avatarThe Good Men Project

Summary

The article emphasizes the importance of respecting a person's, particularly young girls', right to consent to physical affection, such as hugs, and the potential harm of disregarding their discomfort.

Abstract

The article "It Is Not ‘Just’ a Hug" by Amanda Dettloff, published on The Good Men Project, argues for the respect of personal boundaries, especially in the case of young girls who are often pressured to show physical affection, such as hugging, against their will. Dettloff illustrates this with a personal account of being coerced into hugging her boyfriend's friend despite feeling uncomfortable, and her boyfriend's dismissal of her feelings. The piece underscores the long-term impact of such experiences, which can teach individuals that their comfort and consent are secondary to others', a lesson that often persists into adulthood. The author advocates for allowing individuals, regardless of age or gender, to say no to unwanted physical contact, thereby promoting a culture of consent and respect for personal boundaries.

Opinions

  • Forcing girls to be affectionate when they don't want to is wrong and can have lasting negative effects.
  • It is crucial to support individuals, particularly children, when they express discomfort with physical contact.
  • Dismissing someone's discomfort for the sake of another's feelings can be hurtful and disrespectful.
  • The societal expectation that women and girls should prioritize others' emotional comfort over their own physical and emotional comfort is damaging.
  • The author's personal experience highlights the importance of believing and supporting individuals who set boundaries regarding their bodies.
  • The article suggests that the issue of consent and personal boundaries is not limited to extreme cases but is also relevant in everyday social interactions.
  • The author implies that the lessons learned in childhood about consent and bodily autonomy can shape adult behavior and attitudes towards consent.

It Is Not ‘Just’ a Hug

Allow your daughters to say no when they don’t want to hug people.

Photo credit: Shutterstock

By Amanda Dettloff

Hugging and cuddling are wonderful ways to connect with family and loved ones. But in all seriousness — stop forcing girls to hug and be cuddly when they don’t want to. Or any child for that matter. They only thing they learn is that the emotional comfort, which is usually not feeling the sadness of rejection, of the people around them is more important than their own. Shaming language for refusing to touch their body to another human doesn’t end when they grow up either.

At the age of 23, I had a boyfriend. My boyfriend had friends some of whom I got along well with and some that I did not. There was one friend in particular that made me very uncomfortable. I still could not say why, but he did. This friend started to want hugs. At first, I complied, keeping the peace and not making an awkward scene with friends around seemed like the easier option. I hated every moment of it. I eventually built up the nerve to tell my boyfriend that his friend made me very uncomfortable and I asked for support, some help with getting out of the situation.

He told me I was being too dramatic. His friend was a good guy and why make waves now? I did not have a good answer. My boyfriend didn’t understand that it had taken me ages to build up the courage to speak to him and ask for his help. He didn’t understand that the way he placed the comfort of his friend over mine would be hurtful.

I stopped giving his friend hugs.

This was noticed immediately by my boyfriend and his friend. I was told I was being rude. The friends’ feelings were hurt. Why would I want to make him feel like that?

At future gatherings, his friend decided that he would get his hug from me. Whether I wanted it or not was irrelevant. My boyfriend would laugh.

There is nothing original or uncommon to the story I have just shared. My comfort was never considered to be equal to that of my boyfriend or his friend. If touching my body would make them feel better, then that was what I had to do. You and what you feel are secondary, is the lesson that we teach girls when we tell them they have to hug their brother, uncle, aunt, cousin. And the lesson continues well into adulthood for most women. It is never ‘just’ a hug.

If you enjoyed this article, consider joining Medium for just $5 a month! You’ll get unlimited access to our articles along with thousands of other writers

Read more from The Good Men Project on Medium:

The story was previously published on The Good Men Project.

About Amanda Dettloff

Amanda lives in the mountains of Panama with her trusty pup, Pippin. When she’s not meandering the countryside or baking something delicious, Amanda is a Catalyst Coach through SHFT. Improving confidence and navigating the sometimes tumultuous seas of familial relationships are her strengths.

Sexism
Consent
Harassment
Social Change
Family
Recommended from ReadMedium