Summary

Baseball's ongoing lockout, resulting from failed labor negotiations, threatens the sport's popularity and future in the United States.

Abstract

Baseball has entered a precarious phase as the expiration of the labor agreement without a new deal has led to a lockout, putting the sport's credibility and relevance at risk. The impasse is due to disagreements over playoff expansion, minimum salaries, luxury tax thresholds, and more, with both players and owners entrenched in their positions. The players, feeling shortchanged in the 2016 agreement, are resistant to compromising, while owners cite financial losses due to Covid-19. This situation could accelerate baseball's decline in popularity, especially among the younger generation, who are increasingly drawn to other sports and forms of entertainment. The lockout underscores baseball's failure to effectively market its players and the game, which is compounded by the sport's reluctance to adapt to modern times and embrace change.

Opinions

The author believes that both the players and the owners are at fault for the lockout and the potential damage to the sport.
There is a perception that baseball is not doing enough to promote its players or the game, which is partly attributed to the players' lack of personal branding efforts.
The author suggests that even the emergence of a charismatic, dominant player may not be enough to revive baseball's popularity in the current climate.
The author criticizes Major League Baseball for not learning from past mistakes, such as alienating players from the steroid era who helped popularize the sport.
The author implies that society's tendency to move on quickly from pastimes, combined with the abundance of entertainment options, could lead to baseball's diminished status if significant changes are not made.
The author expresses disappointment on behalf of the fans, who are excluded from the decision-making process, and emphasizes the urgency for both sides to reach an agreement to prevent irreparable harm to the sport.

NO DEAL!!!!

Baseball’s lockout could have a catastrophic impact on the future of the game

Baseball is on the verge of a catastrophic mistake!

When the deadline to reach a labor agreement expired on Monday at 4 pm, baseball entered a familiar territory where the credibility and relevance of their game are once again on the line.

Make no mistake about it, both sides are to blame!

Some of the sticking points surrounding the negotiations are the number of teams to make the playoffs, minimum salaries, luxury tax thresholds, etc.

Like most negotiations, both sides have to talk in good faith and be willing to take a little less than they may desire. The players feel like they got hosed during the 2016 agreements so they are unlikely to bend too much.

As a fan looking from the outside, one would think that the 2 sides would have been able to reach an agreement before a lockout occurred.

But, here we are! The players claim they simply want to play baseball, and the owners are shouting they have a business to run and Covid has cost them a lot of money.

Both sides seem to misunderstand the real implications of their disagreement, which is baseball becoming a forgotten sport in the United States.

We still call baseball America’s favorite pastime just like we call the Dallas Cowboys America’s Team. Neither is true, but we don’t often like to change catchy slogans.

Baseball is the 3rd most popular sport in this country and this lockout could cause them to slip even further in sports popularity.

Every day, you see young fans on Twitter, having debates and ridiculing others on their sports takes regarding basketball and football.

You never really see anyone under 25 debating who is the better player between Juan Soto or Fernando Tatis Jr. Baseball simply doesn’t generate the same type of interest as the other 2 sports amongst the younger crowd.

The sport has been in decline for many years but this season, they could lose the younger crowd for good.

We already have more distractions than ever before with social media, video games, television streaming options, etc. It has become very easy for young adults to find something to do rather than watch sports.

I’m sure that Rob Manfred and other baseball purists would argue that Covid hurt the game more than other sports but the real fact is that the game has done an extremely poor job of marketing their players.

The players themselves are partly to blame as they could take a bigger interest in creating their brands.

I recently saw a thread on Twitter that compared the social media following of Angels start Outfielder Mike Trout vs. Miami Heat guard Tyler Herro.

Herro had a significantly larger following than Trout, who is undoubtedly the best player in the game and a 3-time MVP. Herro, on the other hand, is a good player for the Miami Heat, but nowhere near an all-star at this point of his career.

Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa saved baseball with their home run race in 1998, a few years after the last baseball strike.

Following that historic moment in baseball was some of the most dominating seasons the game has ever seen by slugger Barry Bonds.

Since then, MLB has turned its backs on these players due to their connection to steroids, even though the league profited off the era tremendously.

I’m not sure there would be anything that could save the game this time around. We as a society tend to move on from things quicker than in the past.

Even If an American-born, charismatic, superstar came into the league and dominated from early on, I doubt that fans would gravitate towards him the same way they would a player in the NFL or NBA.

Baseball simply doesn’t do enough to promote the players or the game. It might be that MLB is trying to operate In the same manner as in the past but until significant changes are made, the game will continue to lose its luster.

As far as the lockout goes, the players seem to be dug in. I’m not sure that owners and players will be reaching an agreement anytime soon.

It’s a huge disappointment to the fans of the game who once again, don’t get a seat at the table. Let’s hope for the future of baseball that a deal is made before it’s too late.

Join Medium with my referral link - Justin Stinnett

As a Medium member, a portion of your membership fee goes to writers you read, and you get full access to every story…

justin-stinnett82.medium.com

Sources:

https://legacy.baseballprospectus.com/compensation/cots/league-info/cba-history/