stuffs two pumpkins into a giant brassiere will be automatically disqualified.

14. Penis-shaped pumpkins, gourds, squash, etc. — circumcised or not — are not eligible for the contest.

I hope that covers everything. Jeez. It shouldn’t have to be this complicated. Just buy, not steal, a pumpkin. Open a hole in the top; remove the pulp; cut out a face; stick in a candle. Is that really too much to ask?

Now sharpen those knives — not the metaphorical ones, please — and get carving! Pumpkins, not each other.

Halloween
Writing
Plagiarism
Humor
Pumpkin
Recommended from ReadMedium