I Understand the Student Loan Frustration of Both Sides.

Summary

The Biden Administration's student loan debt cancellation plan has sparked mixed reactions, with some seeing it as a life-changing aid for the middle class and others viewing it as an unfair advantage for those who have already been paying off their high-interest loans without forgiveness.

Abstract

The Biden Administration has introduced a student loan debt cancellation plan that provides up to $20,000 in relief for Pell Grant recipients and up to$ 10,000 for non-Pell Grant recipients, with income eligibility capped at $125,000 for individuals and$ 250,000 for married couples. This plan, which extends the federal student loan repayment pause to December 31, 2022, is designed to benefit borrowers earning less than $75,000, with 90% of the relief directed to this group. While the initiative is seen as a significant help that could change lives, it has also been met with criticism from those who believe it is unfair to those who have diligently paid off their loans without such assistance. The author points out that many borrowers have been making payments that do not reduce the principal due to high-interest rates. The article emphasizes that while the debt cancellation is a temporary fix, a more sustainable solution is needed to address the root causes of exorbitant tuition costs and high student loan interest rates. The Biden Administration has proposed making community college free and ensuring tuition rates are reasonable, but the author notes that until these promises are fulfilled, the issue may persist.

Opinions

The student loan debt cancellation plan is seen as a temporary band-aid rather than a long-term solution to the underlying issues of high tuition costs and student loan interest rates.
There is a sentiment of unfairness among those who have already paid off their student loans, as they did not receive similar debt forgiveness.
The author considers the mindset of those against debt forgiveness as selfish, suggesting that they should be grateful for their ability to pay off their loans and empathetic towards those receiving help.
The author believes that the government needs to implement real solutions to prevent the need for future debt cancellations, such as making community college free and holding universities accountable for tuition rates.
The article suggests that the current student loan system punishes Americans for pursuing higher education, as they often incur significant debt for moderate incomes.

However — One Side Is Being Selfish

The Biden Administration announced its student loan debt cancellation plan. Recipients of Pell Grant from the Department of Education will receive $20,000 off their loans and up to $10,000 for non-Pell Grant recipients. To be eligible, the individual income must be less than $125,000 and $250,000 for married couples. They also extended the federal student loan repayment pause until December 31, 2022, and payment will resume in January 2023.

According to Whitehouse.gov, 90% of this debt cancellation will go to borrowers who earn less than $75,000. So, think about it, people went to college to get in over $100,000 in debt to make less than $60,000. Yes, college is an option; however, it feels like Americans are being punished for wanting higher education.

This debt cancellation will help many middle-class Americans, who are the backbone of the economy. For some, it’s going to be life-changing. This sounds amazing, right? To some, however, it doesn’t sound amazing. Those who have “worked hard” to pay off their student loans don’t think it’s fair that others are getting their debt forgiven.

But what people don’t understand is that these people have been paying their student loans. They work hard just like those who could pay them off already, but the interest rate is so high that they owe more than what they borrowed, so their payments aren’t going to the principal.

So here are the two frustrations. The first is that debt cancellation isn’t a real solution to the root of the problem. This is putting a temporary band-aid to the problem, which is something our government is good at doing. There needs to be a real solution put in place for the rise of tuition and the interest rate of these student loans.

The second frustration is those people who don’t think it’s fair that they didn’t have their debt forgiven and paid their loans back, so others should too, but this is a selfish mindset. How can you not be grateful that you were able to pay off your loan and be happy for others who are receiving help? It’s like being grateful that you don’t need welfare, but the help is available for those who do need it.

Let’s go back to the needed solution, so this debt cancellation doesn’t need to happen again. Whitehouse.gov states that the President will fight to make community college free and hold universities accountable to keep tuition reasonable so borrowers can get value out of their investment in education instead of debt they cannot afford.

However, until this happens, just like every other politician, these are empty promises. Hopefully, legislation can be passed to prevent this from happening again. Because if not, it’s going to be the same thing again four years from now with new borrowers.

What are your thoughts?

If you’d like to support thousands of other writers and me, sign up for Medium’s membership and get access to unlimited articles. If you use my referral link, I’ll get a commission on your monthly membership fee. Sign up here. Thank you so much!