How New York City is not an American City

A Few Reasons why NYC isn’t America

Spalding Gray said it before I thought it: “I knew I couldn’t live in America and I wasn’t ready to move to Europe so I moved to an island off the coast of America — New York City”

I was born and grew up right smack dab in the middle of America. Ohio. The town I grew up in was a real Mayberry kind of place where everyone knew your business and loved talking about it. I fled to the safety of Cleveland when I was 18 and it was better but it was still America.

What do I mean by that?

It was still a place where people unquestioningly bought that crap about American exceptionalism. Land of the Free. Home of the Brave. Support our Troops. Most people didn’t have a passport and, for the most part, only those from other countries spoke anything but English and there weren’t many of them. People lined up for the latest Hollywood product, regularly ate at Appleby’s or Olive Gardens, and viewed foreigners with distrust.

Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Detroit, and a hundred other Rust Belt cities all around the Great Lakes and beyond have been struggling mightily to regain traction. As manufacturing got sent to countries without unions and men with high school educations could no longer raise a family, buy a house, and keep a decent car on the road, these places got more and more resentful and fearful. This after decades of waving the ol’ red, white, and blue in patriotic fervor.

Scapegoats had to be found. The politicians, always most interested in reelection, pointed to the easiest: brown people from other countries. They are the problem. They took our jobs. They’re having too many babies. They’re going to erase us!

The rising fear and resentment that blamed immigrants was just a variation on a long-played out theme in rural areas and smaller cities. Anyone who was different, who didn’t fit in, who wasn’t ready to settle down and start popping out babies every two years; those people were suspect.

I was 42 when I made my escape from America after being lectured by the old guy who railed about communists in the grocery store. My crime? I had shaved my head because I had always wanted to see how it felt (fantastic). Everywhere I went with my shiny pink head I created a ridiculous stir. People stopped talking to stare and then quickly avert their gaze if I looked in their direction. Cars literally rolled onto the sidewalk because the driver was so incredibly shocked to see a bald, female head. Clearly, I had to get out of America.

It was my good luck that there is an island off the coast of America where the weirdos can still walk freely and be ignored. Here are some of the reasons I’ve found New York City not to be an American city:

We don’t expect everyone to speak English

Remember the kerfuffle that happened in Philadelphia when some smart guy put a sign on his cheese steak emporium instructing customers to place their orders in English? Yeah. That’s not going to happen here.

Some French tourists were having trouble understanding why they couldn’t pay the bus fare with their dollar bills (crazy throwback to the 60’s I guess but the buses here only take coins or Metrocards). I wasn’t at all surprised when several passengers who spoke French went up to help.

51 percent of New Yorkers speak only English at home and it’s estimated that up to 800 different languages are spoken in the five boroughs (1). And we all just roll with that. And I’m not talking about only those of us poor boneheads who only speak English; for the most part on a daily basis people manage to communicate with each other and get stuff done regardless of what language each brings to the table.

We mind our business

I fled to Cleveland shortly after having a “friend” take it upon herself to go to the Ford dealership where Daddy worked as a mechanic to let him know that his daughter “slept with anything wearing pants” (Let the record show that I only slept with three guys that summer and furthermore I’m partial to having sex with those in skirts as well).

In New York no one cares who you’re having sex with. We don’t care about how many, what gender, or where you’re having it (as long as it’s not on the subway platform).

Here are some other things we don’t care about: We don’t care if you’re crying in public, fighting in public, making out in public, asking for money in public, practicing your scales in public, or posing for your latest Instragram masterpiece in public. Just don’t get in our way. We’re in a hurry.

We move fast

We’re not unfriendly and, if we have the time, we’re happy to direct confused tourists to the right train. But speak up quick and be clear.

The energy here is intoxicating and infectious. Even when I’m not in a hurry here I’m in a hurry. Generally, however, I’m in a hurry. So are you and so is everyone else who, by God, is going to fit into this subway car. We get that and most of us remember to pass on the left and that the right lane is for the slower folks or those with walking casts (it happens).

We don’t expect anyone to do it the way we do it

Radical self-expression rules in New York City. Pimp that ride just the way you like it and drive with pride, baby.

It does take a certain authority to pull it off, but people can and do wear whatever the hell they feel like wearing…for the most part. Unfortunately homophobia, misogyny, and plain old stick-in-the-mud-ness aren’t exclusively American traits.

And this ability to transcend societal expectations in the matter of dress, while certainly pioneered by transgender people, is seen on every street in Manhattan at least daily. Cisgendered men in dresses, mini-skirts, and mink stoles with a dashing lapel pin holding it on the shoulder. Goth, total fashion plate, ethnic of every description, prints-with-plaid (I don’t understand either), tuxedos in the afternoon, and a coat made out of shredded white garbage bags which float most becomingly.

We define what success means to each of us

It’s true that I’m currently a paid up member of the rat race with a daily office awaiting me and great health care insurance. Before I get too comfy here, though, let’s remember that the position is being eliminated in six months (nice of them not to bother mentioning that in the job offer but that’s how it goes in the 21st century).

That’s a drag but here I know I can make a living in a hundred different ways that don’t include a HR department and corporate compliance learning modules. While it’s true that remote work and independent contracting are becoming the norm across more and more of the country here it’s been the norm for so long that no one bats an eye.

In the years I cobbled together my living with two part time on site jobs and another remote position no one ever asked me when I was going to get a real job (see above for how we mind our own business here).

The Take Away

If New York City isn’t America then it should be. I mean that the daily virtues of acceptance, tolerance, and making room for everyone would seem to be what Jefferson and the rest of the Founding Property Owners had in mind and, ideally, should still be in play throughout the country.

That would make America exceptional.

I’m not holding my breath. We’ve gotten real comfortable over here where no one’s invading army has clobbered us. Four centuries of relative peace and prosperity has skewed our thinking. Europe took a devastating pounding in the last century and learned some hard lessons.

It is my sincere hope that this country can learn from those lessons without having to go through the carnage that tore Europe apart in the 20th century.

My partner’s mother was born in Poland and, apparently, if you can prove a parent was born there you can go to the Embassy, fill out some paperwork, pay a fee, and claim Polish citizenship. If I wanted to pay to dig up the documentation that could possibly prove that my Italian great grandfather was not a naturalized citizen when my grandfather was born, I might be able to claim dual U.S/Italian citizenship.

Those European Union passports do look tempting but as long as we’ve got this island to call home this is where we’ll stay.

© Remington Write 2019. All Rights Reserved

(1) — WNYC News: https://www.wnyc.org/story/255668-blog-census-languages-new-yorkers-speak/