Can Men and Women be Just Friends? Exploring the Psychology Behind
Whether a man and woman can hold their relationship within the boundaries of pure friendship, is a question that eludes no one. It’s a quintessential teenage dilemma, a maze that grows more convoluted with age. Finally, when the answers matter no more, you would reconcile with some blurred theory.
People arrive at their conclusions, assuming universality for their intimate experiences. “That’s how it’s gotta be for everyone,” they assure themselves. Individual interpretations apart, let’s look at the psychological expounding of the same matter, shall we?
“‘It’s better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all.”
Why do you fall in love anyway?
Have you ever felt that when you look at the mirror, you don’t see yourself, but you often see what you lack?
It’s true. Most people are guided by what I would call a ‘psychological’ deficiency: A feeling that something is just not right about them, a pricking problem of self-assumed ‘lacking.’ It might just be delusional or founded on healthy roots.
For instance, a good looking girl can still assume that she is unattractive. She might have a tiny scar on her face that steals all her attention when she looks at the mirror. She blames the disfigurement for spoiling her otherwise pristine appearance, subconsciously scans if anyone around has spotted it. In reality, that mark could be the last thing to catch the attention of a potential suitor. It doesn’t matter what the truth is; your perception defines your psychological state. In this case, her lack was purely imagined.
But If you are in a perpetual state of ‘deficiency,’ real or assumed, a person who can fill these gaps would seem very attractive to you. There is a good chance that you would want to keep that person close to you for the rest of your life; in other words, ‘fall in love.’
So in the case of the above girl, a charming guy with a Greek godlike appearance would make a strong case to her senses. Being in a relationship with him gives her a sense of accomplishment, reassuring that she is indeed beautiful. In other words, he helps to fade her feeling of lack.
The reasons why a person would feel low about themselves needn’t always be a conjured one. A girl growing amidst the alcohol abuse of her father would find great comfort in the company of a man who pays heed to her problems, offering her a sense of shield. An arm of support she has missed for the better part of her life. She would want that armor around her and is likely to develop romantic feelings for him. Here, her sense of lack was a product of years of misery.
I can go on and state any number of examples, but you get the gist. The theory works for any gender, don’t think I am cherry-picking women here. In fact, I feel, men have more issues to sort out.
What Familiarity Does
You may or may not agree with the theory of deficiency, but there is one thing we can all nod our head for.
You are very likely to fall in love with a person whom you are meeting consistently.
When that happens, most people would weigh their options, and see if he is a deficiency filler or a deficiency amplifier? A guy who looks unattractive to the first girl we discussed, doesn’t do any good to her feelings of lacking. She is likely to reject him. Again, it only matters how she perceives; there are only subjective realities here. If the guy is caring and nurturing, the same guy would seem like a catch to the girl with alcoholic parents.
But if there are suitors who fall into no man’s land, neither doing excellent nor bad to a girl’s psychological needs, but is someone she sees regularly, she might give it a shot. Familiarity, regularity in a meeting, etc. can make up for some slack in what the guy brings to the table. In such cases, she can go for him.
Once again, I apologize that all the examples are female-centric.
To sum up, yes, men and women can stay friends. If they don’t fill each other’s deficiencies, they would see no reason to be together. In such cases, friendship would stay friendship.
I also agree that there are umpteen things that could draw you to a romantic affair. From the scent of a person to the way she smiles, literally anything. Whether you would call such bursts of emotions like love, is a different matter though. Food for thought, I guess.
Thanks for reading.






