Short Story, Erotica

Jennifer and Amber

Those you meet online might not always be who you think they are

“Nothing’s wrong, love. Really.”

Nathan looked straight into her eyes and seemed sincere, but doubt still gnawed deep inside her. Intuitively, Jennifer knew something was wrong. During their lovemaking, he seemed absent. It wasn’t the same as it had once been.

They had been married for some years and even though they didn’t have kids, and they always had fun together, their marriage had settled into a routine. Experimenting with sex was something they didn’t do anymore. The unexpected romantic weekend away didn’t happen either due to their busy careers. Jennifer frequently thought about arranging something to surprise Nathan, like a striptease or an erotic massage, but most weekends she only wanted one thing: to sleep as much as possible.

It’s time to get into action, Jen!

With this thought, Jennifer instantly got up.

She smiled at Nathan, who looked at her in surprise, and disappeared into the bedroom. In the adjoining bathroom, she quickly took a shower. Fifteen minutes later, she walked back into the living room, dressed in a black thong and a transparent black piece of fabric, which was supposed to represent a nightie. Black stiletto heels completed the picture.

When Jennifer entered the living room, she was just in time to see Nathan quickly putting his phone away. For a moment, she wanted to ask him what he had been doing, but in her mind she reminded herself: no Jennifer, let’s keep it nice.

Swaying her hips and taking small steps, she walked to Nathan and stood in front of him, her legs spread. Her intentions were clear. Nathan involuntarily looked at her crotch, then up to her full breasts and back down to her feet. Jennifer waited until he looked at her face again, but the lust she had expected in his eyes wasn’t there.

“Jenny,” he said, “not now. We need to talk.”

“Nathan?”

“Sit down, Jennifer,” he said and impatience sounded in his voice.

“Nathan, what’s going on with you?”

Jennifer was also irritated now. First, he told her nothing was wrong, and then all of a sudden, he wanted to talk, ignoring her being in the mood. Sort of. She was at least making an effort.

His voice interrupted her thoughts.

“Jennifer, I want more.”

“More? What do you mean? You want me to suck you?”

“No, of course not!”

The fierceness in his voice startled her.

“What then, Nathan? What do you want? Just tell me!”

“You know I love you, Jenny,” Nathan started, “but I also have feelings for other women.”

“Women?” Jennifer could hardly believe her ears. Was he trying to tell her he had cheated on her with more than one woman?

“Yes, I don’t believe I can be monogamous. I don’t want to lose you, Jenny, but I also want relationships with other women.”

Perplexed, Jennifer just looked at him. What the hell was wrong with Nathan? She had never heard about this before.

“Women, Nathan? Are you telling me you have relationships with more than one woman?”

“No… eh… no… not really… not actual relationships. Okay, relationships, but only online.”

A fantastic story unfolded as Nathan started talking.

For months now, he had been a member of a dating site where people, besides their own relationships, could approach a secondary relationship to get some excitement back into their lives. He hadn’t wanted to tell Jennifer anything, afraid of her reaction, but he was at a point where he wanted to meet some of those women in real life.

“I don’t want to cheat, Jenny. If we both have relationships with others, we will get some excitement back in our own life.”

Weeks later, Jennifer sat behind the computer, creating a profile on the dating site. She had already found Nathan’s profile, but it took some courage to create her own. No, she had no desire to meet any other men. Nathan was enough for her; the only man she wanted.

Unfortunately, he felt differently.

The evening of that conversation, she had gone to bed like every other night. His decision was made. Jennifer would not beg him.

The weeks after their conversation were rather normal, they even had more sex than the weeks before.

Delicious sex!

For a few moments, she had wondered whether Nathan was right, until a plan started forming in her mind. And here she was, looking at her own profile, or rather, the profile of Amber.

Amber’s profile made them a perfect match: Nathan and Amber. The dating site tipped Amber to contact Nathan. But she didn’t. She wanted Nathan to take the first step. As an extra incentive, there was the profile photo. Nathan was a man who loved looking at women’s bottoms, and he would certainly love this one.

Jennifer had to try several times to take a photo of her own bottom before she finally succeeded. In the black-and-white photo, she faced away from the camera while kneeling, her bottom resting on her feet. Her bottom and back formed one straight line. She had experimented with the image in an editing program, and before long, the profile photo of Amber was unrecognizable.

Two days later, Amber received her first message from Nathan.

Jennifer sat on the bed with her laptop. Nathan was in the study, supposedly working. His message was full of praise for her profile picture and he asked her a couple of personal things. Amber answered cautiously, with one or two questions thrown in to keep the conversation going. She didn’t want to come across as being too eager.

Messages followed in rapid succession until Amber had enough and told him she wanted to go to bed. Nathan wished her a good night, ending his message with several kisses. Jennifer put her laptop away. When Nathan entered the room, she pretended she’d been watching a movie. Nathan was in an exceptionally good mood.

“I’m tired, Nathan,” she said when he slipped into bed next to her and covered her pussy with his hand. Knowing that his joy and excitement came from talking to the sexy, fictional personality had angered her.

For weeks, they sent each other messages.

Nathan tried everything to get Amber to agree to a meeting, but every time she had another excuse about why she couldn’t meet him.

Nathan was head-over-heels in love.

Since that first evening speaking to Amber, he had been in a good mood and was overly attentive to Jennifer’s needs. After that first night, Jennifer had not refused him sex again. They kissed like two young lovers and tried positions they had long forgotten.

“You’re in love, Nathan,” Jennifer said one night, still out of breath after their fierce lovemaking.

“Yes,” Nathan admitted, and Jennifer was surprised that he didn’t deny it.

“Tell me about her?” Jennifer asked, and Nathan did.

“… and I cannot wait to meet her. I’m also thankful to her, because if it wasn’t for Amber, our sex life would not have been as exciting as it has been these past weeks,” Nathan concluded.

The next day, Amber finally agreed to meet Nathan.

That night Nathan jumped on the bed like an excited child, pulled the covers from Jennifer and roughly spread her legs. He buried his face between her thighs and firmly licked her. A wonderful shiver ran through Jennifer, and for a couple of seconds she felt guilty about Amber, but soon she was only aware of the lovely sensations between her legs.

Nathan didn’t only lick her, but also massaged her pussy lips between his fingers, like only he could. An orgasm overwhelmed her, and just before her second orgasm, she felt a finger entering her ass. Jennifer arched her back in pleasure until another climax took hold. Nathan pushed her legs up and held the tip of his cock at her entrance, teasing her for a couple of seconds before he buried his cock deep in her cunt.

Two nights later, they were both getting ready to go out.

Nathan had an appointment with Amber, and Jennifer was going to the movies with a friend. Jennifer’s laptop was on the table, with Amber’s profile picture on her screen. Nathan entered the room while Jennifer painted her nails.

“Oh,” Nathan said, “I see you have Amber’s profile on your screen.”

“Yes,” Jennifer said with a sweet smile, looking up at Nathan, “I’m changing my profile pic. I’m tired of this one.”

If you’re thinking of joining Medium, click on my referral link to support me and other writers.

Find more of Marie on her lists, and here…