7 Alternate History Plots That Will Leave You Wondering

Uncovering the imagination — Rewriting the past.

Have you ever wondered how the world would be different if major historical events had gone a different way? Alternate history is a captivating genre that poses the ‘what if?’ questions and imagines a different reality.

In this article, we’ll explore 7 of the most intriguing alternate history scenarios and discuss how they differ from our timeline.

Whether you’re a fan of science fiction, fantasy, or history, these compelling plots will leave you wondering what could have been.

7- The Axis Wins World War II — Petrified World

The thought of a world where the Axis powers — Germany, Japan, and Italy — won World War II is terrifying. If this scenario were to happen, the world as we know it would be unrecognizable.

Europe and Asia would be under the control of the Nazis and the Japanese, respectively. The United States, which played a crucial role in the war, would either be invaded or become isolationist, thus ceding global dominance to the Axis.

The Nazi regime would have continued its heinous actions against Jews, homosexuals, and other “undesirables” without consequence.

The Japanese would have dominated Asia, implementing their form of colonialism. The idea of a free and democratic world would be nothing but a memory.

On the other hand, some argue that the outcome of the war would have been different if the Axis powers had better leadership and technology. Hitler’s focus on invading the Soviet Union, which drained Nazi resources, could have been avoided.

Japan’s technological advancements in warfare could have been fully utilized. It is even possible that the war could have ended in a stalemate or a negotiated peace.

Either way, the possibility of the Axis winning World War II is a frightening alternate history scenario that leaves us with many unanswered questions and an appreciation for the sacrifice and bravery of those who struggled for liberty and democracy.

6- The Central Powers Win World War I — Reverberate History

In this alternate history scenario, Germany and its allies come out victorious in the Great War, marking a dramatic shift in world events.

The Treaty of Versailles is never signed, and the harsh reparations imposed on Germany are never put into effect.

The result is a much more prosperous and powerful Germany, with Austria-Hungary and the Ottoman Empire also retaining their former glory.

This outcome drastically alters the geopolitical landscape of Europe, as the defeated Allied powers struggle to maintain their sovereignty.

The Soviet Union never rises to power, as the Bolshevik Revolution is prevented by the Central Powers’ victory. Without the harsh conditions imposed on Germany by the Treaty of Versailles, World War II never happens, and the Holocaust never takes place.

However, the rise of the Central Powers also ushers in an era of authoritarianism and nationalism across the world, as other nations seek to emulate their success.

The League of Nations fails to gain traction, as the balance of power in Europe is already shifted towards the victors of the Great War.

Overall, the world of this alternate history scenario is vastly different from our own, and the ramifications of a Central Powers victory continue to reverberate throughout history.

5- The Protestant Reformation — The Dominancy Of The Catholic Church

Imagine a world where the Catholic Church remains the dominant religious force in Europe, with no other competing faiths. This scenario is what would have occurred if the Protestant Reformation never happened.

The Catholic Church would have continued to maintain its absolute power over Europe’s political and social institutions, with no challenge from Protestantism.

The doctrines of the Church would have remained the only source of spiritual guidance for European society, and the power of the Pope would never have been questioned.

Without the Reformation, many of the key events that occurred in European history would not have happened.

The Thirty Years’ War, which claimed the lives of millions of people, would not have occurred, as the conflict was rooted in the tensions between the Catholic and Protestant factions.

Similarly, the rise of the Puritans in England and the establishment of the Anglican Church would not have occurred, with significant consequences for the country’s social and political history.

Moreover, the Catholic Church would have maintained its dominance in science, as the Church would have been less likely to have restricted scientific inquiry as it did in the 16th and 17th centuries.

However, without the stimulus of Protestantism, European society might not have experienced the same intellectual and cultural effervescence that characterized the Renaissance and the Enlightenment.

4- The Confederacy — American Civil War

In this alternate timeline, the Confederacy is victorious in the Civil War and gains independence from the Union. The ramifications of this event would have been significant and far-reaching.

The first thing that would have happened is the formation of two separate nations: the Confederate States of America and the United States of America.

The Confederacy would have been a pro-slavery nation, with the right to own slaves enshrined in its constitution. This would have further solidified the divide between the North and the South, and have gone to war with the Confederacy again in the future.

