As I Lay Dying vs. As I Die Laughing
No doubt you’ve been wondering how William Faulkner’s classic stacks up against fellow Mississippian Noel Holston’s new memoir. Here’s a quick guide:
Q. What are some of the similarities and differences between William Faulkner’s As I Lay Dying and Noel Holston’s As I Die Laughing?
A. Glad you asked. Though both authors are Mississippi natives of modest height who spent time in Hollywood before returning to the South, there are significant distinctions to be made when it comes to their best known works.
1. Faulkner was a genius. Holston is of slightly above average intelligence.
2. Faulkner’s prose can be more dense than a double fudge brownie. Holston’s is more like the meringue atop a banana pudding.
3. Faulkner’s book is best consumed with a reader’s guide. Holston is best consumed with a bowl of peanuts and a Nehi peach soda.
4. Holston’s book is slightly funnier.
5. Holston’s book is slightly larger.
6. Faulkner’s book is still being read almost a century after publication. Holston’s book is still being read a month after its publication.
We suggest getting copies of both and comparing for yourself.
