avatarDarcy Thiel

Summary

The author, Darcy Thiel, recounts a distressing experience with aggressive neighborhood dogs that culminated in the tragic death of her beloved cat, leading to a profound shift in her perspective on neighborly relations and community responsibility.

Abstract

Darcy Thiel has endured a decade of stress due to her neighbors' aggressive dogs, which have bitten multiple individuals and ultimately caused the death of her cat, Matilda. Despite her efforts to maintain a good relationship with her neighbors, including accommodating their pets and not reporting violations, the situation escalated to a point where she could no longer ignore the danger posed by the dogs. The loss of Matilda, coupled with the lack of accountability and support from local authorities, has left Thiel and her family traumatized and feeling victimized by a system that seems to protect the dogs over human safety and emotional well-being. This ordeal has led Thiel to reevaluate her approach to neighborhood interactions, deciding to become more reclusive and less involved with her neighbors to avoid further conflict and heartache.

Opinions

  • The author believes that the aggressive behavior of her neighbors' dogs is unacceptable and should not be tolerated in a friendly neighborhood.
  • Thiel feels that the responsibility for the dogs' actions lies with the owners, and that the entire neighborhood bears some responsibility for not addressing the issue sooner.
  • She expresses frustration with a legal system that appears to prioritize the welfare of the aggressive dogs over the safety and emotional distress of the victims.
  • The author and her children are of the opinion that common platitudes such as "dogs will be dogs" and "cats shouldn't be outdoors" trivialize their trauma and fail to acknowledge the severity of the situation.
  • Thiel's perspective on neighborly relations has shifted from prioritizing harmony to recognizing the importance of setting boundaries and ensuring safety, even if it means disrupting peace.
  • Despite the prolonged tension, Thiel eventually chose to extend an olive branch to her neighbors, which led to a reconciliation and a significant reduction in the emotional strain she had been experiencing.

GAME OVER

When you just can’t turn the other cheek

I think I’m officially done. Except I don’t really know what that means. At first, I thought of just crying, “UNCLE!” but that doesn’t seem to cut it. So the phrase that comes to mind is simply, “GAME OVER.”

For the last decade, I have lived my life like I always have. I put people and their feelings first. I suffer discomfort for the sake of others or in order to accomplish some higher goal. I have invested a lot of myself in my neighborhood. I started the block party several years ago and make an effort to have phone numbers and invite people over regularly. Good to have a great relationship with your neighbors, right?

When Frankie was in infant, my neighbor had a St. Bernard. Huge breed, but also an extremely gentle breed. Usually. However, this one decided he didn’t like us. My neighbor asked me for sleepers that Frankie had slept in. She wanted her dog to get used to Frankie’s scent. That way the dog would be less likely to eat my baby for a snack. As a new mom, I can tell you I thought that was pretty screwed up, but I gave her the pajamas and prayed nothing would happen.

Eventually, that dog died and then there more. You are only supposed to have two dogs per property, but my neighbor had four at one point. Did I turn them in? Of course not. I wanted a good relationship with them. One time, one of the dogs bit our handyman. Did I turn them in? No, of course not. Then we decided we had to put a fence up. We asked their opinion about the style because we wanted them to be happy with it too. We were sensitive to the fact that they would have to look at it too. The Home Depot people thought I was nuts. But hey, we want a good relationship with our neighbors, right?

The fence went up but I still couldn’t do my yard work without that dog sticking his vicious jaws through the slats as he was trying to attack me. I finally risked the relationship and asked the family to do something. They added chicken wire over the fence so the dog could no longer have access to my hands. It still scared the crap out of me because it clearly had only one mission and that was to hurt us, but hey, the relationship with my neighbors was more important, right?

Then my daughter got married. We had the rehearsal dinner in our backyard. The same dog bit the maid of honor because she was talking and had rested her hand on the top of the fence. Did I turn them in? Of course not. Who is really the idiot here? Me. I’m the one at the fault. Fascinating that when I called to let my neighbor know what happened, she started yelling at me. She said she had put the wire up and there was no way she was putting the dog down. I calmly (of course) told her she needed to take a deep breath. Her dog bit. I never asked her to put the dog down, nor was I yelling at her. I just thought she should know the dog had bitten again.