One of the most significant changes would have been the effect on African Americans. The Confederacy was built on the idea of white supremacy, and have continued for much longer than it did in our timeline. This would have meant that the Civil Rights Movement and the push for equality would have taken longer to gain traction.

There are also economic implications of the Confederacy winning the war. The South was heavily reliant on the export of cotton, and the Union’s naval blockade had a significant impact on the economy.

If the Confederacy had won, it’s possible that it would have continued to rely on cotton exports and remained relatively poor.

Overall, the victory of the Confederacy in the Civil War would have had a profound impact on the United States and the world as we know it. It’s fascinating to think about what could have happened if things had gone differently.

3- American Revolution — Existence Of America

If the American Revolution had gone differently, we might be living in a world without the United States of America. Imagine if the British had defeated the revolutionaries and the 13 colonies remained under British control.

The American identity would not have existed, and the founding principles of freedom and democracy would not have spread around the world.

Without the U.S. to lead the way, the global power structure would be vastly different. The balance of power would have shifted toward the European monarchies and away from republics.

The consequences of this alternate history are vast and difficult to fully grasp. One possibility is that without the U.S. to act as a check on European colonialism, colonial powers would have been emboldened to take over even more territory around the world.

Another possibility is that the British would have gone on to become the world’s dominant power, spreading their language and culture around the world. All in all, the existence of the United States has had a profound impact on the course of history.

It’s impossible to predict what our world would look like if the American Revolution had gone differently, but one thing is certain: it would be vastly different than the world we know today.

2- Rome Never Fell — The World Under Roman’s Control

In an alternate universe, Rome never fell, and instead, their empire continued to expand, until they controlled the entire world. It’s a fascinating concept to ponder, and one that raises all sorts of intriguing questions.

What would the world look like today if the Romans had remained in power? Would they have developed technology at a faster rate? Would they have created a world government?

Would they have eventually collapsed under their weight, like other empires throughout history?

Perhaps the most intriguing aspect of this alternate history scenario is the clash of cultures that would have ensued.

Rome would have encountered a multitude of different peoples and civilizations, each with their unique traditions and ways of life.

Would they have been able to peacefully coexist, or would the Romans have simply conquered and assimilated them all?

Regardless of the answers, it’s clear that the world would be vastly different if Rome had never fallen.

It’s a reminder that even small events in history can have far-reaching consequences and that the course of human history is always subject to change.

1- The Atomic Bombs Don’t Work — The U.S. Invasion Of Japan

In this alternate timeline, the famous bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki never happened. Perhaps there was a technical glitch that caused the bombs to malfunction, or maybe they were never even developed.

Regardless, this change in history drastically alters the events that followed. Instead of Japan surrendering to the Allied forces, the war drags on for months if not years.

Without the devastating impact of the atomic bombs, the U.S. decides to launch a full-scale invasion of Japan. The invasion is bloody and costly, with many casualties on both sides.

The Japanese military, fighting fiercely to defend their homeland, inflicts heavy losses on the invading forces. The battles rage on for months, with no end in sight.

Eventually, the U.S. manages to gain the upper hand. Using their superior resources and technology, they manage to push the Japanese back. T

he final battle takes place in Tokyo, where the Japanese finally surrender after a fierce fight. The U.S. takes control of Japan, occupying the country for several years before granting it independence.

This scenario raises many questions about the impact of the atomic bombs. Would the battle have been won if they hadn’t been there? Would the U.S. have invaded Japan regardless of whether or not the bombs worked?

Would the invasion have been even bloodier than the atomic bombings themselves? As with all alternate history scenarios, there are no easy answers.

Points To Ponder

Intriguing and thought-provoking alternate history scenarios make us wonder what our world could have been like if past events had played out differently.

From the devastating outcome of World War II to the possibility of a world dominated by Rome, these scenarios remind us of the significance of seemingly small choices and how they can lead to vastly different outcomes. They make us question our reality and ponder the role of fate versus free will.

Alternate history also emphasizes the importance of remembering the past and learning from it, as it can have far-reaching consequences for the present and future.

Ultimately, these alternate-history scenarios offer a fascinating glimpse into what might have been and leave us with the humbling realization that our current reality is just one of many possible outcomes.

Join Medium Today

More from the author: