avatarSherry McGuinn

Summary

Sherry McGuinn offers advice on maintaining humility and integrity on Medium, emphasizing the importance of supporting each other rather than boasting about personal achievements.

Abstract

In her article "How To Be A 'Medium Mensch,'" Sherry McGuinn addresses the Medium community, urging writers to be respectful and supportive of one another rather than focusing solely on self-promotion. She acknowledges the importance of celebrating success but cautions against excessive self-congratulation, which can alienate fellow writers. McGuinn suggests that true success on the platform comes from honing one's craft, sharing meaningful insights, and maintaining integrity. She advises against flooding the platform with superficial 'how to be curated' listicles and stresses the value of genuine engagement over braggadocio. The article serves as a call to action for writers to be 'mensches'—people of integrity and honor—and to contribute to a supportive and inspiring community.

Opinions

  • McGuinn believes that while it's important to celebrate one's success, there's a fine line between sharing achievements and over-promoting oneself, which can be off-putting.
  • She points out that the essence of success on Medium is the ability to inspire others through one's writing, rather than simply seeking adoration from curators or financial gain.
  • McGuinn criticizes the proliferation of repetitive 'tips' articles on Medium, suggesting that writers should aim for originality and provide 'Aha!' moments rather than rehashing common advice.
  • She emphasizes the importance of writers focusing on their own journeys and not assuming that others are automatically interested in or part of their personal success stories.
  • McGuinn encourages writers to be a 'mensch,' which she defines as a person of integrity and honor, and to use their platform to uplift and support the Medium community as a whole.

How To Be A “Medium Mensch.”

For starters, cut the crap.

Source: Flickr.Com

Okay. Deep breath, Sherry.

How do I begin this piece? Should I be forthright? Sensitive? Kind? A mix of all three?

As my style is to just go for it — here goes.

Recently, there has been a lot of talk in the forums and in Medium stories, alike, about being “respectful” and “supportive” of our fellow writers.

I am on board with the above, one hundred percent. And, I have been the grateful recipient of both respect and support. I also return it. That said, there are people on this platform who just aren’t getting it. Who think that “being supportive” is open to broad interpretation.

Let me tell you something: It isn’t.

Kids, take it from someone who is older, and yeah, a little wiser than you. There’s a huge difference between celebrating your success and shoving it down people’s throats.

If you are being curated three times daily — bravo!

If your stories are Pulitzer-Prize worthy — bravo!

If your fans and claps runneth over — bravo!

Source: Flickr.Com

Just shut up about it, for a while, okay? Or, even better, figure out a way to share your good fortune without making the reader want to vomit on his or her shoes. Because, when you continually write in a fashion that suggests it’s all about you, that we’re all here to support you — that’s not cool. We’re here to support one another.

Did you notice the operative word in the above graph? “Write.” That is what we’re here for. At least, that’s my impression. If others like what I have to say, all the better. That, to me, is the essence of success.

Do I want to be adored by the curators? Hell, yeah. Do I want claps and fans and the opportunity to make a few bucks while doing what I love? Hell, to the yeah. But, if it happens, I want to share my success in a way that inspires, not repels.

Also, Medium is awash with stories about “how to be curated.” Listicles, galore. So, when you cough up, like a hairball, yet another story containing banal “tips” we already know about — please think twice before submitting it.

Now, I know you think I’m being a crank with a mouthful of sour grapes. I’m not. This is my attempt at being supportive of you, because frankly, you’re making yourself look like an ass.

Source: Flickr.Com

I speak from broad experience. I’ve opened my mouth, without thinking. Written stuff, without thinking. So, I know whereof I speak. Don’t repeat my mistakes, of which I’ve made too many to recount here.

That’s why I wasn’t sure if I should write this. But, I know for a fact, I’m not the only person who feels this way. Trust me: You’ll receive support of a genuine kind if you rein yourself in, a bit.

Enthusiasm is good. Braggadocio, (look it up), not so good.

Since “tips” seem to be the way you roll, here are mine, for becoming a Medium Mensch. I’ll speak from my perspective, only.

First, hone your craft. Instead of continually bloviating about your success on this platform — read. Check out some of the truly great writers, here. There are many, and you will learn much, because you need to. Honest.

Don’t tell me to polish my stories when yours are rife with typos and improper grammar.

Refrain from trumpeting every curation, every clap, every fart. Again, not cool. And, who doesn’t want to be cool, right? In fact, I want you to be cool! How’s that for supportive?

If you’re going to include tips in your stories, make them worth something. Don’t regurgitate material from other pieces. In other words, make sure you have at least one “Aha!” moment.

Source: ClaraDon/Flickr.Com

Don’t write a headline documenting the amount of money you made in a single week. In the body of your story, is fine. But, right up top there? Blech.

Please don’t assume I’m “with you” on your journey. I’m on MY journey. Period. The end. I support everyone else’s journey and hope there are nothing but rainbows and unicorns along the way, but I have my hands full with my own.

That’s all. With all sincerity, I say please take this in the spirit of which it is intended. To help and support you. Not to tear you down. I hope you believe me.

A “mensch” by the way, is Yiddish for “a person of integrity and honor.” I know you have it in you.

Best of luck to us all.

Sherry McGuinn is a longtime Chicago-area writer and award-winning screenwriter. Her work has appeared in The Chicago Tribune, Chicago Sun-Times and numerous other publications. Sherry’s manager is currently pitching her newest screenplay, a drama with dark, comedic overtones and inspired by a true story.

Thanks so much for reading. If you like this, please follow me here:

Following my new pub would be most appreciated, as well.

Writing
Advice
Humility
Success
Médium
Recommended from ReadMedium