avatarNavdeep Singh

Summary

The web content discusses the implementation and comparison of Clean Architecture and MVVM + Coordinators patterns in SwiftUI, providing practical code examples and evaluating their respective advantages and challenges.

Abstract

The article delves into the application of Clean Architecture and MVVM + Coordinators patterns within the context of SwiftUI development. It explains how Clean Architecture separates concerns into distinct layers, emphasizing the decoupling of business logic from UI and frameworks, which enhances maintainability and testability. The MVVM + Coordinators approach is presented as a solution for managing data presentation and navigation logic separately, with Coordinators handling complex navigation flows. The article provides code snippets to illustrate the implementation of these patterns in SwiftUI and discusses the scenarios in which each pattern might be more suitable, suggesting Clean Architecture for complex, multi-platform applications and MVVM + Coordinators for apps with intricate navigation needs but less complex business logic.

Opinions

  • Clean Architecture is praised for its modularity, flexibility, and independence from UI or frameworks, making it ideal for large, complex applications.
  • The use of MVVM + Coordinators is seen as beneficial for clarity and decoupling navigation logic from the UI, which is particularly useful in SwiftUI applications with sophisticated navigation.
  • The article suggests that Clean Architecture might be excessive for simpler applications due to the rigor required in defining boundaries and dependencies between layers.
  • MVVM + Coordinators is acknowledged to introduce additional complexity, especially in apps with deep navigation hierarchies, necessitating careful management of coordinators' ownership and lifecycle.
  • The choice between Clean Architecture and MVVM + Coordinators is presented as dependent on the specific needs of the application and the preferences of the development team.

Clean Architecture vs MVVM + Coordinators in SwiftUI

Architectural Patterns Demystified

Photo by La-Rel Easter on Unsplash

SwiftUI, Apple’s UI toolkit, brings declarative UI programming to the forefront, allowing developers to build interfaces across all Apple platforms seamlessly. While SwiftUI revolutionises UI development, choosing the right architecture remains pivotal to project scalability, maintainability, and testability. Let’s dive deeper into Clean Architecture and MVVM + Coordinators in the context of SwiftUI, enriched with practical code examples.

Clean Architecture in SwiftUI

Clean Architecture focuses on separating concerns into layers, making your codebase more modular, flexible, and independent of UI or frameworks.

Implementation in SwiftUI

Implementing Clean Architecture in SwiftUI involves defining these layers clearly:

  • Entities: The core business logic and rules. In SwiftUI, entities would be your data models that remain unaffected by UI changes or data sources.
  • Use Cases: Application-specific business rules. This layer orchestrates the flow of data to and from the entities, and is presented to the UI through view models.
  • Interface Adapters: This layer contains the view models in MVVM, adapting the data from the use cases for the UI. SwiftUI views bind to these view models, observing any state changes to update the UI.
  • Frameworks and Drivers: The outermost layer includes frameworks like CoreData or external libraries. SwiftUI itself could be considered part of this layer, along with any other UI frameworks you use.

Example: Defining Entities and Use Cases

Entities (Core Business Logic)

struct Item {
    var id: UUID
    var title: String
    var details: String
}

Use Cases (Application-Specific Business Rules)

protocol ItemsRepository {
    func fetchItems() async throws -> [Item]
}

struct FetchItemsUseCase {

    var itemsRepository: ItemsRepository

     func execute() async throws -> [Item] {
        try await itemsRepository.fetchItems()
    }
}

Example: Interface Adapters with SwiftUI

ItemViewModel

class ItemViewModel: ObservableObject {
    @Published var items: [Item] = []
    var fetchItemsUseCase: FetchItemsUseCase
    
    init(fetchItemsUseCase: FetchItemsUseCase) {
        self.fetchItemsUseCase = fetchItemsUseCase
    }
    
    func loadItems() {
        Task {
            do {
                self.items = try await fetchItemsUseCase.execute()
            } catch {
                print("Failed to load items")
            }
        }
    }
}

Example: SwiftUI View

struct ItemsView: View {
    @ObservedObject var viewModel: ItemViewModel
    
    var body: some View {
        List(viewModel.items, id: \.id) { item in
            Text(item.title)
        }
        .onAppear {
            viewModel.loadItems()
        }
    }
}

Advantages of Clean Architecture with SwiftUI:

  • Decouples core business logic from UI and frameworks, making it easier to test and maintain.
  • Promotes a single direction of dependencies, from outer layers to inner layers.
  • Enables interchangeable UI or data sources without affecting business logic.

