avatarTony Stubblebine

Summary

The web content discusses the importance of shifting from a hubris-driven leadership model to one that values competence and emotional awareness, as highlighted by executive coach Chantal in her article addressing the inner critic and the role of emotions in decision-making.

Abstract

The editorial note introduces Chantal, an executive coach, whose work emphasizes the significance of overcoming the inner critic to foster competence and the necessity of emotional awareness in personal development. The article contrasts the prevalent leadership culture, often dominated by overconfident individuals, with the potential for competent individuals to rise to success. It suggests that the current leadership landscape does not naturally favor the most competent people, which is a concern for the editor. The piece also touches on the broader theme of the emotional basis of decision-making, referencing Daniel Kahneman's research, which reveals that most decisions are emotionally driven rather than purely rational.

Opinions

  • The editor believes that there is a notable discrepancy between hubris and competence in leadership roles, with a slight gender bias towards men as per Harvard Business Review.
  • There is a perceived need to support competent individuals in achieving success, rather than allowing those with mere confidence to dominate leadership positions.
  • Chantal's approach to quieting the inner critic is seen as a method to empower individuals who value competence, thereby removing obstacles to their success.
  • The editor values the development of emotional awareness as a critical component of personal growth and decision-making, a sentiment echoed in Chantal's strategies.
  • The editor expresses a personal pain that the natural progression in leadership does not favor competence and suggests that a shift in mindset is needed to rectify this.
  • The reference to Daniel Kahneman's work implies that understanding our emotional selves is crucial, as it contradicts the common misconception that humans are primarily rational decision-makers.

Editor’s note: I’m the editor who finds personal development articles for Medium Members, and I like to put each of those articles in the context of the overall topic.

Chantal, who is one of the great up and coming executive coaches, hits on two themes that matter a great deal to me and which a lot of the articles here are going to hit on.

The first is what I’d call a clash of two mindsets. One mindset is hubris and the other is competence. This is a slightly gendered clash, according to HBR’s Why do so many incompetent men become leaders?

But you could flip that framing around and say “How can we help the most competent people become the most successful?” It pains me that this isn’t what happens naturally.

In that context, Chantal’s piece on quieting your inner critic is about removing a roadblock from people like you and me who worship competence. The pure-hubris crowd needs the opposite — they need an inner critic telling them to be quiet.

The second theme is about the power of developing an awareness of our emotional lives. This is one of the strategies in Chantal’s piece.

And it’s a theme that comes up almost everywhere. Daniel Kahneman’s famous book Thinking, Fast and Slow goes deep into this and reminds us that the majority of our decisions come from an emotional mode of thought rather than a rational mode. We wish we were rational creatures, but we’re not.

Self Improvement
Inner Critic
Personal Growth
Resilience
Life
Recommended from ReadMedium