avatarSherry Caris

Summary

A third-grade student decides to learn the violin, joins the school orchestra, but quits after realizing they must perform a solo, having previously pretended to play to avoid criticism.

Abstract

The narrative recounts the experience of a young student who, captivated by the allure of the violin, joins their elementary school orchestra. Despite their initial enthusiasm, the student is hindered by laziness, fear of public shame, and a reluctance to take risks. To avoid the harsh reprimands of the orchestra leader, Mr. Walter James, the student resorts to miming the violin during practices. This strategy works until a solo performance is announced, prompting the student to quit the orchestra rather than face the prospect of being in the spotlight.

Opinions

  • The student admires the violin's beauty and desires to incorporate it into their identity.
  • There is a fear of being publicly shamed for making mistakes, which is a significant deterrent to learning.
  • The student believes that effort is unnecessary due to a history of easily achieving success without practice.
  • The student is risk-averse, preferring to avoid potential embarrassment, influenced by previous experiences of being teased.
  • Mr. James' teaching method, which includes public admonishment for mistakes, is perceived as intimidating and discouraging.
  • The student feels a sense of accomplishment in evading detection while miming the violin, but this is overshadowed by the constant fear of being caught.
  • The decision to quit the orchestra is driven by the student's unwillingness to confront their fear of performing solo in front of others.

Little Violinist

When I was in the third grade I got a wild hair up my ass to learn to play the violin. I have absolutely no idea what possessed me to become enamored of this instrument, except perhaps the fact that it was smaller than I and had very beautiful curves, which I admired. The worn fuchsia crushed velvet that lined the beat-up old violin case in our closet only enchanted me more. I wanted this beautifully carved, voluptuous instrument to become part of my persona, and thus I joined the elementary school orchestra.

The orchestra — and I use that term loosely — was led by the great and powerful Mr. Walter James. I soon discovered to my horror that if a mistake were made, the offending child would be gruffly admonished in front of everyone and made to play the troublesome notes over and over until they had it down.

Now I had 3 strikes against me before I even picked up that violin and placed it under my chin (which by the way was extremely uncomfortable).

First and foremost, I was lazy. Learning came easily to me. As a result, I had no idea how to put effort into anything. “Practice makes perfect” was a completely foreign concept to me.

Secondly, the idea of being publicly shamed was horrific to me, and I was terrified of making a mistake.

Last but not least, I was not one to lay my ass on the line and risk looking foolish, no matter how tempting the reward. I was mercilessly teased by my big sister, and that was quite enough mocking for one little life.

I soon developed a strategy to ensure that I would not have to bear the brunt of Mr. James’ wrath.

As the violin section played, I held my bow a quarter of an inch above the strings.

I fingered the neck as I had been taught and swung my bow up and down enthusiastically, but not a peep came from my violin, and I was one of the few students never chastised by our fearless leader.

After quite a few weeks of playing air violin, I realized there was no actual necessity for practicing, since I wasn’t really making any noise. I continued to participate in the weekly orchestra practice, but now I just watched the other violin players and mimicked their fingering. When their bows went up, mine went up and when their bows came down, mine followed.

I couldn’t believe I was getting away with it. There was always the faint shadow of dread that I would be caught, but for the most part it was a good arrangement.

That is, until the fateful day that Mr. James announced we had progressed to the point that the following week we were all going to perform a solo.

Needless to say, that was the day I quit the school orchestra, never to return.

Music
Memoir
Humor
Recommended from ReadMedium