Then they got a German Shepherd. It didn’t take long for that dog to just eat right through the fence. Then they had to put up another chain link fence. Then the dog started to attempt to jump over the fence and was in danger of doing so. They had to add yet another layer of the fence. Now that dog is muzzled. But hey, as long as I don’t hurt their feelings, I can put up with anything, right?

They have had five dogs since I’ve lived here. Three of them have been vicious. No one can believe what I put up with when they come over. It’s impossible to describe if you don’t see it yourself. It’s not just like an annoying dog barking. They lunge at the fence and growl and bark and make you shake. And I just look at people at say, “But we like our neighbors and I want to keep it that way.” When you leave your dogs outside 24 hours a day, when you don’t walk them or socialize them, they become like wild animals. Savage.

On the day that would have been Tim’s (my deceased husband) 54th birthday. I texted with a couple of my kids in the morning and I thought it seemed like it might be a bearable day. That is, until about 10 AM when Colin (my son) came bursting in the house screaming my name over and over.

Same dog that has bitten twice on my property, same dog that I found out has bitten the neighbor on the other side three times, killed our beloved cat Matilda.

She was barely a year old and she was beautiful. She was an extremely gentle kitty. And she made the hideous mistake of walking home near those dogs. Poor Colin. He heard the screams. He ran over to their yard, trying desperately to get his kitty from the mouth of the dog. When my neighbor finally heard it, he came out and got the dog to drop her. That was when Colin came in the house screaming. We rushed her to the hospital. They tried CPR, but it was too late. Did you know that when intestines are punctured there is a putrid smell? We couldn’t bear it.

All I can say is, our household has been suffering the last week. The closest way to describe it is like suffering from PTSD. The kids have decided the only way those people could possibly understand what we are feeling, is for them to be forced to watch their precious dog be eaten before their eyes. They need to hear the screams. They need to smell the aftermath. And then every day afterward, they need to hear and see the killer whenever they dare to walk outside their home.

Because that is what it is like for us here. There is no peace. There is no escaping it. Those three dogs are outside and they still bark and still lunge at us.

I don’t give one flying fuck that our cat was in their yard. I don’t care that our cat was an indoor/outdoor cat. THIS IS NOT WHAT HAPPENS. IT WAS NOT OUR FAULT. THERE IS NO EXCUSE.

Even the dog warden said that being territorial is what is normal. Killing is not. Dogs know the difference between a wild squirrel or a rabbit. They DO NOT KILL DOMESTICATED ANIMALS.

Game over. I’m not the bigger person. There are no cheeks left to turn. No more neighborhood parties. No more bigger picture. My kids are going through hell. I am going through hell. This is MY fault for not turning them in dozens of times. I will never make the same mistake again. This is not just, “Oh that poor family, they’ve gone through so much.” We didn’t just lose yet another pet. We are victims of a violent crime. And the stupid system protects them, not the victims.

We can’t use pepper spray because if it injures the dogs, we are liable. Yet their dogs can KILL our pet, and nothing is done. In what world does that make sense? Oh yeah, in America.

Game over. I am officially going reclusive. I can’t invest anymore. I can’t try anymore. I can’t risk anymore. I will just keep to myself and be like most people. They won’t get involved or stand up for us because no one wants to ruffle feathers. And hey, Matilda wandered in their yard so that makes it all ok.

Vicious dogs don’t belong in friendly neighborhoods. When a toddler or child gets their arm or head chewed off, then everyone on this street should be held responsible for allowing this dog to be here.

As my kids say- and I have to agree with them- anyone that makes these kinds of statements doesn’t realize how much they hurt us: “Dogs will be dogs” “Cats are too curious” “I’m sure they feel bad” “Just let it go” “Cats shouldn’t be outdoors” “Oh, this is a shame”

My kids say all of these people just don’t get it.

POSTSCRIPT: This story was written four years ago. After four years of bitter rivalry, this Christmas Eve I finally broke and took my neighbors a token Christmas present. I was greeted with a hug, tears and an apology. It took me that long to swallow my pride, but I am glad I did. It feels much better to not breathe in the hate that was in my yard.

I’m Darcy Thiel. I utilize my professional and personal experiences to increase my understanding and compassion to help others. I am a Licensed Mental Health Counselor, Adult Planning Specialist, End of Life Doula and author. Feel free to check out my profile to hear more.
Pets
Cats
Forgiveness
Life
Life Lessons
Recommended from ReadMedium