Ongoing Dispute in Concholakeland Subdivision Raises Questions About Property Rights and Law Enforcement’s Role
Date: July 30, 2023
https://youtu.be/DoEmY56KDzA https://youtu.be/i825lL2BSNw https://youtu.be/T86tYEW4ndY https://youtu.be/yJV3r0MRpgQ
In a continuing saga of disputes, a third encounter occurred in the Concholakeland subdivision in Vernon, AZ, on July 29th, 2023, adding to the growing concerns surrounding property rights and law enforcement's response. This latest incident involved two individuals claiming ownership of a property without presenting a warranty deed or bill of sale, leading to tensions with the Concholakeland Homeowners Association (HOA) and the Apache County Sheriff's office.
According to residents of the Concholakeland subdivision, the two individuals, who identified themselves as Aaron Luna, approached the west half of Concholakeland unit 6, stating they had purchased a property within the subdivision. However, when the Concholakeland HOA checked the Apache County parcel viewer, they found no lots registered under Aaron Luna's name, raising doubts about the validity of the claim.
As per the HOA's guidelines and governing documents, any new property owner must be approved by the HOA and complete an application process before taking possession of the property. As Aaron Luna had not gone through this process, the HOA informed him that he was not approved and that they would serve him with court documents.
In response, Aaron Luna called the police. While waiting for law enforcement to arrive, the Concholakeland HOA told the Apache County Sheriff’s office to inform them about the situation. However, to their surprise, the Sheriff’s office allegedly refused to remove the individuals from the property, even though they lacked a warranty deed or bill of sale despite potentially leaving liabilities for injuries within the undeveloped area.
The Sheriff's office reportedly cited the need for a judge's order to remove the individuals, despite the fact that Arizona law defines unauthorized entry onto private property as third-degree trespassing. This contradiction has sparked further concerns among the Concholakeland residents about the enforcement of property rights and the role of law enforcement in such disputes.
The Concholakeland HOA maintains and pays for the private N roads that serves the subdivision, as confirmed by the county engineers. However, the repeated encounters with the Sheriff’s office have led to conflicting interpretations of the HOA’s rights to control access of the incorporated subdivision.
Community members in Concholakeland are calling for a resolution to the ongoing issues, seeking clarity on their property rights and the enforcement of trespassing laws. Residents are urging the Sheriff's office to consider the county engineers' statement that N roads, including the one in question, are not part of the county's inventory and are maintained by private entities, such as HOAs.
The situation in Concholakeland has raised important questions about the balance between property rights, law enforcement's role, and the need for proper legal authorization to address trespassing issues effectively. As the dispute continues, residents are hoping for constructive engagement between the Concholakeland HOA, law enforcement, and legal experts to find a resolution that upholds the principles of justice and respects individual property rights.
It remains essential for all parties involved to approach the matter with restraint and respect for the rule of law. The community's cooperation with law enforcement and a thorough understanding of applicable laws and regulations are critical in resolving the dispute and fostering a harmonious relationship between property owners and the authorities that serve them.