avatarWilliam Vincent Carleton

Summary

The author discusses the need for a highlight toggle feature on Medium, suggesting improvements to the platform's user experience based on interactions with other users like Lorrae G. and David Perlmutter.

Abstract

The article on the undefined website delves into the author's experience with Medium's highlighting feature, emphasizing the potential for a new toggle feature to enhance reader experience. The author has engaged in discussions with Medium user Lorrae G., who wrote about a one-minute hack to remove excessive highlights from articles. This conversation, along with the author's own experiment with posting typewritten pages as images to avoid highlights, underscores the limitations of the current system. The author suggests that Medium Engineering could improve the platform by allowing higher-quality images and introducing a toggle to turn highlights on or off. The author also notes the impact of highlights on readability, especially with certain custom profile colors, and how this can affect both readers and writers. The proposed highlight toggle feature, dubbed "The Toggle," could be a premium feature for paying members, potentially increasing referrals and improving the overall experience for the Medium community.

Opinions

  • Lorrae G.'s perspective on excessive highlighting is valid, and her workaround demonstrates a need for platform improvement.
  • The author's method of posting typewritten pages as images is acknowledged as difficult to read and could be improved with higher-quality image posting capabilities by Medium Engineering.
  • David Perlmutter's active engagement with the author's work through highlights and comments is seen as a form of collaboration.
  • The author points out that excessive or contrasting highlights can negatively impact the reading experience, leading to frustration for both readers and writers.
  • The author believes that the introduction of "The Toggle" feature for highlights would be widely celebrated by the Medium community, akin to a rock star performance, and could lead to increased membership and engagement on the platform.
  • The author suggests that "The Toggle" should be a feature exclusive to paying members, which could drive referrals and support the ecosystem of readers, writers, and the platform itself.
  • The author emphasizes that even without an increase in referrals, giving the community control over highlights with "The Toggle" would significantly enhance the reading experience.

Highlight This.

Welcoming a discussion with Medium developers

Photo by Clayton Robbins on Unsplash

New Perspective is Good

What I’ve discovered over the course of the last month and a half navigating Medium is revealing, regarding highlights.

Had a really great discussion with Lorrae G. this morning, in response to this terrific article she wrote:

It offers a work-around excessive highlighting, because she had to make it happen. Her points are totally valid. And it led me to write this. As it’s an opportunity for Medium Engineering to improve upon the platform’s features.

So Let’s Talk

Lorrae G. and I shared thoughts in the comments, and I mentioned how I stumbled upon a way to avoid highlights through posting typewritten pages as images. Like this:

Image by author

She explained that this is difficult to read, which is true. Part of this is because my typewriter ribbon needs a change, but also because it’s lacking in image resolution. The pages I upload are scanned in high-res. So, Medium Engineering, if there’s a way to allow higher quality images to post, I would be grateful. It will help folks who require reading assistance to fully enjoy my work. I find myself squinting at times even with 20/20 vision. Substack allowed me to zoom in with each and every word and really analyze the typewritten text. I loved that feature. That said, I’m sticking with Medium because I am at home here. Hopefully you can add a similar feature with the images soon. Thank you.

Now, Back to Highlights

It seems David Perlmutter is often the elephant in the room when it comes to this discussion. Beyond his enthusiasm with highlighting articles, he’s also reading. And writing.

David finds the Easter eggs I put in my work, and highlights them. He also comments. Like in this case:

As a result, David is now in my most recent novel. And this is how we decide to collaborate.

That said…

Lorrae G. also pointed out there are times when reading articles becomes near impossible because of the contrast the highlights make with certain custom profile colors. I have also experienced this and fully agree. Some readers give up. Others go as far as to voice something to the writer. The writer hears this, and gets frustrated. It all makes sense.

Here’s a Chance for Medium Developers to Serve like Rock Stars

I’m speaking to the folks at Medium Engineering when I say that if Medium members suddenly notice there is a new sliding button that toggles highlights ON/OFF, you will receive a standing ovation. All the claps in the world returning to you, like you just finished playing your #1 hit at Madison Square Garden in front of thousands of screaming fans.

It’s called, ‘The Toggle’

I expect Medium Engineering to go into how developing The Toggle was a logistical nightmare. But the team plowed through, and did what it had to in order to make this happen for the readers and writers of Medium. Folks that pay $50 a year for the same reasons fans pay for the rock concert. To support the venue, and the visiting artists. To have the best possible experience together, as a result of how well the venue accommodates its patrons. This is accomplished through unique features.

Make The Toggle a Feature for Paying Members

This way, David Perlmutter and anyone else highlighting help writers get referrals. They’ve already laid the foundation for so many. For anytime a reader wishes to get past the highlights, they choose to become members. To support writers. Referrals will increase.

This is good for the patrons, artists, and venue. It leads to new readers gaining access to articles written by so many talented writers. Then it snowballs. All from The Toggle.

And look, even if this doesn’t lead to referrals, it makes the reading experience more enjoyable by putting the power into the community’s hands.

Now please give us The Toggle!

Encore!

Immortal Type
Writing
Community
Medium
Tech
Recommended from ReadMedium