avatarUlf Wolf

Summary

The web content discusses the concept of cognitive dissonance through the lens of George Orwell's "1984," drawing parallels with contemporary issues, such as the naming of a social platform by an ex-President as "Truth Social."

Abstract

The article titled "Hate is Love" delves into the theme of cognitive dissonance, a psychological conflict that arises from holding two contradictory beliefs simultaneously. It references the iconic slogans from George Orwell's dystopian novel "1984," such as "War is Peace" and "Freedom is Slavery," to illustrate how governments and other entities manipulate truth to align with their agendas. The author, Wolfstuff, parallels the novel's Ministry of Truth with the real-world example of a social platform named "Truth Social," which, despite claiming to be a bastion of free speech, imposes restrictions on criticizing its ownership. The article reflects on the mental toll of reconciling such contradictions and the dehumanizing effect of numbing oneself to cognitive dissonance. Wolfstuff suggests that maintaining sanity in the face of such dissonance may require sacrificing one's full cognitive awareness, leading to a form of mental enslavement.

Opinions

  • The author finds it both amusing and frightening that the ex-President's social platform, "Truth Social," echoes the manipulation of truth as depicted in "1984."
  • Wolfstuff implies that "Truth Social" is hypocritical, claiming to champion free speech while simultaneously censoring criticism of its leadership.
  • The article suggests that the only way to cope with the mental conflict of cognitive dissonance, without losing one's sanity, is to dull one's cognitive faculties, which ultimately leads to a loss of humanity and freedom.
  • The author expresses a hopeful sentiment that the newly introduced "Truth Social" platform may fail, indicating a preference for the preservation of truth and freedom of expression.
  • Wolfstuff invites readers who appreciate the content to contribute financially to the creative process, indicating a value for independent thought and expression.

Hate is Love

Cognitive Dissonance

Hate is love War is peace Olympic quality Mental gymnastics

I believe the term is “cognitive dissonance”; they are also some of the well-known Orwellian calling cards from 1984, the book.

As Winston Smith grapples with the dark inside-out and self-conflicting revelations that permeate the future — and devastated — London: “Hate is Love” and “War is Peace”, he is (while attempting to reconcile these obvious lies) tasked by his employer, the Ministry of Truth, to rewrite history to bring it in line with the current political thinking — including these new truths.

All four ministries: the Ministry of Truth, the Ministry of Peace, the Ministry of Love, and the Ministry of Plenty, share the same slogan, seen and heard everywhere: “War is Peace, Freedom is Slavery, and Ignorance is Strength.”

Smith’s problem is our problem, he has eyes to see and he (still) has an independent mind to think with, and he can tell that hate is not love, that freedom is not slavery. He knows that the Ministry of Plenty is overseeing government-sponsored starvation. Reconciling these opposites takes a gargantuan feat of mental gymnastics — one cannot succeed without sacrificing one’s sanity.

As an aside, I find it frighteningly amusing (if these two sentiments can indeed co-exist) that our ex-President’s recent venture “to give the Tech Giants a run for their money” is named Truth Social.

Yes, it would be funny if it was not also so spine-chillingly apropos. Hailed as the only platform in the world (and the best platform in the world, of course) where everyone is free to speak the truth without censorship or restraints; but since freedom, in this case, is slavery one soon discovers, hidden among the fine print, that contributors may not slur or defame (as in expressing non-flattering views about) the management or owners of Truth Social (e.g., Mr. ex-President and his cadre of Ignorance-is-Strengthers).

Here, then, is our very own, new Ministry of Truth. Luckily, it seems to be sputtering at the gate so, Karma willing, it will soon die a quick and painless (to us) death.

Returning to Smith’s dilemma: How do you reconcile these opposites? How do you keep two opposing forces, notions, data, or emotions, in mind simultaneously? How do you harmonize them?

The blunt but true answer is that you don’t. The only way out of this, this hellish mental conflict, while clinging to your last scraps of sanity, is to dim your ability to sense it, this conflict; to numb your cognitive awareness to the point where the gray merging of the two opposites, while not making sense as we know it, at least no longer offends.

The downside: thus numbed, we a no longer wholly human, we have become slaves.

© Wolfstuff

P.S. If you like what you’ve read here and would like to contribute to the creative motion, as it were, you can do so via PayPal: here.

1984
George Orwell
War Is Peace
Facebook
Ignorance Is Strength
Recommended from ReadMedium
avatarRoman Newell
Couch

Between the cushions

4 min read
avatarMisbah Sheikhh
Lamp and Light

Light as my muse

1 min read