HTMX vs React with examples

Choosing between HTMX and React for your next web development project involves understanding not only the conceptual differences between them but also seeing how they work in practice. Below, we’ll dive deeper into both technologies with examples to illustrate how each can be used to enhance your web development projects.

Introduction to HTMX and React

HTMX is making waves for its approach to simplifying web interactivity by leveraging HTML’s innate capabilities. It enables dynamic content loading and page updates without needing much JavaScript, making web development more accessible and faster.

React, developed by Meta, is renowned for its component-based architecture. It enables developers to build highly reactive and complex web applications with ease. React’s extensive ecosystem and community support have made it one of the most popular front-end libraries.

Practical Examples

To understand the practical applications of HTMX and React, let’s explore how each can be used to create a feature that loads comments on a blog post without refreshing the page.

HTMX Example: Loading Comments

With HTMX, you can achieve this functionality with minimal code and without writing complex JavaScript. Here’s a simple example:

HTML:

<button hx-get="/comments" hx-target="#comments-section" hx-trigger="click">
  Load Comments
</button>
<div id="comments-section"></div>

• hx-get=”/comments”: Tells HTMX to perform a GET request to the /comments URL when the button is clicked.
• hx-target=”#comments-section”: The response from the GET request (expected to be HTML) will be inserted into the element with the ID comments-section.
• hx-trigger=”click”: Defines the event that triggers the GET request, which, in this case, is a click on the button.

This example shows how HTMX allows for interactive content loading directly with HTML attributes, making it incredibly straightforward for developers familiar with HTML.

React Example: Loading Comments

Achieving the same functionality in React involves a bit more setup due to its component-based architecture and the use of JavaScript for handling state and events.

import React, { useState } from 'react';

function CommentsLoader() {
  const [comments, setComments] = useState(null);

  const loadComments = async () => {
    const response = await fetch('/comments');
    const commentsData = await response.text();
    setComments(commentsData);
  };

  return (
    <div>
      <button onClick={loadComments}>Load Comments</button>
      <div id="comments-section">{comments}</div>
    </div>
  );
}

export default CommentsLoader;

• The useState hook initializes the comments state.
• The loadComments function fetches the comments when the button is clicked and updates the comments state with the fetched data.
• The component renders a button that, when clicked, triggers loadComments. It also renders the comments inside a div.

Making the Choice

When to choose HTMX:

• For projects that require simple to moderate interactivity.
• When you want to avoid heavy JavaScript usage and keep your project lightweight.
• If rapid development and ease of use are priorities, especially for developers with a strong background in HTML.

When to choose React:

• For building complex single-page applications (SPAs) or when you need a robust state management system.
• If you’re developing large-scale applications that benefit from component reusability.
• When you have a development team familiar with JavaScript and modern front-end development practices.

Both HTMX and React offer unique advantages for web development. HTMX simplifies the process, making it ideal for straightforward tasks and developers looking to enhance HTML’s capabilities without diving deep into JavaScript. React, with its component-based architecture, is better suited for creating complex and dynamic web applications.

Through the examples provided, you can see that the choice between HTMX and React depends on the project’s complexity, team expertise, and specific development needs. Whether you choose the simplicity and directness of HTMX or the powerful and scalable React, both technologies can help you build efficient and interactive web applications.

Happy Coding! 🚀

In Plain English 🚀

Thank you for being a part of the In Plain English community! Before you go:

• Be sure to clap and follow the writer ️👏️️
• Follow us: X | LinkedIn | YouTube | Discord | Newsletter
• Visit our other platforms: Stackademic | CoFeed | Venture | Cubed
• More content at PlainEnglish.io