Challenges of Clean Architecture with SwiftUI:

  • Requires rigor in defining boundaries and dependencies between layers, which might be overkill for simpler apps.

MVVM + Coordinators with SwiftUI

MVVM is a well-known pattern in the iOS development community that separates the concerns of presenting data (ViewModel) from the presentation layer (View). However, MVVM does not inherently solve navigation concerns, which is where Coordinators come into play.

Implementing MVVM + Coordinators in SwiftUI

  • MVVM: Each view in SwiftUI has a corresponding ViewModel that it observes, typically using the @ObservedObject or @StateObject property wrappers. The ViewModel interacts with models to fetch/update data and notifies the view of changes.
  • Coordinators: Act as the navigation logic layer. Each coordinator is responsible for deciding when to navigate between views/screens. In SwiftUI, coordinators can be implemented as separate objects that manage navigation by triggering changes in observable properties that the SwiftUI views are watching.

Combining MVVM for data-binding with Coordinators for navigation management provides clarity, decoupling the UI from its navigation logic.

Example: Coordinator in SwiftUI

AppCoordinator

class AppCoordinator: ObservableObject {
    @Published var currentPage: Page = .home

    enum Page {
        case home
        case details(Item)
    }
    
    func goToDetails(with item: Item) {
        currentPage = .details(item)
    }
}

NavigationView

struct AppNavigationView: View {
    @StateObject var coordinator = AppCoordinator()

    var body: some View {
        switch coordinator.currentPage {
        case .home:
            ItemsView(coordinator: coordinator)
        case .details(let item):
            ItemDetailView(item: item)
        }
    }
}

Wiring MVVM with Coordinator in SwiftUI

ItemsView with Coordinator

struct ItemsView: View {
    @ObservedObject var viewModel: ItemViewModel
    var coordinator: AppCoordinator
    
    var body: some View {
        List(viewModel.items, id: \.id) { item in
            Button(item.title) {
                coordinator.goToDetails(with: item)
            }
        }
        .onAppear {
            viewModel.loadItems()
        }
    }
}

Advantages of MVVM + Coordinators with SwiftUI

  • Clear separation of navigation logic (Coordinators) from presentation and business logic (MVVM).
  • Enhanced testability and maintainability, enabling each component to be tested independently.
  • Offers flexibility in managing complex navigation flows in SwiftUI apps.

Challenges of MVVM + Coordinators with SwiftUI:

  • Introduces additional complexity in managing coordinators, especially in apps with deep navigation hierarchies.
  • Requires careful thought in handling the ownership and lifecycle of coordinators.

Clean Architecture vs MVVM + Coordinators: When to Use Which?

While both architectures aim for separation of concerns and testability, the choice between them often depends on the app’s complexity and the development team’s preference.

  • Use Clean Architecture when building large, complex applications where the core business logic might be used across multiple platforms or when the application logic is complex enough to benefit from strict layer separations.
  • Opt for MVVM + Coordinators for apps that are less complex but have sophisticated navigation needs. This combination provides a balance between structured architecture and SwiftUI’s declarative nature, making it well-suited for most iOS/macOS apps.

Conclusion

Whether adopting Clean Architecture or leveraging the power of MVVM + Coordinators, SwiftUI app development benefits significantly from a thoughtful approach to architecture. Clean Architecture suits complex applications with rich business logic, while MVVM + Coordinators cater well to apps with intricate navigation needs. Understanding these patterns and selecting the right one for your project needs can significantly impact the success and scalability of your SwiftUI application.

Stackademic 🎓

Thank you for reading until the end. Before you go:

iOS
iOS App Development
Swift
Mobile App Development
Android
Recommended from ReadMedium