avatarEsteban Thilliez

Summary

The website provides a personal review of Friedrich Nietzsche's "Beyond Good and Evil," noting its challenging nature, the author's distinctive style, and its selective appeal.

Abstract

The review titled "Book Review — Beyond Good and Evil — Friedrich Nietzsche" offers a brief overview of Nietzsche's seminal work, describing it as a collection of 296 aphorisms that delve into his mature philosophy. The book's structure is thematic, with each aphorism contributing to a larger narrative, though the connections may not be immediately apparent. The reviewer shares their struggle with the book's complexity and the perceived lack of consistency, yet acknowledges the presence of an underlying logic and progression. Nietzsche's writing is praised for its expressive and sometimes provocative style, despite his acknowledged misogyny. The review concludes by cautioning that the book may not be suitable for all readers, suggesting that personal resonance with Nietzsche's perspective is key to engaging with his work.

Opinions

  • The reviewer found "Beyond Good and Evil" difficult to read and understand, especially for a first-time Nietzsche reader.
  • There is an appreciation for Nietzsche's thought-provoking and occasionally offensive mode of expression.
  • The reviewer notes an "order in disorder," suggesting that there is a method to Nietzsche's seemingly disjointed aphorisms.
  • Nietzsche's lack of proof for his statements is mentioned, though the reviewer does not see this as a significant issue.
  • The book's misogynistic elements are acknowledged, and readers are encouraged to look past these prejudices.
  • The reviewer believes that enjoying the book requires a level of identification with Nietzsche's viewpoints.
  • The reviewer does not regret reading the book but does not plan to read more Nietzsche in the near future.
  • The recommendation to read the book is cautious, with the caveat that it will help readers determine if they can engage with Nietzsche's writing style.

Book Review — Beyond Good and Evil — Friedrich Nietzsche

Quick Summary

Beyond Good and Evil is a comprehensive overview of Nietzsche’s mature philosophy.

The book consists of 296 aphorisms, ranging in length from a few sentences to a few pages. These aphorisms are grouped thematically into nine different chapters and are bookended by a preface and a poem.

While each aphorism can stand on its own, there is also something of a linear progression between aphorisms within chapters and from one chapter to another. Nonetheless, each aphorism presents a distinctive point of view, and even the individual chapter summaries omit a great deal.

My Thoughts

That was my first Nietzsche’s book, and honestly, it was a bit hard to read and understand. From time to time I felt that the author was simply stating a random point of view without any real consistency with the rest of the book.

On the other hand, I liked how the author express his thoughts. It was a bit offending sometimes, but that was not a problem. Also, there was order in disorder. I mean, sometimes even if I didn’t understand the logic of the book, this logic was well present because there was a kind of progression through the book.

One thing that can make people dislike this book is that Nietzsche rarely proves what he states. For me, it wasn’t a problem as I think there’s no truth and I don’t have to trust what he says.

Then, Nietzsche is misogyn. It means, some words can be shocking and really offensive. But he recognizes his misogyny as one of his weaknesses, so we must succeed in the book by detaching ourselves from our prejudices about this misogyny.

One last thing, I think this book is not for everyone. There are philosophical books that you don’t really need to identify with to read and enjoy. For this one, however, you need to identify with Nietzsche. The author has such a way of expressing his goals and thoughts that it can quickly irritate someone who does not recognize himself in what he says.

To Read or Not to Read

As I just said, this book is not for everyone. On the other hand, you won’t know without reading it. But you will at least know if you can read Nietzsche or not.

For me, I don’t regret having read this book, but I’m not going to read Nietzsche again any time soon.

To explore more of my book reviews, click here! You can also access all my content by checking this page.

If you liked the story, don’t forget to clap, comment, and maybe follow me if you want to explore more of my content :)

You can also subscribe to me via email to be notified every time I publish a new story, just click here!

If you’re not subscribed to Medium yet and wish to support me or get access to all my stories, you can use my link:

Philosophy
Nietzsche
Books
Reading
Book Review
Recommended from ReadMedium